First time

~Noelle~

"This is weird. I can't see any of you."

'You don't need to see us. Just hear us, feel us.'

I shuddered out a gasp, and pressed my lips together as I nodded. I could certainly feel them. Their fingers tracing everywhere, god it's impossible to tell who's who when they don't talk. And that for some reason makes me feel hotter. After my first time with Dante, I realized, my body is different from the normal. I doubt normal me would be getting this wet from…. FROM-

Who the hell is that?

Something thick and long, smacks the top of my ass. And I feel someone sliding under my body, so my front is pressed to theirs.

Who is- the scar on the left pec tells me that it's Lucifer. Holy shit. 

That leaves the person with that fully engorged dick to be either Shepherd or Dante. But I've also felt Lucifer. I know they're about the same size as each other. Only he's thicker.