I will probably comment on every chapter that he is just Stupid, and it does not make sense that he is that way, she was trained in management, she was supposed to be the heir to all that wealth, why does he think she is stupid? Couldn't he tell her he wants her to do the duchess duties, and from where is his misunderstanding that she is lazy, she was the HEIR of the business empire... He probably lost their business to protect them from the emperor because it would be a threat, but then why marry her, and not some poor noble....he is just an a****** and he didn't even tell her, that her family business is gone, he has 0 respect for her....maybe she should just became the emperor, the 2 most powerful men in this empire are both hatefull, she sould team up with the empress and destroy them.

Omg so he really is just stupid, I really can't accept it, how can he have a good reason to be so stupid, also if she wanted wealth she had a TON of property so why would she need him, and he says she had the honour of archduchess but she does not have the right to administer the house.....she was not yet that evil so why does he have so little trust?....all she even wanted was to be a normal wife and she did ask him by doing all her advances. ..you are telling me an super duper famous smart duke can be this stupid ? how can she manage her businesses if he is so stupid. ....why did he never ask her what she wants?.....why does he think she wants to be a virgin for life what is his excuse for that!!!???

I will slowly :((.....but that is exactly what my fear is, the justification for his actions should not be enough to make him a good enough character for her, he is an *****, even if he had a shitty childhood and even if other shitty things happened to him it does not justify harming an innocent person, and maybe he thinks she is not innocent but if that is so he never gave her the benefit of the doubt, to see for himself if she is a good person....in conclusion he is just soooo hateful, and i can see this is going for him being the ML, even though i hope i am surprised later to find out he is not, still and abusing relationship, and i just can't accept her to be with him......also for people to change they need to lose things, if he won't lose her for good , I don't think it's realistic for him to change...... The only 2 justification i can think of is that he is cruel or stupid, he is cruel if he did it because he misunderstood that she did some nasty stuff to marry him....or he is stupid and really does not realise how much of a f***ing jerk he is, but he is supposed to be this smart duke so that should not make sense or maybe he thinks she killed his ex, but then why marry her, or just take her to prison , or did he just belive that without evidence and that goes back to him being stupid......anyway i could have accepted if he was a reasonable amount of cold to her in the past but he was not reasonable........

He is still so hatefull, and isn't this trope of "the duke that treated me coldly but actully, never hated me so in this life i will still forgive him... can't we wish for her to be happy without some stupid hatefull man, that not only took advantage of her wealth but he did not even have the decency to treat her with respect..... and no it does not make sense for him to have that low EQ beause, their house should be good in administration, he should know how to read people and he should know that if he does not kiss her on the weading day, he does not go to parties with her, or even look at her then she will not live well, and not be respected in their circle, really his stupidity is so frustrating......and i see that the author does not want us to hate him so then is is probably the ML, but just no, she is better of alone then this jerk!!!!... and yes i know she wants a kid and I wish that for her, but honestly he does not diserve a happy ending and i just hope she and Killian will live happly while he suffers because he was a jerk in the past

Is Rosa stealing Freddys way of "teaching"? yes, yes she is :))

Best moments are of worrying Amar, he notices so fast that something is wrong with Rosa and the apples, and also instructs Yuna to take Rosa away from gore:)) Second best is Rosa saying that she can do more to help them..... Point of view of Lukas, a crazy rumbeling Lukas that in his Adhd mind knows a lot of inner secrets of Rosa and Amar, the trick is if you can figure it out :))) Author-nim please give us some recomandations of some books that you enjoy, nothing can best Unloved twin, but if you can write this good surely you have some good recomendations, pretty pleeeeaseee ^^

I actually hope he does not reincarnate, I hope to see Rosa move past her past and learn from her mistakes, maybe accept and grieve for her loss....(not a conventional happy ending but a more truthfull ending as in real life, if we lose someone we lose the,m forever and what we have to do is move past it).......anyway I wouldn't mind even if he reincarnates, I trust author-sama to do a good job in anything she imagines in this story <3

The line is breaking, slowly but her guard is slipping away <3 will she soon have to face the truth of herself?

ahah, slowly everyone is loosing their sanity, in the good way:))...just what kind of mess would they make of they had a baby brother <3

Haha, Freddy really just wants to be a good father and get a nice thank you from Rosa:)))

That is some good sense of smell:))

Soon everybody will have a crush for him, muahhahaha :)) He is great so why wouldn't people like him?

Is the thing with salt making fruits sweeter real? who even discovered that?.....so Rosa is only oblivios for Ron and Gabel and not everyone, good to know:)) Georgie is good looking, caring, funny and a good cook who wouldn't want him? Poor Vincent almost dying because of Rosa, I hope slowly he manages to fight his anxiety and wish for death, I want only good things for my poor baby Vincent <3 Lovely chapter ^^

Omg yey <3

Good point, but I don't think the warnnings are necesarly bad, I just anticipate more and want to read more...

At least she has very good teachers, even if this ruins her plans:))

I can't wait to find out more about the creepy doll, did it get attached to Rosa so she changed her hair colour? also she is probably just trying to be helpfull, she did signal the ambush to Amar and company when they where on the road, so good creepy doll? Did not expect the prison, but well it fits with Freddys character....people should be carefull when befriending Rosa.....I wander how would have Maria reacted if she discoverd Amar in the cell, Freddy should thank Amar that he disapeard before that. Also Rosalia actually spent time in her own prisons!!! to improve them, that is some serios dedication:))) Yey for unexpected fast chapter <3

Btw will we see Vincent being all shy next chapter, because Georgie is there? or maybe worried, well anything with the two?

I truly believe you bring yourself down too much, "your clumsy" attempt is just too good to be called clumsy, I love your story so much, to the point that it is disapointing to read most other stories....it's frustrating because Rosa doesn't talk much, but at the same point that is what real trauma does...the rest of the characters too, everyone is fuc**d up just like in real life, it's also nice to see how they evolve and grow....anyway you are really doing a very good job, considering how many clues you leave in earlier chapters I cannot agree that what you do is clumsy, quite the opposite 🥰

The trauma is certainly agravating, but that is what makes this story so good and real, I don't think it's too much, you don't necessarlly expect it from the discription, but as you read a few chapters you realise just how ****ed up Rosalia is, so it's natural that as the story goes on we just find out more broken things......anyway what a good chapter, I always end up wanting more and more...love your story <3