webnovel
avatar

Review Detail of Sigheti in Endbringer

Review detail

Sigheti
SighetiLv43yrSigheti

I believe I have been quite candid while writing this review. From what I’ve read, I have come to believe that you are the kind of mature, passionate writer that understands constructive criticism and will not be dissuaded by some honest feedback. I focused on what - in my best opinion - has the most need or potential for improvement, (in the hope to help you progress rather than simply sing you praise) certainly since I believe most could be resolved by finding a proper editor. I am convinced you have a clear idea and course of what you want to write, and how you want your story to go, but, personally, I find it very difficult to become immersed in the story and become engaged with the characters. This is, I believe, due to one main aspect: the structure of your sentences is quite poor. There is an absence of proper punctuation marks, misuse of vocabulary, and a lack of proper rhythm. Due to this, it becomes very tiresome for your reader to stay engaged; it is still possible to understand what you mean to write, but it does not inspire interest. I do, however, clearly recognise the work you put into this story, and hope I did not discourage or insult you by being so frank. Therefore, here are some of the aspects I did enjoy: Firstly the characters. They are charming and winsome, and while I often silently berated them for their naiveté, I must confess that it often added to their charm. The pacing of the story is properly done, and while the dialogue seems often a bit forced or stiff, it flows enough to be appealing to your reader. Overall, I find that your story has the potential to be more than it is now. And I know you will polish it into the gem it might be. I wish you all the best and a lot of fun writing your story.

altalt

Endbringer

Shionokami

Liked by 1 people

LIKE

Replies5

Ghassan_
Ghassan_Lv2Ghassan_

That's thoughtful of you.

Sigheti:I always attempt to tell the authors of the stories I read my thoughts on there work, certainly seeing that, as an author myself, I seldom recieve a comment. The sole reason I would not, would be because I believe it would not be appreciated. If I deem an author not mature enough to handle one person’s opinion, or honest feedback, then I won’t take the time to try and help them improve either.
Ghassan_
Ghassan_Lv2Ghassan_

Wow! this is a good and very honest review. I wish I could get this in novels. If you don't mind me asking, what could be the reason people read books, add to their library yet, do not comment? Have you ever done that? and if so, why?

Sigheti
SighetiLv4Sigheti

I always attempt to tell the authors of the stories I read my thoughts on there work, certainly seeing that, as an author myself, I seldom recieve a comment. The sole reason I would not, would be because I believe it would not be appreciated. If I deem an author not mature enough to handle one person’s opinion, or honest feedback, then I won’t take the time to try and help them improve either.

Ghassan_:Wow! this is a good and very honest review. I wish I could get this in novels. If you don't mind me asking, what could be the reason people read books, add to their library yet, do not comment? Have you ever done that? and if so, why?
Ghassan_
Ghassan_Lv2Ghassan_

Are you on the Webnovel forum? if so, you could join this group "Author's and Reader's thoughts" I can't really explain everything here but when you get there, you'll see the welcoming message and reason it was created

Sigheti:I always attempt to tell the authors of the stories I read my thoughts on there work, certainly seeing that, as an author myself, I seldom recieve a comment. The sole reason I would not, would be because I believe it would not be appreciated. If I deem an author not mature enough to handle one person’s opinion, or honest feedback, then I won’t take the time to try and help them improve either.
Sigheti
SighetiLv4Sigheti

It seems like a marvelous initiative.

Ghassan_:Are you on the Webnovel forum? if so, you could join this group "Author's and Reader's thoughts" I can't really explain everything here but when you get there, you'll see the welcoming message and reason it was created