webnovel
avatar

Review Detail of Fiona_Singer in The Arks

Review detail

Fiona_Singer
Fiona_SingerLv34yrFiona_Singer

The whole fiction gives me an impression of being an crystalized meteorite: otherworldly, mysterious, but also very hard and cold. The text is fairly well-versed and is given an hint of old-world English style, allowing it to perfectly blend into the story background, but not too much as in becoming a barrier to understand the plots. And the world setting is beautifully unique, kind of reminds me old-school soft sci-fi works like Doctor Who, combining the futuristic, advanced element of races and planets from outerspace, and the wonderous, colourful element of magic and epics together. The author clearly devoted lots of time and energy into building up this vast, fantasy world, and the writing style depicted the world vividly. However the characters and the story aren't so impressive, which is the part that gives me the "hard, cold" feeling. It's not that the design of the characters and the outline of the plots are bad--they can be quite good too if well processed--but the way author fleshes out the characters and narrates the plots are too abridged, to an extent that sometimes readers feel like the motivations of the actions of the character are too unclear, and the emotions are too thin. I guess it's partly because it's written in a somewhat traditional English style so it's a little obscure--this is more or less inevitable if you are not using modern, plain language, and I suppose it's the writing style that the author feels comfortable with, so let's skip this part. The other reason may be that so far most of the main characters are not human and the real humans seem more secondary and a symbol of ignorance and bullying (well because they are indeed and it's worse in Dark Ages). But the thing is, according to the standard of a fair literature work, it has to be able to appeal to the readers, and unfortunately your readers are emotional, sensational, messy humans (In a perfect world we will have Martian readers), and quite to the contrary, to make the non-human characters alive you need to spend EXTRA EFFORTS on depicting their emotions and motives, because they don't think like humans, so it will be much harder for readers to sympathize with them, especially when they are somewhat unkind and indifferent in human perspectives, like your MC, and the author will have to try extra hard to guide the readers to understand their feelings. From this angle I would strongly recommend the author to learn from Anne Rice's Vampire Chronicles: the blood-sucking monsters are very captivating in her texts, and she is masterful in describing the non-human sensations. Read how she built up the character Claudia, who is in my opinion very simliar to your MC, will be very helpful: she lost all her human family at a young age and was left alone until being turned to a vampire, and although she appears like a dolly child she was much older, and she was taught to be a vicious hunter and ruthless drinker from a young age--She's no kinder to humans, but still readers, whether like her or not, can feel her thoughts and moods, and she is very much alive on Rice's paper(in a vampiric way, at least). Not that if the author continued on like this, it would be bad, in general it's a very original and interesting work, and as the story unfolds and all the buried suspenses are uncovered, when people fully know the past and future of each character, we humans will understand why they did what they did, anyway. But still, if the author wanted to achieve a deeper sympathy between characters and readers where the latter would drop tears for the former, it's better to improve in this area.

altalt

The Arks

Mavislin11

Liked by 2 people

LIKE

Replies6

Fiona_Singer
Fiona_SingerLv3Fiona_Singer

Oh love the new cover btw ∠( ᐛ 」∠)_

Mavislin11
Mavislin11AuthorMavislin11

Great review, yes I am a whovian, so you'll see some relation. I'm aware of the feelings area that I lack of, will work on that in due time.

Mavislin11
Mavislin11AuthorMavislin11

You've got valeriex to thank, I love it as well

Fiona_Singer:Oh love the new cover btw ∠( ᐛ 」∠)_
Fiona_Singer
Fiona_SingerLv3Fiona_Singer

Me too XD Though I love all the doctors David Tenant's "I don't wanna go" is just so sad that first time I cried for half an hour TAT He's my favourite. Which kinda explained your writing style, too, cos I sorta feel like you are very much a world-builder rather than story-teller :)

Mavislin11:Great review, yes I am a whovian, so you'll see some relation. I'm aware of the feelings area that I lack of, will work on that in due time.
Mavislin11
Mavislin11AuthorMavislin11

Lul I have found mah new friend!! It's actually weird for me cause I'm hailing from Singapore, land of broken English.

Fiona_Singer:Me too XD Though I love all the doctors David Tenant's "I don't wanna go" is just so sad that first time I cried for half an hour TAT He's my favourite. Which kinda explained your writing style, too, cos I sorta feel like you are very much a world-builder rather than story-teller :)
Fiona_Singer
Fiona_SingerLv3Fiona_Singer

Well and I'm from China XDDD it doesn't matter, really

Mavislin11:Lul I have found mah new friend!! It's actually weird for me cause I'm hailing from Singapore, land of broken English.