Reviews of My Marvel Reincarnation.
My Marvel Reincarnation.
ScottyTheD
- Overall Rate
- Writing Quality
- Updating Stability
- Story Development
- Character Design
- world background
I don't think I've ever been so excited for a fanfiction after only two chapters. This is going to be great the MC must have the 5 best original wishes that I've ever come across. MCs personality is great. tThe prologue was superb! 🤩🤩🤩🤩🤩🤩🤩🤩🤩🤩🤩🤩🤩🤩🤩🤩🤩🤩🤩🤩🤩🤩🤩🤩🤩🤩🤩🤩🤩🤩🤩🤩🤩🤩🤩🤩🤩🤩🤩🤩🤩🤩
I'm waiting for you on the app's discussion channel!
Download the app to discuss your favorite works, TV shows, and even the weather with me!
After reading the latest chapter (Chapter 16 as of posting this review), I've come to realise that this story has basically went downhill and I just can't help but to myself from reading this story as it's gotten to the point of complete bullshit to me. I feel that abandoning this story is the best choice for me but unlike those asshole reviewers who just say "THIS STORY IS SHIT" and run-off I will try my best to give my justifications. the Good: 1. The word count for each chapter is pretty good and the updates were somewhat frequent and that to me is a plus 2. The batman persona, despite the cringey stuff (like "you have failed this city" was copied from Arrow and also cringey, even if it is a cool line) was actually a good thing. You did shit with him and even killed off some ****ed characters so all was good with this one. But now we get to- The Bad: 1. The emancipation stuff kinda threw me off. usually stuff like that emancipation is like if you're in a abusive family. In this case his family loves him and it you're only doing it just so to beat bad guys and distance yourself from that. I just feel so confused with this one. The familial loves seems to only be one-sided with this one. Keeping a secret life from the parents tends to lead to some bad stuff as well (if peter parker's life has anything to say). 2. Side characters in this story are barely developed and don't even have any screen-time. I don't know if you've noticed but your current character is only talking with an AI and not anybody else. Aside from maybe peter he doesn't talk to anybody and he pretty much abandoned MJ and Felicia and stuff like that instead of actually maintaining contact. this was just sad honestly. The whole-loner mc thing kinda falls apart after a while you know. 3. The whole Superman persona imo absolutely unnecessary and completely forced. There was no need to go the whole superman route and throughout reading this story any and all reasons you have given me did not seem even remotely satisfying. 4. And now, the BIGGEST offender as to why I can't deal with this story, the MC's abilities. Do you know that there's a thing called a "Limit". I didn't have an issue when you got spider powers. Or when you obtained the mutant powers. Or when you obtained both the Hulk and Juggernaut's powers (at this point you should've just stopped cuz you were already powerful as is). But then you got the speedforce and to me at that point was when you should've stopped. But then you wanted to get greedy and copied thors, the other Asgardians and the finally FUCKING ODIN. That was honestly a step too far. First off it should've been impossible for you to obtain the odinforce cuz it ain't as cookie cutter as the any of the other superpowers and frankly should've been impossible. It's the kind of power capable of contending with some the strongest cosmic beings in the universe if not the multiverse heck. And if this universe closely resembled that of the comics then frankly there should've been no way for you to have survived that interaction with odin cuz when it comes to odin he's basically stone-cold. Something like the thing you just did would be more than enuf for him to completely annihilate without a second thought. Frankly that interaction with Odin was more than enough for me to call out "FUCKING BULLSHIT" and rightfully so. The story just kind of went purely downhill and I can't help but describe this story as nothing more than "Well-Written Shit"
this is good this is good this is good this is good this is good this is good this is good this is good this is good this is good this is good this is good this is good this is good this is good this is good this is good this is good this is good this is good this is good this is good this is good this is good this is good this is good this is good this is good this is good this is good this is good this is good
Started well enough (except for his last wish about karma that didnt make sense). But it has been loosing its magic. The longer chapters are a very nice addition, but there has been less and less interesting interactions with side characters(the meat and potatoes for an op mc novel). Also, the dumbing down of the mc(and others) to cause conflict is rather frustrating to read. Yeah absolute power corrupts absolutely and all that, but it shouldnt make him an idiot(or his supreme intelligence AI). Sometimes he is cold, clever, and secretive. Then he does an 180 and is emotional, foolish, and openly shares his secrets. It would have been better to write more interesting interactions with side characters instead of ‘the adventures of only the MC and his ego issues’. Overall, it started ok but I think the story has taken the wrong direction.
(English isn't my first language!) It's a really good story! The first few chapters are a little bad, but the last few chapters (14th at the moment) seems to be written by someone completely different! The quality goes up too much! Well, if you like Ruthless Heroes, the like that would kill every single rapist, killer and supervillain (the bad ones) out there, this story is for you! Other than this, the protagonist utilizes magic, technology and a lot of skills, it's really interesting to see! This Marvel world has the X-Men and all, it's really interesting. As every other story out there, there's obviously some things that people could end up disliking it... Some people here commented about the karma wish... You can simply ignore it! This wish affects only his past world, there's basically no significance to the story. Other than this, some people can end up disliking the fact that the author utilizes some DC Heroes name as the MC Hero name in a MCU story, but it simply a name, nothing more! Well, give this story a chance 'till at least the 11th chapter!
dude can you change MC POV to narrator POV? very strange to read. That's in my opinion, because it's very strange to use MC POV, the impression is very boring. The narrator's POV is better and also, we as readers can better explore the contents of this novel. because with narrator's POV you don't need to focus on MC. in the marvel world, there are many characters that you have to bring in your novel. for example, give a conversation in the perspective of another character. If you are a good reader who has read or is reading WUXIA novels or something else, surely you will understand. because if this novel continues to focus on MC. would be very boring
