Who Got Who?

Without hiccups, Sam and the others entered the room carrying their gifts.

Their eyes shone in excitement for the Secret Atlanta. And when Kin entered last, they finally could start with the game.

Theo smiled as he said, "Who wants to start?"

They all looked at each other as they held their presents, but no one volunteered to be the first one to go. 

Theo shook his head helplessly and said, "I guess I'll be the first one to go." He laughed as he stood up and walked to the front of the fireplace.

"Yes, Theo!"

"There is no mystery, I was the one that Theo got."

"Didn't you just say that I got you? You are so shameless."

"You don't know anything. Theo mysteriously looked at me a few minutes ago, which means that I was the one he got and he was giving me a hint."

"I'm pretty sure he didn't look at you even once throughout this evening."