webnovel
avatar

Review Detail of WiLeYBiGhEaD in Reincarnation in One Piece: The Adventure of Ian Louis! [COMPLETE!]

Review detail

WiLeYBiGhEaD
WiLeYBiGhEaDLv113yrWiLeYBiGhEaD

Above average and entertaining, but not what you may expect and not for me. I have tried picking up this novel twice and have become disinterested twice (read until zou). It is well written for a fanfic without glaring grammer issues and the story takes a unique spin on the one peice world which is not easy given how many fanfics there are for it. However the author chose to wuxia the one peice world which always felt out of place to me. i.e. new power levels like emporer realm and saint realm are totally unnecessary in a world that has a very clearly defined power structure(especially when the author chooses to use both power structures to explain eachother when one is already enough). The other reason i became disinterested is the inconsistency of the mc’s power levels and the mc’s deus ex machina abilities. One chapter he is stronger than vice admirals but weaker than admirals and can barely hold his own. Then a few chapters later he is able to hold back 3 admirals, sengoku, and Garp without and power increase? The same with his abilities, which are just introduced when the author needs them, like healing, mind manipulation, increased gravity, etc, followed by a sentence how he learned that ability long ago but didnt use it because he didnt want to or was unable to yet. He recently told his crew about increasing his abilities through exotic DNA which they should not understand at all. DNA is known as the lineage factor in one peice and is something both new and not known to common people. It is the whole premise for the vinsmoke family arc, but his crew just casually understand this because they need to for the story. Overall, i enjoyed much of this story and many will not be bothered by what i mentioned. But for me the repetative deus ex machina moments for the mc have dulled any tension or interest i had.

altalt

Reincarnation in One Piece: The Adventure of Ian Louis! [COMPLETE!]

CrazyGuest

Liked by 52 people

LIKE

Replies5

CrazyGuest
CrazyGuestAuthorCrazyGuest

yeah, I don messed up lol, well I know it's a cluster **** but I'm committed to finishing it before attempting a new and hopefully better story!

WiLeYBiGhEaD
WiLeYBiGhEaDLv11WiLeYBiGhEaD

Nah its not that bad. Like i said, i enjoyed much of the story. It has a decent plot and character development for a fanfic. Just needed some more planning ahead i think as introducing those powers/abilities in an earlier chapter would have made sense. Your characters were fairly consistent in character and the mc was never nerfed for plot development (You did the opposite which is not as bad in my books((plot armor vs armor for the plot)))Your story was good enough for me to come back twice and i probably will again to see how it progressed as i am a sucker for this genre. Your fanfic is already above average, keep up the good work.

CrazyGuest
CrazyGuestAuthorCrazyGuest

Well, I can only say thank you then! :)

WiLeYBiGhEaD:Nah its not that bad. Like i said, i enjoyed much of the story. It has a decent plot and character development for a fanfic. Just needed some more planning ahead i think as introducing those powers/abilities in an earlier chapter would have made sense. Your characters were fairly consistent in character and the mc was never nerfed for plot development (You did the opposite which is not as bad in my books((plot armor vs armor for the plot)))Your story was good enough for me to come back twice and i probably will again to see how it progressed as i am a sucker for this genre. Your fanfic is already above average, keep up the good work.
EroFan
EroFanLv4EroFan

PLease tell me you will add boa Hancock to the harem

CrazyGuest:yeah, I don messed up lol, well I know it's a cluster **** but I'm committed to finishing it before attempting a new and hopefully better story!
Knived
KnivedLv10Knived

Ahh so its a generic chinesium fanfic. Got it.