Review Detail of Harem_fan in Harry Potter but AU???

Item: Harry Potter but AU???
Rating: 3

Review detail

Harem_fanLv53yrHarem_fan

First what I do not care for..I hate when writers make an HP fan fiction and make muggles and science BETTER than magic [Its like saying a nuke is better than a wish from God] it takes away from what JKR created. That said if you do not mind this mind set than its a good read, AUs are refreshing.

Harry Potter but AU???

DAFR

Liked by 18 people

Replies9

John_sins1Lv11John_sins1

No worries you haven’t been rude, we are just exercising our right to express what pleases us in a story and what doesn’t. Also the review is useful for people who have similar tastes to see whether they would enjoy the story or not. That way if they love the magic aspect of HP then they see this review amd know the story is not for them so they don’t waste time reading something they don’t find enjoyable!

DragonsRulez:I dont mean to be rude, but there are hundreds of HP fictions, it is not a rule that you must read all of them and even like them. If you dont like one a few days or a week later a new different one will appear that is how it is

3yr

John_sins1Lv11John_sins1

Preach good sir. Why bother writing a Harry Potter fanfiction if you are going to trash magic and focus on technology. Makes 0 sense. People read HP fanfiction for OP magic and potential witch waifus. Not technology bullshit, if i wanted that i would read some Star Trek bullshit

3yr

Harem_fanLv5Harem_fan

Food a fellow enlightened reader!

John_sins1:Preach good sir. Why bother writing a Harry Potter fanfiction if you are going to trash magic and focus on technology. Makes 0 sense. People read HP fanfiction for OP magic and potential witch waifus. Not technology bullshit, if i wanted that i would read some Star Trek bullshit

3yr

Pablo099Lv5Pablo099

Es para darle sentido y tener un sistema de poder como la magia controlado y manejando el progreso de poderes del prota.

3yr

LightOfCertainityLv4LightOfCertainity

My good sir,i dont agree with you,i think what the author was.trying to say is that by using a scientific mind,you can push magic to higher degree,afterall,knowledge without understanding,believe and magical intent is useless

3yr

Harem_fanLv5Harem_fan

Sure if what you said matched how I read the story I would believe your words...but thanks for trying.

LightOfCertainity:My good sir,i dont agree with you,i think what the author was.trying to say is that by using a scientific mind,you can push magic to higher degree,afterall,knowledge without understanding,believe and magical intent is useless

3yr

DragonsRulezLv4DragonsRulez

I dont mean to be rude, but there are hundreds of HP fictions, it is not a rule that you must read all of them and even like them. If you dont like one a few days or a week later a new different one will appear that is how it is

John_sins1:Preach good sir. Why bother writing a Harry Potter fanfiction if you are going to trash magic and focus on technology. Makes 0 sense. People read HP fanfiction for OP magic and potential witch waifus. Not technology bullshit, if i wanted that i would read some Star Trek bullshit

3yr

Lv4

I agree the part where astronomy is far behind muggles makes no sense.was a real turn off.

2yr

SrCuervoLv4SrCuervo

Hi, I'm SrCuervo and I'm writing an HP novel where your help would be very useful, I hope you can read it so you can tell me what you think. It's called Harry Potter: Narnia and The World Hidden in a Closet.

1yr