Review Detail of Syahrul_Azhar in Are you kidding me

I am a muslim and no I won’t change the MC’s religion because I am writing to make people understand that Muslims can also have humor, charisma and many other aspects to them than just being viewed as terrorists. I could have chosen a Hindu, Jewish, Christian or other religion but no one would have been offended but only when I use muslim you complain. And honestly I am thankful to you because I can say what I am feeling and it will be accessible for all to read... I have not written anything offensive against Islam so why are you feeling offended furthermore Islam doesn’t belong to anyone because it is “Allahs religion” and I think your sentence “ muslim doesnt take everything easy if its about our religion” is wrong. We don’t take it easy when we get insulted but we can talk about Islam and make it an topic to make others understand us as an community. So dear reader once again I feel sorry that you feel offended but I can’t and I won’t change anything about my choice of religion for my MC unless you show my in which pint I have done something that is offensive.

I have talked to my Parents well thank you because of your constructive criticism... I got slapped in the face and insulted and I will change the MC’s religion and for the rest of the people reading this... Please understand that each muslim is a mini “oppressor” even my own parents because these people has some serious issues. I had intended to use this MC to show certain Islamic values and characteristics but it seems that just mentioning these people is triggering them...They’re totally ignoring how the world is hating them, Muslims in china being sent to concentration camps, in Indien being secluded, in Europe and the USA being labeled as terrorists... all these things are being tolerated but me using for my MC in an FAN-FICTION that is playing in an anime world even while being a muslim is triggering them. Well done world for once again bitchslapping me in the face!!!

i actually dont know what im talking about before, but what your write to me looks like questioning god? i dont know, i just feel its wrong i actually have a tought about writing the same as you did, but im questioning it, is it okay? is it good? etc also i dont mind(care) about whats other said/write/tought/fell/etc about their religion because its not mine sorry if i somehow disturb your feeling argh its hard to write with a language that is not my 1st language

you can still do it you know, from small things, maybe you can slip an islamic value to your novel? idk, i dont really a smart person maybe if you want to take big moves you can be ustadz or preacher

Well I am questioning god and honestly I am doing it quite often because it is this world that is just going down the drain! I am not knowing god’s plan or what he’s intending for his world but being part of a play and watching him just watch while some humans get oppressed, some doing the oppression, some just being happy not to be part of either group and all of us just being powerless... how is all of this something that we’re all accepting. I tried doing a character based on an muslim and he would have shown values that are important to us Muslims but whatever now he is anything but an muslim...I have had enough of an discussion with my dad... So let’s just think he is from some other religion or an atheist...

im offended because you clearly denied what have been said in the alquran god did not eat, drink, sleep, sleep, neither childless nor begotten, etc

No need I don’t want to do sth. that will end up offending people. :) It is not my mission to change anyone’s image... I’ll just do my thing and wait for the world to burn down XD this is also the exact same words I said to my dad... I didn’t think that some people would feel offended but okay I have changed it now anyway and made it more neutral.

sometimes... i did, but its god what are w talking its beyond my comprehension level so after a lot of question, tought, and thinking. i take it, god know better, he have plan and i thinks its because its near the time of apocalypse(the judgment day) what i had written perhaps its not exactly what im to say and think but again english its not my 1st language btw, whre do you come from? im from Indonesia

Let me ask you a question that is making me wonder. Do you think this world is a good place to live in? Each day thousands of people are being murdered, robbed and abused while god is just watching and we assume that god will punish them once they die... while we are living our whole lives in misery... thinking to ourselves that at the end we’ll go to a place where we won’t need to feel misery. The problem is, that we’re not all the same so how can we all be judged based on “one” standard? But whatever I am trying not to think about it and so I won’t... If you like the story pls enjoy it but if you feel offended then I am sorry. But still have a nice day. Each person has his own doubts and I personally believe that if I don’t try to deal with mine I’ll go mad, so I’ll write about them because this is just how I deal with them.

I do think it is “God” and that he has his own plan and it is outside my comprehension but I don’t have to be happy with his plan and I don’t have to accept it... I can try my very best to do something about it and even when I die and stand in front of god I can say proudly that I have tried my best and if I fail then I accept my punishment because that is the kind of person I am. We have to try to do things and accept whatever outcome we get exactly because we don’t know gods plan! I am sorry but I don’t feel like answering that question because once I do it will get related to my countries people... like all people from country XY are like that people do that unconsciously so just assume I am some guy who could be from anywhere.

im actually not have the knowledge but this my answer from what i know no idont think so if i remember correctly we sent(lived) in this world to be tested(judged) allah is infinite justice, we will fairly judged i remember a story when an angel ask god why did you create humans while they will only cause damage, then God answered "I know better" i do enjoy your story you actually can put an islamic value in your story, but dont make it clear not all islamic value is about muslim like honesty, kindness, and else beacause all religion teach the same i guess?

ahh... i see what you really trying to do(write) now i agree actually but you do it wrong, i think? you just another person that is try to make difference, that only make you a better person then me

I am not denying that he’s all knowing and also not denying that we’ll be judged but the problem is based on what will we be judged...the problem is just me being someone who’s constantly doubting everything... mostly myself but occasionally everything and everybody else!

That is your opinion and I respect that you have one but the alternative would be me going out drinking, partying and picking up some girl... and that is a much worse alternative than me just being skeptical... nice discussion btw I liked it but pls just let us stop here... I use this site to get some distance while this discussion is the exacta opposite of getting distance.

I have read all of it and one thing that stuck to me is that what you said about how religion is used... When fanfiction used Christian, Hinduism, Buddhism, other religion while mix matching everything, no one bat an eye... When devil is sexy, God is evil, all kind of stuff you see in anime, no one care.. But just one word of Islam appear in any article that didn't worship The Almighty(See here? It even need a big capital when you talk about your religion just to barely not scold or spam by others..), you will be attacked by readers that suddenly feel like those old warrior who fight for religion... Its like, "D@mn, I'm going to uphold my religion!!! I don't care if you use other stuff, even a fish or a dog, but Islam is no go!!! I watch p0rn and hentai, yet I will still fight!! Its my ninja way to correct fellow brother way!!!" I can see that what you said about mini oppressor is right.. Just look at how nowadays people use religion to justified nearly anything.. Politic, they will use it to push out for more benefit while justified it with religion since its the most universal shield with no one can denied it or they will get full assault from physically to mentally(It happen to alot of politician who protest some plan that made by another politician and they use Islam to justified it. Just throw in a few word in Islam AlQuran and it turn legit. And then, the one who protest will have his house ransacked by the fanatic, the so called justice warrior, with his car punctured, he got smack in the face, his child got bullied in school, and lots more.).. Lots more point which I wouldn't mention here.. All in all, majority of Muslim will hate you unless you use it to glorified the religion, make other religion looks fake, fighting all the religion with great speech or divert it to another topic to confuse people, make it looks like its the only humanity saviours and stuff.. You know, it's like those Chinese novel with modern genre that makes Chinese mc so powerful that he could singlehandedly fight the whole world and push his Huaxia(Chinese novel love to use Huaxia, old name for Republic of China) to the top of the world like there's nothing better than China...

This one, I really agree... When you bastardized other religion, everyone will not care.. But just one word Islam, the world turn into war battlefield with you as biggest target... And how they said "I don't take my religion as something easy" and they feel insulted.. But did other worshipper of other religion take easy of their religion?? Believe me when I said that the only reason your religion is staying strong is because of you being forced to. In the Islam, there's lots of failsafe that ensure you can't leave your religion. "Once a Muslim, always a Muslim", is what Islam hold on to. While others religion didn't have it. No bi ding to the religion like a rope on your neck. There's pro and con obviously, but in the end Islam win just because their worshipper can't leave... P.S:Author,want to bet how many people will smack both our comment? 🤣🤣🤣😊😊😊😘😘😘

I am Muslim too: 1. The God gave us free will, if somone does something bad or good he will be judged after dead. With free will you can choose what to do, god will not stop you from doing it... Maybe god will give you some hints, what to do but, like I said, it depends on you 2. We can stop opression, but we dont do it. Why you would ask? Some people get money or power with opressing others... With that power and money they manipulate the people... And we, all humans are too selfish to do something about it. They all think the same: Its not our buisness. And there something more they think and wish: I will get rich one day and get political power, like them too. If I work hard enough... If we unite, we can solve all problems in the world... Its not Gods fault, its the humans being greedy and slefish And about muslims and how they behave: The problem are not the muslims, the probelm are the people in Power!

Respect brother

Bro you said all i want to say good response fellow brother .

Salam to you fellow brother .