webnovel
avatar

Review Detail of ClemCa in Rebirth Of The Urban Immortal Cultivator

Review detail

ClemCa
ClemCaLv134yrClemCa

Dropped after 45 chapters. Though I handled pretty fine the inconsistencies and the author hiding the mc's power with plot power despite him being literally the strongest of the world (that's no spoil), I discovered the author did huge mistakes explaining a cultivation system as basic as it can be. Basically a kid trying to write a novel like an *****. I would advise you to avoid it and instead spend you time reading something else. By the way, the mc is of a rare stupidity. Seeing how people coming from the comic praised it, I wanted to wait until chapter 100 or the premium to judge whether it was good, but I really couldn't hold on. If you like seeing common tropes being mishandled and overused however you should love this novel. 1 on everything but translation quality, which is pretty ok, with a 4

altalt

Rebirth Of The Urban Immortal Cultivator

Ten Miles Sword God

Liked by 17 people

LIKE

Replies14

Kayox23
Kayox23Lv5Kayox23

I can barely stand to those Wuxia novels where the MC offend all the peoples he encounter but it's barely passable when it's a Man Hua

LaoTze
LaoTzeLv14LaoTze

This makes me want to check out the Manhua, especially since it’s ahead of this novel

ClemCa
ClemCaLv13ClemCa

you can, I can't promise you won't be disappointed however

LaoTze:This makes me want to check out the Manhua, especially since it’s ahead of this novel
Kougetsu
KougetsuLv5Kougetsu

This novel was banned in China all works of this author have been removed from Qidian since January of 2019. The author already had a short hiatus, because of story problems back in April/May 2018 And stopped at chapter 1201. Since that hiatus he only managed to write 7 more chapters reaching 1208 before the novel got banned in January 2019. Stop spending SS for a novel that will never be finished. Please help spreading this Information. It's absolutely disgusting of webnovel to charge for a banned novel that will never finish!

Kougetsu
KougetsuLv5Kougetsu

This novel was banned in China all works of this author have been removed from Qidian since January of 2019. The author already had a short hiatus, because of story problems back in April/May 2018 And stopped at chapter 1201. Since that hiatus he only managed to write 7 more chapters reaching 1208 before the novel got banned in January 2019. Stop spending SS for a novel that will never be finished. Please help spreading this Information. It's absolutely disgusting of webnovel to charge for a banned novel that will never finish!

ClemCa:you can, I can't promise you won't be disappointed however
Kougetsu
KougetsuLv5Kougetsu

This novel was banned in China all works of this author have been removed from Qidian since January of 2019. The author already had a short hiatus, because of story problems back in April/May 2018 And stopped at chapter 1201. Since that hiatus he only managed to write 7 more chapters reaching 1208 before the novel got banned in January 2019. Stop spending SS for a novel that will never be finished. Please help spreading this Information. It's absolutely disgusting of webnovel to charge for a banned novel that will never finish!

LaoTze:This makes me want to check out the Manhua, especially since it’s ahead of this novel
Joshua_Lee_5926
Joshua_Lee_5926Lv2Joshua_Lee_5926

Woah, you read 45 chapters out of a thousand+ chapters novel and then said it was trash and rated it one star. Just so you know this novel was the Number 1 book in the entire urban category on qidian out of almost 400,000 other novels. I wonder why?

ClemCa
ClemCaLv13ClemCa

Because it used all the popular tropes of the time. Shit can be popular too, especially if it is heavily promoted in the midst of industry growth. Even now, looking back at it, even reviews further into it point out the entire novel is a repetition of what I read over and over again. It could probably be okay if you didn't know anything about cultivation tropes, don't mind inconsistencies and illogism.

Joshua_Lee_5926:Woah, you read 45 chapters out of a thousand+ chapters novel and then said it was trash and rated it one star. Just so you know this novel was the Number 1 book in the entire urban category on qidian out of almost 400,000 other novels. I wonder why?
Joshua_Lee_5926
Joshua_Lee_5926Lv2Joshua_Lee_5926

dude are you kidding? you literally read 45 chapters out of a 1000+ chapters novel. I bet you don't even know 1% of the story. how can you even judge what the novel is like.

ClemCa:Because it used all the popular tropes of the time. Shit can be popular too, especially if it is heavily promoted in the midst of industry growth. Even now, looking back at it, even reviews further into it point out the entire novel is a repetition of what I read over and over again. It could probably be okay if you didn't know anything about cultivation tropes, don't mind inconsistencies and illogism.
Joshua_Lee_5926
Joshua_Lee_5926Lv2Joshua_Lee_5926

this is probably one of the best cultivation novels on this site.

ClemCa:Because it used all the popular tropes of the time. Shit can be popular too, especially if it is heavily promoted in the midst of industry growth. Even now, looking back at it, even reviews further into it point out the entire novel is a repetition of what I read over and over again. It could probably be okay if you didn't know anything about cultivation tropes, don't mind inconsistencies and illogism.
ClemCa
ClemCaLv13ClemCa

I strongly doubt it. It had the worst start I read on this platform, and it follows a quick downward trend. If I had even a bit of hope for a turnaround, I wouldn't have dropped it within 100 chapters.

Joshua_Lee_5926:this is probably one of the best cultivation novels on this site.
Joshua_Lee_5926
Joshua_Lee_5926Lv2Joshua_Lee_5926

if you read a couple hundred chapters and dropped it then that would be valid. but reading 45 chapters is basically the same as not reading at all because you have practically zero understanding of the overall story.

ClemCa:I strongly doubt it. It had the worst start I read on this platform, and it follows a quick downward trend. If I had even a bit of hope for a turnaround, I wouldn't have dropped it within 100 chapters.
Joshua_Lee_5926
Joshua_Lee_5926Lv2Joshua_Lee_5926

r u really going to trust someone who read 45 out of a 1000+ chapters novels. just so you know this novel is ranked number 1 in the entire urban category on qi. and qi had thousands of times more novels then webnovel so it's much more competitive than this site.

Kayox23:I can barely stand to those Wuxia novels where the MC offend all the peoples he encounter but it's barely passable when it's a Man Hua
ClemCa
ClemCaLv13ClemCa

The first chapters are what set the tone of the story. It's possible for a turnaround to have happened 200 chapters later, but I don't have time to waste reading any more chapters this trashy.

Joshua_Lee_5926:if you read a couple hundred chapters and dropped it then that would be valid. but reading 45 chapters is basically the same as not reading at all because you have practically zero understanding of the overall story.