webnovel
avatar

Review Detail of NebulousArcana in The Uchiha's in MHA 11111 (Has been moved)

Review detail

NebulousArcana
NebulousArcanaLv143yrNebulousArcana

Probably this fic's first actual review but whatever. Let's just do bullet points and knock this out. • OC and his lack of a personality • Background Characters aren't Characters • Not really adding anything to the world to make it unique • Lack of descriptive writing • Waste of potential - This rendition of the character doesn't exactly excite me to any degree and I've seen just about every one of his potential fights played out in other crappy fan-fics. His ego seems a tad bit more leveled than Bakou-b*tch's but thats only because he has a hype man that follows him around in every chapter doing the boasting for him. - Since Enjiro is the only 'person' besides the OC that you'll often see it's kinda sad that you got his character completely wrong, first off he dyes his hair red (naturally black), I don't remember him having any prior combat experiance before U.A and if he did it would be boxing. While he does respect strength and "manliness" it wouldn't be to fanatic levels of lunacy shown. Brief mentions; Aisawa wouldn't let the OC be a popus little sh*t and would knock him down a peg as early as entering the classroom, season 1 Bakou-b*tch would've leaped over people in danger to punch the OC in their first 'interaction' - Not really anything inherently different to set this MHA universe apart from the rest except another Madara Uchiha that still manages to fail miserably at being as cool as OG Madara even with all his powers. - Only the OC and Kirishima have actually gotten any physical descriptions (Note: I stopped reading at the 3rd to last chapter so it's possible someone or something was 'lucky' enough to have their eyes, hair or structure defined) - I've read a few Madara fan-fics and this one doesn't even make the top 50 list, the guy is just boring, he mentioned wasting his natrually born gift in his first life then manages to do it again in his second. And really there isn't an excuse for that type of fuckery other than letting readers know that yes he's stronger than All Might but other than raw fighting potential the guy isn't really cut out to be a hero. He doesn't have the charisma, drive nor values to be a proper hero so why is he at U.A? It's just a damn shame because if you could write someone compelling with those same abilities that actually trained to master them instead of a douchè bag with an 'that was easy button' being a hero just because he 'can' my review would be completely different. Just bring back Mineta atleast that perverted midget had goals (though holes they may be, actual goals all the same.)

altalt

The Uchiha's in MHA 11111 (Has been moved)

DaoistShinobi

Liked by 6 people

LIKE

Replies2

DaoistShinobi
DaoistShinobiAuthorDaoistShinobi

Thanks for your honest review! After re-reading my fan fiction I also came to this conclusion. I have started to develop the characters more. I have in the latest chapter given Madara a more defined goal and am working on his personality. Also I purposely changed it so that Kirishima is taking martial arts. Also, if you could read up to my new chapters and update your review (either up or down.). I would be most grateful! I really appreciate this and it gives me points to work on to help improve my writing. I really hope you will give it a second chance. Thank you!

NebulousArcana
NebulousArcanaLv14NebulousArcana

Edit: Invisible girl got described so not 2 characters but 3. OC has a goal, said goal is to be the best Madara he can be. (It's a fakeout goal that doesn't mean anything because he won't exactly change any of his behaviour. What I believe the author meant was that he would be living his life to the fullest extent with the given abilities he possesses and try to experiance the things he could not or didn't bother with in his first life) The most developed character up to date(chap 12) is the mother who's name I don't remember(if it was stated) Minor deviations in the plot and creating 1 other original character does not make this Madara Uchiha fan-fic unique. My original star rating will remain the same. *I couldn't exactly find a way to edit my review outside of asking for it to be deleted and making another so this is my middle ground*