webnovel
avatar

Imperfect Things Novels & Books - WebNovel

Novels912

Popular
  • altalt

    Cultivation: When you take things to the extreme

    Having crossed into the Immortal Cultivation World and finding himself at the very bottom, struggling to survive, Xu Yang discovered he possessed a special golden finger. As long as he persisted in any single activity, he could gain the power to transform the decayed into the miraculous. Eating: Stabilize the Foundation and Cultivate Essence, strengthen the body, extend lifespan… Sleeping: Nourish and accumulate energy, be as vigorous as a dragon or a tiger, Eternal Youth… Breathing: Turtle breathing technique, a tide of vitality, Qi Moves Mountains and Rivers… Walking: Travel a thousand miles in a day, shrink the land beneath you, rival mountains in your speed… No matter if it was the common myriad activities or the Hundred Arts of Cultivation, as long as one was persistent, they could reach the pinnacle of refinement. With this, Xu Yang evolved from a humble fisherman into the strongest ever known, revered as the Ten Mile Sword God!

    Forget to wear a vest · Eastern
    Not enough ratings
  • altalt

    Imperfect Desires

    "Are you looking for your Mr. Right?" "Why would I wait for him? Mr. Right is lost on his way." He quirked his brow at her answer with a faint smile at the corner of his lips. "Then what are you doing?" He questioned in amusement. She placed both her hands on his chest and pushed his masculine body against the wall taking him by surprise. Her honey-brown eyes blinked at him with mischief dancing in them as she planted a firm kiss at his jaw and said, "I'm planning on taking advantage of Mr. Right Now!" His eyes widened dramatically in disbelief. Before his eyes darkened with desire and passion. He placed his hands on her small waist and she could feel the heat of his big hands through the flimsy fabric of her shirt. His head leaned ahead as he whispered close to her ear, "Feel free to take whatever you want." She felt his hot tongue licking her earlobe making her heart to beat erratically. ~~~~~ Chen Xiu; known as Ms. Goody-two-shoes. A Superstar who was said to have it all which made her the center of hatred and envy as well. Little did anyone knew that the same Superstar had to nurse her own wounds in the silence and darkness of night where no one was looking. But for how long could she hold on for? Eventually, she decided to end her own misery and ended her life in the darkness of night, her only companion. Having woken up in a new body and at a new place wasn't something she could ever believe in. At least, not until she became Bai Xiu out of the blue. The day she thought to be her last became her first as a second chance awaited her. But whether this new chance was a blessing or disaster, it was hard to tell since she was trapped in a new body with a new life with the shackles of only her old memories. New life or a new curse? What really awaited her? The same disappointing silence of the night or was there someone calling out her name desperately at the end of the tunnel? Were sparks meant to fly in her heart or the fire in her heart was meant to burn her whole? Was this leap of faith gonna make her fall on her face or was she meant to fly the horizon? The new life brought a lot of questions. But the answer was simple... You would never know until you give it a shot! ~~~ This is an original novel by Xiao MeeHee. All rights are reserved to the author. Thank You! ~~~ Join the Discord Channel: https://discord.gg/gwfrsYyc Instagram: amaya_meehee ~~~ Other Novels by the author: "Mr. CEO Loves The Devilish Beauty" "The Inconceivable Flame: A Fallen Angel's Disguise" "Master's Untamed Wife" "The Moon Mistress" ~~~

    XiaoMeeHee · Urban
    4.8
  • altalt

    I'll Add Points To All Things

    Su Yang was an average university student in Shanghai when he received a system that allowed him to add points to things. The point system provided him with missions and by clearing them, he would gain points. Add a point into an object, the object will receive a special ability; add a point into a plant, the plant will come alive; add points on himself, he will get talents or superpowers. With the mysterious point system in hand, Su Yang aimed to become rich and alter his fate. On his path towards success, he encountered many interesting matters and people, including famous actresses and business tycoons. Fueled by determination, Su Yang set his sight on adding points into all things to help him achieve his goal.

    Eternal Era · Urban
    4.4
  • altalt

    Pernikahan Tersembunyi: My Imperfect CEO

    Anya hanya bermimpi untuk bisa memiliki kehidupan sederhana yang damai. Namun, hingga saat ini hanya ada kesengsaraan dalam hidupnya. Setiap hari gadis cantik itu harus banting tulang untuk menafkahi ibunya dan dirinya sendiri. Sampai suatu malam, tanpa sengaja Anya bermalam di sebuah kamar hotel mewah, bersama seorang pria tampan yang tidak dikenalnya! Malam itu mengubah seluruh kehidupannya… Aiden menawarkan pernikahan kepada Anya, dengan alasan yang tidak diketahui gadis itu. Tetapi Aiden juga berjanji untuk membuat impian Anya menjadi kenyataan: harta dan kehidupan yang damai. Akankah Anya hidup dengan tenang dan bahagia seperti impiannya? Apakah Anya bisa hidup damai dengan menjadi seorang istri CEO Perusahaan terbesar di asia?

    Renata99 · Urban
    4.9
  • altalt

    Meeting You Is The Most Beautiful Thing

    The new book【Addicted to the Demon CEO's Kiss】is out now, please support~ 【Supremely Sweet and Adorable Pampering Story】Imperial City is in an uproar because the Little Overlord, Ou Zun, has become a devoted husband. When they were engaged, she ran away, but was later caught. He roared angrily, "I've provided for you, given you my heart and soul, and you still run away?" She fidgeted with her small hands, her cheeks rosy, "You're too good to me, I can't repay you." "Devote yourself to me." Upon hearing this, she couldn't contain her joy, "I've been waiting for you to say that for a long time!" Everyone knew, Mù Qiānxún was the apple of Ou Zun's eye. He was so gentle with her, afraid the warmth of his mouth might melt her, and worried the air might freeze her. He even kept her tied to his belt, bringing her everywhere he went.

    M Fennel · General
    Not enough ratings
  • altalt

    Hidden Marriage With My Imperfect CEO

    Anya dreams to have a simple, and peaceful life. However, there has only been misery in her life. This beautiful girl must work hard Every day to support her mother and herself. Until one night, Anya accidentally spent the night in a luxury hotel room, with a handsome man she didn't know! That night changed her whole life... Aiden offers Anya a marriage, for unknown reason to the girl. But Aiden also promised to make Anya's dream come true: wealth and a peaceful life. Will Anya live quietly and happily like her dream? Can Anya live in peace by becoming the wife of the CEO of the largest company in Asia?

    Renata99 · Urban
    4.9
  • altalt

    Imperfect

    David Lee gets emotionally attached, falling fast and hard. He can’t do one night stands. He’s had the worst crush on Tobias since high school, but it changes to intense hatred when he discovers how much Tobias sleeps around in college.<br><br>Tobias has been infatuated with David for years, but grows frustrated and furious after being repeatedly rebuffed. That’s why he enjoys arguing with David. It’s the only time David will pay any attention to him.<br><br>After college, they lose touch. But when they meet up years later, Tobias is surprised to discover how much feeling he still harbors for David.<br><br>This time, David agrees to a date. Can the two men work through their issues and find their happily ever after with each other?

    Casper Graham · LGBT+
    Not enough ratings
  • altalt

    IMPERFECT CEO

    !! WARNING MATURE CONTENT 19+ !! (Harap bijak dalam memilih bacaan) Kalian tahu apa itu 'Ge Sketchbook Company'? Sebuah perusahaan peneribit terbesar yang ada di tengah indahnya Kota Amsterdam, Belanda. And bingo! Tuan Ge adalah pendirinya. Seorang pria dewasa berusia 40 tahun yang sangat gagah dengan stelan jas mahal yang membalut tubuhnya. Jam tangan berkilau kalau sinar sang surya menerpa permukaannya. Mobil mewah dengan harga fantastis serta rumah bertingkat yang menyaingi tingginya gedung pencakar langit di tengah kota. Rupanya? Sangat tampan! Di usia yang semakin tua, pria dewasa pemilik nama Ge Hansen Joost itu tak pernah mendapatkan hujatan perihal tampangnya yang ikut menua. Semakin tua, semakin mempesona! Itulah yang mereka katakan kala tak sengaja bersua dengannya. Sayangnya, ia sudah berkeluarga. Satu istri dan seorang putri cantik. Mereka memanggilnya Amanda Hansen Ge. Bukan kisah Amanda yang super duper mewah jauh dari kata 'kurang' yang akan aku ceritakan di sini. Namun, kisah ku! Kisah seorang gadis berusia hampir mirip dengan Amanda Hansen, namun aku sedikit tua tiga angka di atasnya. Usiaku 21 tahun. Menjelang 22 tahun jikalau tahun ini berakhir. Namaku adalah Luna. Luna Theresia Skye. Terlalu panjang jikalau kata teman-temanku menyebutnya. Jadi, mereka mempersingkat. Hanya Luna Skye. Kata mereka itu sangat cantik! Secantik paras dan tubuh yang aku milikki. Yang ada di dalam diriku adalah bentuk kesempurnaan yang berhasil dilukiskan semesta untuk ciptaannya. Namun, sayangnya mereka tak melukis indah takdir percintaan yang menyertai dalam setiap langkah yang kuambil. Salah satu kebodohan yang kupunyai dalam kehidupan percintaanku adalah ... aku mencintai bosku itu. Ya, Tuan Ge Hansen Joost! Sudah berkeluarga? Memang! Tapi aku tetap menyukai dan ingin memiliki raga serta rasa dalam diri pria yang 21 tahun lebih tua dariku itu. Gila bukan? Memang. Aku ini memang gila!

    Lefkiilavanta · Urban
    5.0
  • altalt

    All Of The Little Things

    BOOK THREE in the Chronicles of mischief saga.《*Can be read as a stand alone*》 "Asa, you need to listen to Daddy," Joel Murdock warned. Asa Finch barely spared him a glance. "I'm not Asa. I'ma Dinosaur." "Asa... I won't ask you again." "RAWR!"

    Louise Baston · LGBT+
    Not enough ratings
  • altalt

    IMPERFECT LOVE (21+)

    KONTEN 21+ Natalia merupakan seorang penulis cerita anak-anak yang tidak mengenal cinta. Bahkan, sepanjang usianya, dia tidak pernah mencintai seorang pria sama sekali. Baginya, hidup sendiri bukanlah kesalahan. Hingga dia mendapatkan tawaran untuk menuliskan sebuah cerita bergenre adult romance, membuatnya benar-benar pusing karena sekali pun dia tidak pernah membayangkan akan menuliskan kisah yang membuatnya muak. Sampai tanpa sengaja dia bertemu dengan Daniel–pria dengan segudang rahasia.

    Kim_Meili_9611 · Urban
    5.0
  • altalt

    all the things we lost

    "Who are they?" I asked Sarah as the bikers got closer. "Bad news," she whispers, she looked at Tyler and James, who was already walking towards us in a hurry. "Get in the car," she warns. I almost did, but when I saw the look of fright in her eye I didn't move. I felt hands around my naked waist, I knew it was Tyler. He pulls me tightly against his chest, I could feel the heat coming from his body. "Get in your car and drive off. Don't say a word" he whispers into my ear. "Why?" why did they want me to leave? "Just fucking do it Bella!" he says angrily pushing me forward, I bumped into another hard chest. But this time I could smell cheap beer and sweat. I look up and saw a tattooed face with a nose ring. Taking a step back slowly when he showed me his yellow teeth. "Well, aren't you a pretty thing!" He laughs out, the others agreeing with him. "What's a pretty thing like you doing here?" I didn't reply, I didn't like the way they were watching me. I felt Tyler's hard hands on my shoulder, his grip was hard enough to make me wince. He pulled me up against his chest as if trying to shield me away. I look around the now deserted desert, everyone seems to have disappeared. It was just James, Jada, Sarah, Nelson and Tyler. They were all standing next to us. "Boy! We've been looking for you" they yelled at Tyler. He didn't look affected by them, in fact, I think they knew each other. Why would Tyler be hanging out with guys like this? "I see you got your self a new pretty bird" one chuckles pointing at Tyler's arm that was around my waist. "What are you doing here Stone" he growls at the guy that just spoke. "It seems you've forgotten you owe us money" the guy name Stone growls at Tyler. Does he owe their money? Why? "We made a deal, you said on the 7th" Tyler say, today was the 5th. "Well, you see our boss change his mind" Stone laughs casually. "I don't have that kind of money on me Stone" Tyler was breathing hard now. I knew something bad was about to happen, I just wasn't sure what. "Then we have a problem boy," Stone pulls out a gun and point it directly at me. I freeze tears forming in my eyes, I stare at the gun, not moving. I held Tyler's hands tighter, trying my best not to move. "She's got nothing to do with this" Tyler steps forward blocking me from the gun. I felt him reaching behind his back slowly. "Your gonna have to pay Son and that one looks like she's worth 50 grand" He owns them 50 thousand dollars! I wanted to yell. How did that happen? Doesn't he know people like this can kill you for that? "Come back on the 7th and you will have your money" James steps forward. Oh god, this boys looked like they did this daily. What the hell was I doing here, I should be with my friends getting wasted not stuck in the middle of what looked like a gang War. "Just give us the girl and will be on our merry way" "Not gonna happened," before I could blink Tyler pulled out a gun from his back making my eye wide. HE HAD A FUCKING GUN!! Oh my god, this is not going to be good. Does he carry that with him all the time? If he does how comes I've never felt it. "Be a smart boy, there are three of you and six of us. If you give us the girl will let you keep the other two" Stone says referring to Sarah and Jada. "We just want one!" another biker yells making me jump. "None of them are going with you" Tyler stood his ground, pointing his gun directly at Stone. "Fine," Stone spat on the floor and the other men behind him pulled out their guns some had long knives instead. "James gets Bella out of here," Tyler whispers deadly not taking his eyes off Stone. Bella Thomson, the queen bee. This was her senior year, she already planned everything-homecoming queen, Harvard. Tyler Carter isn't like every other typical 18 years old. Living in the wrong neighbourhood all his life and after losing his mother age of 15, never knowing who his dad was. He is known as the best fighter on the north side.

    cluelessgixl · Teen
    4.8
  • altalt

    Re Istode : Things that kitsune girl do in another world

    Giselle Gibson is too masculine to life as a woman, it made her life quite abnormal, it is also not uncommon for her to be considered a sissy by others when she wore women's clothes. Giselle was being bullied, ridiculed, and used as a joke. Lifelike that pressed her mentality. To protect her mind, Giselle plays VRMMORPG Ark Fantasy online. And unfortunate for her, the hardware that can scan her gender accurately encounter an error and she got a man avatar. Giselle held back her tears and continued to step forward. And happy things arise! In the game, Giselle encountered good people who then became her friends. In the real world, after she learned to accept herself for what she was, she got a girlfriend. For the next few years, Giselle's life was getting better. But ... the circle of fate spins. Giselle had to part with her girlfriend. Her work became unstable. Knowing the future waiting for her becomes unclear. Giselle decided to fully play Ark Fantasy Online to raise money. Thanks to game items trading, Giselle can support her life. She also became a player who was strong enough to deserve the title of an elite player. To test her abilities, Giselle participates in a PVP Tournament. The woman won the match and she became a champion. Then, the circle of fate spins once again. The gift she got after winning the PVP Tournament changed her life forever! What things in her life that change? What will happen to Giselle? Can the woman survive? Can she get her happiness? No one knows other than you. Discord link: https://discord.gg/A8UznKuh3q [Warning: For character development, there are a few chapters in the first 25 that have sensitive content about Sl*ve, Assault Attempt, and Dark Past. There is a notice on those Chapters.]

    Pandora_Phantasy · Fantasy
    4.3
  • altalt

    Imperfect Marriage

    #WSA 2022 Menikah adalah keinginan dari setiap orang, apalagi jika bisa menikah dengan laki-laki yang baik dan bertanggung jawab. Namun, hal itu hal menjadi mimpi bagi Hanin, dirinya harus menikah dengan seorang pria yang angkuh, otoriter, sombong, dan kejam. Pernikahan keduanya terjadi karena sebuah perjodohan konyol, diantara kedua orang tua mereka. Pernikahan yang dinilai Hanin akan membawa kebahagian nyatanya tidak, Galang sang suami sudah memberikan kontrak pernikahan setelah kedua resmi menikah. Ketika Hanin belajar membuka hati, disaat itu juga Galang mencoba terus menorehkan luka, dan saat Hanin menyerah Galang kembali hadir dengan sejuta cinta. Bagaimana kisah keduanya? Mampuhkah Hanin bertahan dalam belenggu cinta Galang?

    Ocha_Gumay24 · Urban
    5.0
  • altalt

    The Imperfect Second Male Lead (English)

    Love to Ursilla, a novel written by Liera and successfully distributed, has reaped a lot of profits. Many pros and cons occur among readers regarding the main character in the novel. Liera is a writer who loves to torture the female lead and get her bad luck before leading a happy life with the male lead. Liera is just a teenage girl who occupies a vocational school and will turn 16 years old in May. However, one day Liera did not expect that her careless actions made her transmigrate into the novel she wrote. Unfortunately, Liera becomes Ursilla dà Victoria, the Crown Princess of the Victoria Kingdom and the lover of Morgan, the playboy who always hopes for Ursilla's death. Liera never liked Morgan, the male lead in the novel Love to Ursilla. She prefers the second male lead, Antares, a pathetic man who is willing to give his life to save Ursilla from the brink of death due to Morgan's orders. As a result, Antares died bringing his love which he had not had the chance to convey to Ursilla. Liera wanted to change the story line she wrote and prevent Antares's death. Nor would she be the lover of an asshole like Morgan who wished for her death. However, the struggle was not as easy as she thought. Because there is someone who always gets in the way of changing the story line. *** You can contact me on: Instagram: lidiacntys10 Discord: LidiaCntys10#7888 My other novels: - I Will Get You Back, Young Master! (English) [ Book 2 ] - Dear Angkasa : My Pet Boyfriend (English) - The Mafia Queen : Trapping A Man Who Phobias With Women [ Book 1 ] You can read both books separately. For now, the second book has been uploaded early.

    LidiaCntys10 · Fantasy
    5.0
  • altalt

    All Things Bright

    Welcome to America! The land of the free, where dreams come true. Literally... When you say that all the magic happens in your bedroom, you're usually talking about one thing. But not if you're Cameron. While everyone else is vast asleep and dreaming, his mind travels through time, and he has no control over it whatsoever. That might be neat when you just want to mess around and have some fun. But not when you keep getting thrown into situations where you constantly have to face the person who broke your heart. Especially not when their life is slowly deteriorating right in front of your eyes. Drugs. Guns. Suicide. And there is nothing Cameron can do to save him. Lost in time and deprived of sleep, Cameron gets closer to an old friend again - depression. And suddenly his crush isn't the only one whose life is in danger. An LGBT Coming-of-Age story about true love and mental health.

    AnnikaTheGerman · LGBT+
    4.7
  • altalt

    His Pretty Little Thing (The Personal Assistant)

    r18 (Intentional Love And Erotic Scenes). I was determined to work my way back to the top after taking a rather long break from the corperate world. Fate did it's thing and I found myself back in the same space with my most dreaded ex. Working at Nolem PLC as a personal assistant was fulfilling. The feeling of love and lust clouded our senses for a very long time until Thomas Maclewin stepped in. An engagement to a childhood friend, The sudden reappearance of an ex and Thomas Maclewin, The Chaos, The bitterness, The feeling of betrayal, Family, Love, Lust and Romance all gave rise to a beautiful and relatable love story. Excerp 1 "You think I would be interested in just any random woman who puts her room key in my hand. What the hell kind of man do you think I am." He couldn't believe what he was hearing. Didn't he tell her he hasn't been with anyone else since her. Where was all this coming from. "Did you not understand when....." "No, you don't understand!" She interrupted, slamming a brush on the counter, looking up at him furiously. "I'm not like this, I'm not someone that sleep with her boss. I'm thirty and I've only been with two men my entire life, you inclusive. And I've never let any man rid me of my sense of reasoning, ever!" She yelled, her voice getting louder with each word. "But when I'm with you, it's like nothing else matters. This... this thing," she continued, gesturing between them. "This isn't me. It's like I turn into a different person when I'm with you, and I hate it. Maybe it's so easy for you, but it's not same for me." *CURRENTLY EDITING* *Other suggested Books In Order of Reading* •A Crazy Kind Of Love; The End •The Woman For Me •Miss Clara Instagram: christabel_radiance Mail: christydew25@gmail.com Telegram: christsbel_radiance

    Christabelradiance · Urban
    Not enough ratings
  • altalt

    Imperfect Boyfriend

    TAMAT. Proses Revisi. Clarissa Annabelle ditakdirkan hidup dalam kesedihan. Kedua orang tuanya berpisah sehingga tidak ada lagi rumah untuknya mendapat kasih sayang. Ketika waktu mempertemukan gadis itu dengan seorang lelaki dewasa, Annabelle merasa sangat nyaman. Mereka menjalin hubungan meskipun terpaut umur cukup jauh, hingga takdir kembali mempermainkan perasaannya saat Dhani menikahi wanita lain. Annabelle berusaha mencari kebahagiaan dengan meninggalkan semua orang yang telah melukainya, mencari kisah baru dan berharap ada sedikit kebahagiaan untuknya. ~ Cover by Mendystxxx. FB: Ikka Fahrie IG: Ikka Fahrie

    Ikka_Fahrie · Teen
    5.0
  • altalt

    The Imperfect Second Male Lead

    Love to Ursilla, novel yang ditulis oleh Liera dan berhasil didistribusikan sehingga menuai banyak keuntungan. Banyak pro dan kontra terjadi di antara pembaca mengenai pemeran utama di novelnya. Liera itu penulis yang suka sekali menyiksa pemeran utama wanita dan membuatnya mendapatkan kesialan sebelum menjalankan kehidupan bahagia bersama pemeran utama pria. Liera hanyalah gadis remaja yang menduduki bangku SMK dan akan berusia genap 16 tahun pada bulan Mei. Namun, suatu hari Liera tak menyangka bahwa tindakan cerobohnya membuatnya bertransmigrasi ke dalam novel yang dia tulis. Sialnya, Liera menjadi Ursilla dà Victoria, Putri Mahkota dari kerajaan Victoria sekaligus kekasih dari Morgan, playboy yang selalu mengharapkan kematian Ursilla. Liera tidak pernah menyukai Morgan, pemeran utama pria dalam novel Love to Ursilla. Dia lebih menyukai pemeran utama pria kedua, Antares, pria menyedihkan yang rela menyerahkan hidupnya demi menyelamatkan Ursilla dari ambang kematian akibat suruhan Morgan. Akibatnya, Antares meninggal dunia dengan membawa cintanya yang belum sempat ia sampaikan pada Ursilla. Liera ingin mengubah jalan cerita yang dia tulis dan mencegah kematian Antares. Dia juga tidak akan menjadi kekasih dari bajingan seperti Morgan yang mengharapkan kematiannya. Namun, perjuangannya tak semudah yang dia pikirkan. Karena ada seseorang yang selalu menghalanginya untuk mengubah jalan cerita tersebut. *** You can contact me on: Instagram: lidiacntys10 Discord: LidiaCntys10#7888 My other novels: - Queen Of Mafia - The Imperfect Second Male Lead (English) - I Will Get You Back, Young Master! (English) - Dear Angkasa : My Pet Boyfriend (English)

    LidiaCntys10 · Fantasy
    5.0
  • altalt

    FORBIDDEN LOVE: hot kiss for imperfect romance

    UNDER REVISE!!!! Mature content!! Started from romance, adventures, action, into a parallel world. Alpha werewolf and half-blood (vampire x werewolf) queen, love adventures chapter 1-50: Modern setting, romance, jump plot story. chapters 50-: Parallel world adventures "What did you do?" Leah asked with a surprised face when she got out of the bathroom and saw the broken bed. Goose feathers flew into the air, some of the feathers stuck in her exposed and slightly wet skin. "Omg. We haven't even done anything yet in this room !!" **** Met in the modern era did not make the relationship between Leah, Max, and Jack normal. They are trapped in the cursed of the past, fighting, war, blood, fighting for power and hatred. Leah's love for Max didn't work either. They are born with different species. Finding the point, when Leah and Max couldn't be together made Jack happy. Jack was born as a descendant of a vampire, Leah has the scent of vampire blood, they are different from Max. Max was a descendant of a werewolf, he hates that fact. He disappeared from Leah's life and was trapped by Altes's sedition. He lost his identity. There are many cunning ways in Altes' head, he asked Max to kidnap a girl who has extraordinary powers, who can reconcile the wolf and vampire clan. Of course, with the facts upside down. Max didn't realize that the woman in order was Leah, a girl who has made him so much in love before. the hidden fact, Leah was no ordinary human girl. She was the princess of the most famous royal in the vampire kingdom. She's the hidden future queen. P.s The art cover is not mine, pls feel free to tell me if it yours :)

    Redink_109 · Fantasy
    5.0
  • altalt

    IMPERFECT

    Declan299 · Teen
    Not enough ratings