Enormiity

You be like:

That's Funny, you think that i can't think for myself, While you don't even read the deeper meanings of things. You thought that my statement is mostly random while it's point by point proof of my argument. For example you think that FUG is in control of getting the Thorn and what not while Like Madoroko (Forget his name) said to Gustang is S2, That Gustang let FUG & Workshop take the thorn, Every single one of FUG plan regarding Bam failed without any Outside Interference. Luslec and Hwa Ryun are not as good as you think they are. And you still have problems thinking that the other Factions are just extra showing how you know nothing about geopolitics and war. Maybe you need to reread TOG and actually comprehend the story rather than just reading the dialogue.

Counter argument: (1) Your first point, sure V is inside Bam, But It's Not "FUG" in its entirety that supports V nearly nobody in the Tower knows about V and Arlene. V is Luslec God not the whole FUG. FUG would definitely want another Irregular joining them, Ha Jingsung himself said that he would do whatever it takes if it means Urek Join (in S2 if i remember correctly). FUG ≠ Luslec, Luslec is just fUG first Slayer, Luslec is V most loyal followers but he doesn't control FUG as a president otherwise the whole BS with Bam asking Yama (Slayer) help won't happen, FUG = Multiple Faction with Same Goal, Luslec is just a leader of his Faction (V Loyalist). (2) Your second point is a joke in itself, Luslec is not an Irregular. He can't control his or anyone Destiny, His plan in Traumerei Event fails miserably and he Only survived because Arie let him leave, Traumerei only used him and Enkidu as someone to Blame regarding Ameuz. He only survived and Escaped Urek (First time) because Urek doesn't take him seriously. He only Survived so far because the one that actually controlled DESTINY (Irregular) let him be either by looking down on him or because he was their companion while climbing the tower. The one manipulating / directing Bam is not Luslec it's V and Arlene (We probably will know this soon if SIU focused on V POV), V uses Luslec as his pawn while he was out (There is a high Chance that V tells Luslec his plan). The same way V uses Gustang to stop his Friends bickering / to judge them on their argument. If you still don't get it (ONLY IRREGULAR CONTROL FATE) Luslec ≠ Irregular ≠ Controling Fate. (The Administrator probably Helped V and in extension Him). For the "so What if there is another faction in FUG?", What a dumb question, Luslec is a Slayer sure he is stronger than Karaka or Yama but what about the rest, obviously he need other Faction in FUG why would he makes 11 seat for Slayer spot, FUG is already weak as it's (Without V, and V probably will be gone in the next Arc/Two), That Other Faction in FUG is their "Allies" it detters other weak Faction to go against them(FUG is public enemy number 1 afterall). Those other Factions (6 Other Slayer, and Elders) is their Combatants and resources. Which is Why Luslec needs to play nice with the other Slayer until his leader V is awoken. (3) Guide can't do shit to Irregular, The one time we see a Guide going against an Irregular is Khel (Elder) and his Group trying to kill sleeping Zahard (In His Vision), but when he was there Zahard is waiting for them, that is how useless Guide vision against an irregular, and your own argument proved that they can only see the path but the path can change because of their actions. Hwaryun never "pulled the string", Hwaryun has a lot of Connection with FUG elder (Like Sophia) and Luslec, the one that pulls the string is them, she is simply there so she can help Bam pick his path, she never went against Bam. The only confirmed Guide going against Irregular is Khel, and both times he Failed (Against king Zahard, regular Bam). Matter of Fact if Issac decides to kill Bam before V awoken there is nothing She / Luslec can do, she probably doesn't even see Issac existence in her original Vision.

Everything i said there has a purpose and is connected, i don't know about the contradicting part (Say it here, i will say that it probably is not), it's a mess because Webnovel doesn't have any Text Structuring for Comment and Review. "It's Mostly Assumption" obviously it's mostly assumptions currently there is not enough data to make a clear picture of things. List here what is Correct in certain circumstances but wrong in general, and i will prove it otherwise or admit that i am wrong if i was wrong.

These are random pieces of Information because that is all we have, TOG world building is Fragmented you never get a full picture. Everything i said there is based on Canon Information. You already know this information yet you still think that an irregular is a mere secondary weapon, you always implied that FUG is a singular force while every single slayer we see (4 out of 7) has their own agenda, Elder tries to dethrone a Slayer for his own goal. Bam barely gets stuff from FUG because he doesn't have any good weapons or inventory, the only FUG member confirmed to give Bam something is Jinsung Ha (He gave bam Clothes and Spent Billions Points to buy Kaiser, but he is an outlier since he gave Karaka his/her armor). Every single one of FUG's plans so far happened because stronger Force let them happen (The Administrator let Bam Fake his death, help him escape Kallavan by sending Evankhell), (Gustang let Baam have his Thorn, let them (FUG, Workshop) get the Thorn from FOD since he built the system there, let Karaka & White lives, save the entire FUG army escape by visiting Traumerei home).

Another irregular will never be another weapon, It's their God. Irregular > Anybody else. Hell i am sure if Urek chooses to go against Zahard most FUG will join him. A guide is useless when an Irregular is involved. Every faction in FUG counts, Luslec is not that strong and we don't know much about the rest of the Slayer and Elder, FUG is the weakest Faction in the Tower simply because they don't have an Irregular leader. There is also a problem with the "They will only give it to him (Bam)" part, They tried to kill Bam by melting him with the Thorn to give another Slayer a weapon capable of killing The 10 Family Head. And they can do that because Gustang allowed it to happen. Before "He" takes control Issac will always be a better choice for FUG, assuming Issac joins FUG (He still gains nothing from doing so since non Irregular Shinsu technique is worthless, and FUG never gave bam anything if i remember correctly, it's just Jingsung Ha that does it). FUG don't follow Leslec every whim most FUG members will just do whatever their respective Elder / Slayer wants, while the Elder / Slayer plot between themselves for power.

Issac is an Irregular, if he joins willingly and since he is already strong right now FUG would just give him everything so that he won't leave. Why would they risk an Irregular leaving their side, they probably will betray (melt) bam with the thorn and give it to Issac as weapon since between the 2 irregular one is already way stronger than the other.

Luslec and his followers are the ones supporting bam (Because Luslec knows "who" and "what" bam really is), other Slayer / Elder has their own agenda. Canon 'FUG' only started supporting Bam after he beat a Ranker as A Regular.

It's ripping off One Piece, it's a Fanfiction that is illegal the moment the original author wanted it. But there is a big difference between "What IFs" and complete AU using the already popular story. Sure there is more to One Piece than Luffy's story (Although Luffy Time is the Climax of the World as we know now), and my Original comment never said the FF should follow Luffy and Co just that it should be in Luffy Timeline (Like the OG of this story if i remember correctly).

I Literally read more than you on this site alone not counting everywhere else. My Standards for these types of things are already high. Complete AU is always a cheap writing trick since anything goes and the principle of "canon" doesn't matter since it's completely different, it's a disgusting cheap trick where you create a new story using the original story popularity (Just make a new book at that point). For this story specifically One Piece is a story where the Climax of the World is In Luffy Era, Roger pirates reach the End of the Journey but they can only Laugh because it's not time yet. The perfect FF will happen in Canon Timeline as its own "Story" that affects the Original Story, a little bit of AU is fine to develop your fanfiction "world" but a complete AU like this story is bad since it uses whatever is popular but not respecting the original world building.