Johnny Worthington X Reader: Is He a Good Guy? Part Two

Carmen: So, I should go with the pink skirt then?

Y/n: Yeah, it complements the color of your fur.

Carmen: Thanks!

.

She rushes to the bathroom and shuts the door so she can get dressed for the party. You sit on the edge of her bed while you wait for her to be done.

.

Carmen: You sure you don't want to wear one of my outfits or something?

Y/n: Hey it's going to be chilly tonight and wearing this light jacket will be perfect if I'm going to be outside for a while.

Carmen: True, but still.

Y/n: I just rather not dress up completely different from my normal wear just to impress some guy and risk him getting the wrong idea about me.

Carmen: You think every guy is after giggling sluts. That's not true. My boyfriend definitely wasn't looking for that when I first met him.

Y/n: So who's the guy you want to set me up with?

Carmen: Oh yeah, his name is Ethan, and he's one of the O'Mega Howl frat guys.

Y/n: He's in a frat?!

Carmen: (Comes out of the bathroom) Yeah, he says he's had a thing for you and because we're in the same science class together; he asked me for your number. Don't worry, I didn't give him your number. I told him I'll talk to you and see how you feel about it and that's when he brought up the party that'll be in the Roar O'Mega Roar frat house.

Y/n: Well, at least we're just going to be talking in the backyard. I know some monsters like to go out there.

Carmen: (Puts on her earrings while looking in the mirror) Yeah, think of dating like going to an event. You don't have to marry the guy. If you like him and want to continue, then let him know and if things don't go well, don't worry about it and move on with the next guy. You're beautiful Y/n, I wish you can see the guys in my class talk about you.

Y/n: Probably not in an appropriate way.

Carmen: That and… mostly call you pretty and stuff. Anyway, even if things don't go well with Ethan, you have a whole list of admirers to choose from.

Y/n: Ha, isn't that the perk of being a girl?

Carmen: Yeah, but not every girl gets a lot of stares like you do. Some do and some don't. You remember I didn't get much before I met my boyfriend.

Y/n: Yeah I remember, you were going through a chick-flick phase.

Carmen: And I'm done. Are you ready to go?

Y/n: Yup.

.

You two walk out of the room and out of the girls' dorm building, making your way toward the frat houses. It takes a few minutes, but when you arrive, you see a bunch of monsters outside in front of the R.O.R frat house just chilling while a few are going inside for the party.

The music's not too loud, at least not until you head inside. As you and Carmen walk up the stairs, you see some of the frat guys stare at you like you're the only pretty girl at the party. A few look at Carmen too, but you feel like most of their stares are on you.

Walking into the R.O.R house, it's a lot bigger from the inside since there's dozens of monsters here. Some dancing, some smoking, some having a drinking game, and some just chilling by the couches.

Carmen walks you to the other side of the house and you walk out the back door with her. There's a few monsters outside who are just chilling and/or taking a break from dancing. And it even starts to get a little chilly out, so you were right about wearing your jacket and sweatpants shorts.

.

Carmen: Hey Ethan!

.

She gets his attention, and he turns away from his friends when he sees you and Carmen walking up to him.

.

Ethan: Carmen! Y/n! I'm glad you two could make it!

Carmen: I'm going to go get a drink, I'll just leave you two to chat.

.

She playfully pushes you towards him and he nervously smiles at you.

.

Ethan: (Smiles) H-Hey, it's nice to meet you.

Y/n: (Smile) Hey.

Ethan: So uh... what are your hobbies?

Y/n: I really like reading, cooking, watching comedy movies, and studying.

Ethan: That's cool. I'm into football and kickball. Ha, I'm not too good at studying, to be honest with you.

???: Hey everyone! The prank is going to happen!

.

Everyone gets excited and hurries back into the frat house.

.

Ethan: Come on! You're going to laugh at this!

.

Confused but curious, you follow him into the house. You follow him and everyone toward the center of the house and that's when you see Mike and his team standing in the middle. All the lights are on and there's no party music anymore. Just as you were about to walk over to him, you see colorful liquid come down from the ceiling, landing on Mike and his team.

You gasp, seeing your best friend covered in a weird pink liquid. That's when you hear Johnny's voice and you turn your head his way.

.

Johnny Worthington: The most adorable monsters on campus.

.

Then his friend next to him pushes a button and a canon of glitter shoots at O.K, covering them with glitter as another R.O.R guy throws a bucket of little yellow flowers at them. Everyone, including Ethan, is laughing at them. They're all pointing at them, making fun, and laughing at their embarrassment.

.

Johnny Worthington: Realise the stuffed animals.

.

The evil-like smile on his face when he said that... and yet, you saw that same guy showing you a friendly smile just a few hours ago.

Then, dozens of cute stuffed animals are dropped from the ceiling and onto the O.K team. One of the R.O.R then takes a photo of them. You see Johnny with that same grin on his face. Mike was right... he is a fucking jerk.

After they take their picture, Mike and his team hurry out of the building. All while everyone is still laughing at them. They did not deserve that... why the hell would R.O.R do this?

.

Ethan: (Laughs) That was great!

Y/n: Why did they do that?

Ethan: Haha, wait... you didn't know?

Y/n: You did?

Ethan: Yeah, every frat knew and you know, they told their friends to come here. The R.O.R never fails to make us have a good laugh.

Y/n: That wasn't funny, that was just cruel.

Ethan: Aww, don't worry about it. They're a bunch of nobodies anyway.

.

The party music starts playing as the lights go off except the party lights. Everyone's dancing like nothing happened and having a great time. Well, some were still laughing at what just happened. You had enough of this and are not in the party mood anymore, nor do you want to talk to Ethan anymore.

.

Y/n: I have to go.

.

Without looking back, you leave Ethan be and as you were walking towards the exit; you feel someone's hand on your shoulder.

.

Johnny Worthington: Hey Y/n, I'm glad you could make it.

.

Instead of paying attention to him, you smack his hand away from your shoulder and continue out the door. As you exit the frat house, you don't see Mike and his team anywhere. You don't blame them for not wanting to stay here any longer after being humiliated.

.

.

...One Week Later...

.

.

You haven't seen Mike or Johnny since last week at the party. Ethan still tried to talk to you, but stopped when he realized that you weren't going to give him a chance.

After your last class ends, you wander around the campus a bit to clear your mind. Of course, you still thinking about your best friend Mike. He's always been like a brother to you and you two are close since childhood. And for him to be humiliated in front of everybody and... damn... you can't imagine the pain he's going through right now.

As you wander around, you see dozens, possibly over a hundred, of posters and images of the photo that was taken at that party. Of Mike and his team in that strange liquid and glitter. You see everyone smiling and laughing at the photo, a few even mocking them. There's even photos posted all over the nearby small buildings from top to bottom, also the trees, bushes, and cement ground.

You then see Mike, standing alone as his team walks away from him. He looks deeply upset and hurt watching his team leave. You hurry to him in hopes of making him feel better in anyway you can. He's always helped and supported you when you need it, and now it's time for you to do the same.

.

Y/n: Mike!

.

He looks at you but then looks back at his team, who are continuing to walk away.

.

Y/n: Mike? I'm so sorry about what happened. I-I was at the party and now... this is completely fucked up.

Mike: I-It's alright Y/n... (sighs) maybe they're right. I can't change what and who they are as monsters... I-I'm sorry Y/n but, I-I have to go...

.

He then walks away in the other direction, leaving you alone. Placing your hand over your chest, you can only watch him in sadness. You wish there was something you could do to make him feel better.

Meanwhile, Johnny notices you standing alone and sad. Thinking that he could make you feel better, he walks over to you wearing a t-shirt of the image over his frat sweater and holding another t-shirt with that same image.

.

Johnny Worthington: Hey, you alright?

.

Hearing that voice instantly makes you pissed. You turn to him and see what he's wearing.

.

Johnny Worthington: (Smiles) This one's on me.

.

He hands you the t-shirt and when you do; you see the image in the center of it. Instead of smiling and pretending like everything's okay, you throw the t-shirt at his face.

.

Y/n: Keep the damn shirt.

.

You turn around and begin to walk away. He removes the shirt from his face and sees you angrily walking away from him.

.

Johnny Worthington: Woah there, why are you pissed? Is it the fabric of this thing?

Y/n: (You turn around) How the hell could you do that to Mike?! To his team?! You humiliated them and you're over here making a fucking profit from their misery!?

Johnny Worthington: First of all, we're not making a profit. It's for charity. Second, they made fun of themselves. They want to be scariers but they're completely in denial that they're not scary.

Y/n: Oh yeah, and that gives you the right idea to embarrass them like this?

Johnny Worthington: Why do you care so much about them? It's not like you're friends with them, are you?

Y/n: Mike is one of my best friends! And he was right about you. You're a selfish asshole who only cares about himself. Just don't talk to me again.

.

You walk away, leaving Johnny there confused by your words, but he doesn't let that bother him as he goes back to selling the photos and t-shirts.