A Bit of Blackmail (Evangelion)

A/N: A Bit of Blackmail was a commissioned one shot originally written back in October of 2020. Posting it up here and now for people to enjoy!

Themes: Blackmail, Rough Sex, Mild Hate Sex

-x-X-x-

His life was over. Or at least, that was what Shinji had assumed at first, when Asuka had caught him masturbating over Rei's sleeping form. Not just masturbating… he grimaces in remembrance of the moment, at the height of his pleasure, as his cum had arced through the air, the door to the room had opened and Asuka's gasp had alerted him to her sudden presence with soul-chilling alacrity.

She'd watched him cum on Rei's body with a hand over her mouth, and then a moment later ran away. Shinji had just stood there for a moment, dick in hand, knowing without a doubt that it was over. She would tell someone, of course. Why wouldn't she? And then he would… he would be imprisoned. Rightfully so.

For a beat, Shinji had considered going to the roof and throwing himself off of it. In the end, the depressed young man had only decided otherwise because it felt like an escape, like he was avoiding his rightful punishment. Better to take whatever they ultimately decided to do to him. He deserved nothing less. And so, he'd gone back to his room and… waited. He'd waited for them to come for him.

They never had. Eventually, he'd fallen asleep without eating dinner, only to wake up in the morning with a hunger in his belly and a note slipped under his bed. The note had told him to come to Asuka's room later in the day, once Misato was out. So, after getting some breakfast, that was what Shinji was doing. He figured he deserved at least this much, a last meal before he went to his execution.

Approaching Asuka's door, Shinji knocks, swallowing thickly. After a moment, he hears her voice.

"Come in."

Opening the door, he steps inside and closes it behind him before looking to where Asuka is. Sat on the end of her bed in her yellow sundress, the brunette Evangelion Pilot has her legs crossed and is resting on her palms as she stares at him, seemingly studying him.

"Hello, Shinji."

He flinches at her deadpan tone of voice. They both know that she knows what she knows. She saw what she saw. The only question is, what is she going to do about it? Also, why hasn't she done it already?

"You're a filthy pervert. I knew it from the moment we met. I suppose it's nice to have it confirmed though."

Asuka makes a show of inspecting her nails as she speaks, every word a blow to Shinji's soul, making the poor young man shrink in on himself a little further. There's a beat of silence, and then she looks at him again.

"Well? Show me it."

Blinking, confused, Shinji is befuddled as he stares at his fellow pilot.

"W-What?"

Growling, Asuka points down at his crotch.

"Take it out and show me what we're working with."

At his look of complete disbelief, the brunette lets out a sharp laugh.

"Here's the deal, Shinji. You owe me. I could ruin you; I could see you imprisoned for what you've done. But I'm not going to. Instead, you're going to do exactly what I tell you, when I tell you. I'm a growing young woman who needs to learn about sex, if I'm ever to have a chance of properly seducing Kaji. I have to start somewhere, so you'll have to do. Now… take it out."

Not seeing much choice in the matter, Shinji reaches down and frees his cock from its confines. As it flops out, Asuka's breath hitches. She stares at it, and Shinji blushes and looks away in embarrassment. Truthfully, her words were NOT that arousing. He didn't get off on being belittled or told what to do, despite his depressive state, despite his nonexistent ego.

But Asuka was still a cute girl who he'd had a crush on for a while now. Just being in her presence, just having her tell him they were going to have s-sex is causing Shinji to pop the start of a boner.

"Oh wow… bigger than I expected. Come here."

Was that a compliment? Frankly, he didn't know. He didn't know whether size was good or bad, whether he was bigger or smaller than average. He didn't know anything except that masturbating felt good. Still blushing, Shinji walks over, only for Asuka to reach out and grab hold of his cock the moment she's in range. He winces as she tugs on it, and she immediately notices.

"Does it hurt if I'm too rough? I suppose I need to be gentler then… I wouldn't want Kaji to think I'm inexperienced."

… He hated that she kept mentioning the older man. Still, her grip on his cock changes, and while it's still undeniably inexperienced, she's a bit softer in her touch. That, combined with how soft and smooth her palm is to begin with, causes him to quickly grow harder and thicker in her hand.

"O-Oh my… you must really like it, huh?"

"… I like you…"

He can't help the words as they slip out of his mouth. Asuka's eyes flash up to meet his for a moment, before she looks down again. In his own embarrassment, Shinji completely fails to see the blush that spreads across his fellow pilot's face as she stares at his cock, continuing to stroke it experimentally.

"… This is just a transaction. I won't tell anyone what you did to Rei, and you'll do whatever I say… that said, men like to be in control, don't they?"

Shinji blinks at that, before deciding to answer truthfully.

"I… don't know."

Snorting, Asuka grins lazily.

"Of course you don't. Well, I do. I know all about men. I certainly know what sort of man Kaji is. I bet he's rough. I bet he's forceful. I need to learn how to be the kind of woman he'd want. That's where you come in."

His cock now fully erect in her hand, twitching and throbbing painfully, Shinji grits his teeth.

"… What do you want from me, Asuka?"

Looking him in the eye again, Asuka licks her lips.

"I want you to fuck me, Shinji. Not make love to me. Not caress and hold me. Certainly, don't just jerk off onto my body. I want you to take me, pin me down, and have your way with me. I need to prove I can take it… and if I can't, I need to know so I can put in the effort to make sure I can. Is that understood?"

Shinji's mouth is paradoxically dry and watering as he stares down at Asuka, unsure if he should believe his ears or not.

"You… want me to fuck you?"

Asuka just raises an eyebrow at him, distinctly unimpressed.

"That's what I said, isn't i-eep!"

Before she can finish her question, Shinji is on top of her. Pushing her back onto the bed, pinning her down, he finds himself looming over her, wide-eyed. His cock flops out of her hand and onto the front of her sundress as he holds her by her wrists.

"Like… like this?"

This time, Shinji sees Asuka's blush. The brunette squirms for a moment, clearly discomfited, before coming to terms with the fact that this was exactly what she asked of him.

"Y-yes… don't stop now. You're off to a great start, you just have to-eek!"

Like a man possessed (and Shinji certainly possesses of a LOT of pent-up aggression and emotion) he reaches out and grabs at her sundress, pulling it roughly up the length of her body. It rips and tears in more than one place as he pulls it over her head with some belated help from Asuka herself. Ultimately, he bunches up the garment and tosses it across the room, only to stop and stare down at her naked body.

She wasn't wearing anything under the dress. Was she just as much of a pervert as he was, or had she simply been prepared for what was going to happen here today? Either way, his cock is now resting against her pussy lips. She's a little wet, and her slit is spreading to ride up along his shaft, even as Shinji fixates on Asuka's exposed chest, her small breasts each capped with a pink nipple standing out in front of him.

Like a starving man, he falls upon his fellow pilot's tits, grabbing at them and feasting upon them with his mouth. He's none too gentle, and Asuka whimpers as his teeth nibble and gnaw at her titflesh in an inexperienced manner. He doesn't have any better of an idea of what he's doing then she does, truth be told, but… well, she did give him blanket permission, did she not?

Even still, as her whimpers turn into whines and gasps of pain, Shinji finds himself pausing, slowing down, worried that he's hurting her, that he's going too far. Lifting his head, he meets Asuka's eyes to find her red-faced and panting for breath. But the moment he looks to her, her resolve firms up.

"K-Keep going. This is probably exactly what Kaji wo-mmph!"

He surprises even himself, when he silences her by covering her mouth with his hand, his fingers curling around and gripping at her jaw. Gritting his teeth, he decides not to take it back, instead glaring down at her as he uses his other hand to position his cock at her lower entrance.

"Shut up about Kaji. Here's a tip, Asuka… men don't like to hear about other men when they're fucking you."

And then he thrusts in. She's a virgin, of course. So is he. The first thrust is painful for both of them, but Shinji is too turned on to care. Asuka, meanwhile, squeals like a stuck pig, but thanks to his hand, it doesn't go anywhere. Once he's inside of her, Shinji does stop for a moment, letting her adjust. He doesn't let go of her face though, and they maintain eye contact the entire time. Eventually, something flickers in her eyes and Asuka nods to him. Whether it's in acknowledgment of what he's said or whether she's telling him to start moving… Shinji decides to take it as both.

Hardly able to believe his own cockiness, the young man nevertheless seizes the opportunity presented to him. Letting go of Asuka's jaw, he grabs her by the arms instead at first… and then her chest. Her breasts feel like a much better place for his hands, as he begins to thrust in and out of her. It takes a few times for it to start to feel good, for Asuka's juices to really start flowing, but eventually the friction and lubrication manage to reach a more pleasurable equilibrium.

Shinji doesn't hold back. Asuka didn't want him to, and frankly even if she did, even if she was begging him to stop, he's not sure he'd be able to. Instead, he positively mauls her breasts as he fucks her harder and faster by the moment. He can't say for sure if his cock is big compared to other men or not, but it's certainly big enough for Asuka's virgin cunt, which is stretched wider and wider around his member as he thrusts deeper and deeper.

"J-Just like that, Shinji! D-Don't stop! H-Harder! F-Fuck me harder!"

"Shut up! Just shut up and fucking TAKE IT!"

Shinji growls as he picks up the pace again, provoking a loud cry from Asuka. He doesn't even realize at first that she's actually crying out because she's cumming on his cock. He's too busy being grateful that they waited until Misato was gone to do this. He puts two and two together soon enough though, as her cry lasts a while, and her body shakes and spasms beneath him.

At the same time, he can feel juices flowing down the length of his cock, even as her inner walls clench down like a vice grip around his member. He doesn't let that stop him though, in fact he speeds up even more. Shinji Ikari has a LOT of pent-up aggression to let out… and Asuka Langley has effectively offered herself up to be his fuck toy for who knows how long.

Of course, he's not so far gone that he can't tell he's getting closer to cumming, a little while later. By that point, Asuka has cum thrice around his cock if he's not mistaken. The brunette Evangelion pilot is looking distinctly disheveled and sweaty, her skin covered in red marks and bites from where he'd laid hands on her or taken his teeth to her. She looks… honestly, she looks amazing. Like a work of art that HE made.

At the same time though, he knows better than to cum inside without permission. Asuka still holds his life in her hands. Even still, he's not willing to give up totally on the idea, so with a loud groan, he warns her.

"I'm g-getting close, Asuka!"

She takes a moment to register his words, and another moment to respond. When she does, he's already dangerously close to the edge. In the end, her response is what sends him right over it.

"I-Inside! I'm on birth control… I need to learn to take creampies like a good little s-slut!"

'For Kaji' goes unsaid, but Shinji can still practically hear it. It makes him go just a bit rougher in the end, growling into Asuka's ear as he thrusts into her one final time, banging up against her cervix somewhat brutally before letting loose inside of her. Asuka whimpers in pain and discomfort, but also moans wantonly as he fills her up.

Then it's over. Shinji pulls out and isn't sure what to do next. Asuka lays before him, properly fucked sideways and sprawled out, her limbs akimbo as her reddened breasts, littered in his teeth marks, rise and fall with every heaving breath she makes. She stares up at him, and he stares back at her… honestly, just looking at her makes him want to go again, and his cock grows hard once more, right then and there. Asuka's eyes flicker down to it and go wide.

"Y-You're… still hard?"

She wanted to learn to handle a man's needs, didn't she? So Shinji would be doing her a disservice if he didn't… make her accommodate him, right? Licking his lips, Shinji climbs back onto the bed, grabbing hold of Asuka's hips as she makes an abortive attempt to back away.

"Yeah… yeah I am…"

He flips her over onto her front and yanks her up onto her hands and knees. For a moment, he hesitates, waiting for her to tell him to get off, to tell him to go away. But in the end… she hangs her head in silence and just lets him do what he will. So, he sticks it back in and fucks her. His cock slides in and out far faster with the previous load of cum to act as lubrication. Reaching forward, Shinji grabs a fistful of Asuka's hair and pulls, causing her to grunt and mewl in pain as he plows her from behind.

… If this was what she wanted, then he'd give it to her. After all, she held all the cards, didn't she? Something akin to a grin spreads across Shinji's face as he fucks Asuka from behind, faster and faster by the moment. He's never felt lighter, never felt freer. Being blackmailed by Asuka… he could get used to this.

-x-X-x-

If you'd like to read more of my work not seen on this website, check out Hentai-Foundry.com and QuestionableQuesting.com where I have over a thousand stories! I'm known as 'Cambrian' on those websites.

If you'd like to contribute to funding my writing at all, check me out on P atreon.com/Cambrian

Thanks for reading!