The art for this book is impressive to say the least. Every man is sexy, every woman is beautiful. Even the backgrounds and side characters are eyecatching. Clearly great care and love was put into the art, and I commend the artist on this achievement. The story... Maybe it's the translation, but the story seemed all over the place, disjointed, and difficult to follow. The arcs were highly episodic, and they didn't truly seem related except by a thin shred composed of one small piece of the overarching plot. Speaking of the overarching plot...this story is unfinished. I kept reading because I wanted to see what happened with Master and Phoenix (and Wei Wei and Dragon Throne to a lesser extent). Both of these plot lines are entirely unresolved by the last chapter. It's a *massive* disappointment. Since that was my main reason for hanging in there through some truly baffling and convoluted story twists, I feel like I wasted my time and coins. I never got to read the end of the main story or the main substory, so what was the point? There wasn't one. Total let down. Would not recommend the story except for the art. If it actually had conclusions to the main story lines, I'd rate it higher but here's the breakdown as is out of 5 possible stars Art: 6. it gets a bonus star for being so gorgeous. I can not overemphasize the delight or praise this element enough. Plot: 2. It twisted and turned in ways that weren't clear or appealing. The mini arcs were almost stand alone stories that barely served to push the main story any further. Characterization: 4. The characters were well developed and each had a unique and discernible personality. They added to the enjoyment of the book overall. Romantic Progression: 1. By the end, it felt like almost nothing had happened to substantially move the ml and fl closer together. Any gains seemed almost entirely forgotten just a few pages later. The mystery was built up slowly but never solved. The side ships managed a little better, but, all told, those romances were also inconclusive after 112 chapters. If you read the first 20-40 chapters, you see all of them about as far as they'll go by the end. General: 2. Would not recommend except to appreciate the art. Spend coins elsewhere. On a related note, anyone else thoroughly irritated and put off by "completed" books that aren't really? Can writers *please* start finishing their works with *actual* endings instead of just giving up and acting like being defeated by their own works is completion? Just saying.

Absolutely delightful. This was a fun romp through teenage emotions that didn't irritate me or make me want to put it down due to overly stupid characters even one time. I just binged the whole thing cover to cover and was still sad when it was over. The characters are mostly typical teenagers. The story develops at a good pace. The art is very enjoyable, and every guy in the book is smoking hot, (including fl's dad lol). Highly recommend l!

It was so good, and then it just ended abruptly with no conclusion or closure. Pretty much right in the middle of the story. I wish I didn't spend coins on a deceptively incomplete work. The author even teased some stuff for the next chapter that now we'll never see. Super huge disappointment. 1 star or story development because the story failed to properly develop to the end. Otherwise it would be a 5 star story.

This was the first manhua I ever fell in love with. I was glued to my phone for days obsessively reading through it. Feeling all kinds of ways about it. I wanted to hate Aotian. With every fiber of my being, I wanted to, but he makes it impossible. I've been searching for one like this ever since I finished it, but haven't found one even close. This title has that special something, and I feel like it's ruined me for other modern romance, CEO titles. I just wish they'd start updating it regularly again.

easily the best manhua I've ever read. I can't think of anything about it that I didn't like. It was cute, dramatic, compelling, beautiful...so many things. Highly, highly recommend it.

Cute story. Fl is dumb as a box of rocks and that can get annoying, but she's still cute and lovable enough not to hate her. Translation gets iffy in areas, and some of it does not suit the atmosphere of the setting ("Roger that" is used multiple times, for example). Overall, decent, and it managed to end decently allbeit questionably with regard to...standard ethics and...certain legislations...(you'll see when you get there 😬). Overlooking the cringe factor, the ends were cute, and one actually brought tears to my eyes (so tragic😭). I enjoyed this comic. I'd give it a solid A 🙂