Reviews of Minecraft Survival: ASOIAF

good but bad at the same time. The ideas and world is good but the grammar of this is hot garbage and so is the perspective this is written. It's like something I would find on wattpad with it being a written in 2nd person, and makes it feel weird as I'm sure everyone is more used to 1st or 3rd person writing. To summarize, fix the grammar and change to either 1st or 3rd person and you got a really good story

This fanfic is really good but the problem is that when it is in 3rd POV, it is written as if the MC is the readers. you—>him. you should also put your notes and questions at the end of a chapter.

first I will be very frank, the construction of the world is very good you have a lot of imagination, second you are writing me a summary not a story, third it hurts the head reading so many letters you are not separating many paragraphs makes it easy to confuse the progress of the novel, fourth, it would have been better that he himself made the team with some secret family volume etc. fifth has a world of resources so it is not impossible to do it also a story must start from the perspective of the protagonist and his surroundings in short, the novel has a very good idea but it is messy, my idea is that you write it by putting together the ideas you have already done but in another perspective

you read this fanfic, you feel the idea actualy not bad... but you so immerse in inner monologe.... so you just say whetever you want.... ..

The novel has potential but it is just unreadable. The author writes it as if YOU are the main character when you clearly aren’t. He tries to write is as the Mc is the focus of the story but he just keep typing as if YOU are. Im just going to wait till someone else makes a better version of this novel because lets be honest everyone does it one way or another. Below is not from the novel but this is pretty much how the author writes. “After you go to your bed you just remember something important causing you to get back up.” I dont understand why the author keeps writing like this when it should be written like this. Luke will be a random name for a MC. “After Luke went to his bed he suddenly remembered that he forgot to do something important. Now realizing this, Luke got back up and proceeded to do it.” This was just what came to my mind and i know their are some grammar mistakes. Im pretty disappointed because the Author had a good idea but he just does not know how to write correctly. I can read novels with poor grammar but this is just to wrong? I cant even describe it.

the grammar is terrible,i am left confused most of the time,it's definitely a hard read,but the idea was good,if only the author had better skills in English or had an editor,it's not for everyone that's for sure,good luck to the author and i hope he improves....

the story just dosnt make sense to me and is very confusing hhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhbbhbhhhhhhnnjjjjjhhhhbhnnjhnjhhhhhhh hhhhhhhhgvbvvvvvh

read about 20chaps could not read anymore it's 30% info dumps ,50% inner Monologue of a dumb mc 15% conversation between characters 5% pov of other characters(their inner monologue) the mc made manga like one piece dragon ball and novels like Percy Jackson in GOT world in 30BC this is more than enough to say how dumb the mc acts advice if u read remember to shut off ur brain before starting reading this

idea's great it just feels like I'm reading a wiki page sometimes and through a 5 year time skip I still wasn't sure what the mc was trying to do. Another thing is that I feel like there's alot of irrelevant info and it's also pretty easy to get lost in it (for me) as in I'll have no idea what's happening if I accidentally skip a line or 2. I think it's a good book but it's just not for me

the story idea is very promising, but the grammar is illegible and unplanned-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

the novel has many ideas that it can exploit and make a great story, but as always happens in this type of story where the mc has powers beyond everyone else it becomes boring unless there are some funny romances and plots, if this is the author's first novel is on the right track and I hope it improves with time and that there will be some fights soon.

This lookes really promising so hope this goes on ,keep it up author and we'll keep supporting you and the novel!!! .

Hi the author here I gave this a 3 star because of the updating stability. Hahahahhahahahahahhahahahahhahahhahahhahahahahaahahahahahhahahahahahah

I read a comment that describes this story well '5% plot and 95% wiki'. Which barely made it manageable but the all the stuff from One Piece, it became too much. At its core this could of been an amazing story but all we got was a wall of text after another from Wikipedia.

Reveal spoiler

this goes on for a while for word count

Too much info dump and so little of the story itnhad potential with the backgeound story the MC could have used Ice Spiders as mounts but did not bother exploring that idea

It’s seems like the Author never read a book in his life (English Skills = 🧑🏽‍🦯)

WISH FULLFILLMENT STORY READ IF YOUR NOT A HARDCORE GOT FAN GOOD AT STARTING NICE BACKGROUND HISTORY BUT THEN IT BECAME A AMERICAN TEENAGER WISH STORY WHERE MC FORCE A EVOLUTION IN THE NORTH

Honestly the world background was good and the horrible perspective changed eventually but the mc seems to be suffering some mental problems. An example is that despite possessing a world of infinite resources he for some reason doesn't hole himself up in some cave, find some way to extend his lifespan and just watch the got world screw itself over. Instead he thinks and acts as if he Is a normal person who will die of old age and pass down his families land whilst simultaneously strengthening everyone else in the area whether they are all or enemy? He doesn't really have any goal or anything and is just wasting his potential constantly. He owns an actual world but is fine being some King's subordinate. Also way too much irrelevant information as info dumps on some stuff that will never be seen again or stuff that I think is straight off of the wiki that has no influence on the story. Other than that it is fine, just thinking of leaving it for a while to cool down. Ps. Also can't bear to read a 300 or so words straight with no paragraph spacing being written in a really confusing way in the chapter 'Wandless' around chapter 30