Nightmare Night.

//

Long overdue but I had my five years old cousin visit me on the weekend and she's the cutes little lady on earth that deserved all the pampering XD Also had to carry over 7 tones of pellets closer to the "heating furnace" and finish a report for university in a subject I'm totally not interested in XD All in all a buddy weekend and I'm worried that this week is even worse as I have two reports and an exam which are the thing I know about. who knows what else awaits me...

Anyway, I hope you like this chapter and like always EEEENJOY!!!

//

Ponyville that night was a sight to behold.

Whenever you looked, many scary looking decorations like Spiderwebs, Skeletons, bats and etcetera could be seen set all-over the place, while Ponies wearing numerous impressive costumes, strolled around, either enjoying themselves in the festive atmosphere, or looking for candies if they were of the younger age...

Of course there were always exception to the rule...

Watching Pinkie Pie prancing around hunting for sweets in a chicken costume, was a most unusual sight. One, both Starfall and Pinkamena couldn't help but find equally as exasperating as amusing.

The duo followed the Mare in hasty steps, never forgetting to actually stop from time to time to enjoy the Festival of the Halloween-like Holiday.

As it could be expected of the situation, they also wore their respective scary costumes.

Starfall originally wanted to put on a certain metal armour with a red king Cape and a matching metal spiky crown, but upon further consideration, he decided that it would be too suspicious if Luna recognized his attire and he was uncertain of her reaction...Also, seeing as the evil "Pony" he would have imitated was still technically alive, he found the idea somehow unbecoming...

In the end, Starfall opted on conjuring himself a pair of butterfly wings on his back using the Spell from the Best Flyer Competition and putting over it an illusion of black and white wings. The idea of walking through town as an Alicorn, even if fake, stroked his overly inflated ego, and he had to receive a slap at the back of his head from Twilight back at the library to stop showing off in front of a mirror...

Meena on the other hand almost gave Starfall a heart attack when she showed up at his doorstep, with her coat covered in splashes of red liquid, wearing what appeared to be some bloodied bandages and a large kitchen knife (thankfully blunt) strapped onto her left thigh...

It took him a moment to regain his bearings, which a chicken clad Pinkie Pie managed to accomplish fairly easily a minute later...

"Hey Look! Trick-or-treaters! Let's join them!" Pinkie exclaimed excitedly, and without waiting for the two of them dashed towards the children.

"Pinkie! Aren't you a little too-" Starfall tried to call her, but a scream from the chicken mare resounded before he could finish.

"I'm never too old for free candies!!!"

Seeing no way to argue the duo joined Pinkie and the kids.

"Ah! Hey Mr. Starfall! Would you like to join us?" Asked Sweetie Belle upon seeing Starfall and Pinkamena closing on the group.

"Dad! Look how many candies we collected!" Exclaimed Spike who run towards the adults wearing a two headed dragon costume. Only a single head was fake in it...

Starfall ruffled spikes head with a smile as he showed him his basket, before letting the little dragon join back with the CMC and other kids led around by Granny Smith.

He noticed Phoebe flying around, with her feathers painted in black with purple glowing streaks, hunting for candies from unsuspecting victims and couldn't help but chuckle. He could also appreciate her "costume" which, not to brag, he was the author of...

They spend a while following the group as Granny Smith told them the story of Nightmare Moon, soon being joined by Zecora who assisted her by using some fancy green fire alchemy.

What surprised him though was an appearance of the actual Nightmare Moon and a head splitting squeek of Pipsqueak, before Luna also joined whom Starfall guessed to be Midnight Moon in disguise, Both mares giving a small inscenization to explain their Story while a surprisingly large group of Ponies joined to listen, everypony curious of said Story, told from the lips of the mares in question themselves.

He didn't expect Pipsqueak to get even more excited but somehow, the little pirate costume clad colt looked as if he were to have a stroke from excitement at any moment...

Even Pinkie stopped to watch the spectacle while occasionally popping a candy into her mouth...or beak...to appease her sweet tooth...

Pinkamena sat beside Starfall, and it didn't go unnoticed how she tried to sit as close as possible, so Starfall was happy to oblige.

When she felt a hoof wrap around her shoulder, a rare happy smile sprouted on the face of the totally not murder hobo impersonating mare...

Their eyes met and some understanding went between them as Meena slowly leaned closer towards the Stallion.

When their lips met, it was as if an explosion of feeling went through Pinkamena. All her worries, insecurities and depressive thoughts disappeared as the feeling of contentment went through her entire body. And as the electrifying experience reached her flanks, they two were surprised by a sudden flash of light.

They were reluctant to part, but the unexpected situation prompted them to check the source of the disturbance...

But what they saw completely dumbfounded them.

There, right at the flank of the mare, appeared what seemed to be a small inconspicuous symbol of two, star and heart respectively shaped, intertwined with their strings balloons!

Meena looked at this symbol in shock before rapidly turning back towards Starfall. Tears slowly started to form in her eyes as happiness permeated her body.

Both of them knew what it meant.

Any lingering doubt regarding whether she was truly alive and real and not just a well made copy got resolved by this single act of ancient magic. At that moment Pinkamena knew that she would forever keep on loving the Stallion in front of her. He gave her so much, and now, even magic recognised that bringing happiness and staying with her "Star" was what she was meant to do.

She knew that she won't be the same as Pinkie. Her talent wasn't spreading happiness and making great parties. It was to share the happiness that she experienced and to thrive when being together with other Ponies...The Star shape most likely had something to do with the pony who helped her trigger the acquisition of her Cutie Mark...

Even Starfall understood the message of he Mark and noticed how much the sole appearance of the Cutie Mark meant for Meena. He felt extremely happy for her and wanted to show her his emotions by giving her another kiss like the one which gave them such an incredible surprise...

"Starfall look! Pie family set up their classic Labirynth! can we go!? Can we!?Can we!?" A wild Chicken Pie suddenly appeared, shaking them from their emotional moment and bringing them back to reality.

The Children party was already further away while the gathering watching Midnight's and Luna's spectacle was currently pestering the two Alicorns with multiple questions while a newly arrived Twilight, wearing the costume of Starswirl the Bearded, tried to help the two not to get swooped by the excited townsponies...And Pipsqueak...

Starfall smiled and glanced at Meena. Unsurprisingly, the mare gave him a small amused eye roll before both of them stood up to follow Pinkie, who as it appears didn't even notice Meena's new Cutie Mark, too excited about the idea of having fun in the scary Labirynth...

It only took another two hours before the Chicken clad mare finally fell in battle against a food coma, having consumed over two baskets of highly sugary sweets... Starfall quickly made sure that she wasn't in any way in danger before levitating her back into the Sugarcube Corner accompanied by a dreamy looking Pinkamena still wearing her "totally not a murderer" costume...

He laid the body of the still half Conscious and grinning Pinkie Pie onto her bed before taking of her costume, and then slowly let out a sigh of relief...The exhausting but fun night was finally coming to an end...

He was about tuck in beside her out of habit, but a slow sensual brush over his side, done by none other than Pinkamena stopped him in his tracks.

As he looked at her, he noticed the blushing cheeks and a slightly rugged breathing of the honestly scary looking mare, and for some reason could help but get excited at her sight.

Somehow, an idea started to form inside of his mind...An idea he never considered...How would it feel to take Pinkamena while she looked like this?...

The idea of deflowering Pinkameena while she was covered in "blood" and looking like a crazy murderer arose something in him, he didn't knew he had...

And she clearly felt equally excited by the growing look of excitement on her cute pinkish muzzle.

Their lips slowly closed in on themselves, and before they knew it, they were already deep in the process of making out, any semblance of shyness forgotten... Pinkameena might have been insecure and depressed untill recently... and possibly all the time, or that was at least her "character trait", but as they continued exchanging their fluids, another side of her became apparent...The one revealed by the Mark, Starfall was currently fondling alongside her backside...

She wanted to share and give out Happiness...She wanted share and give love...And she did it all and more as the two Ponies fell deeper and deeper into their intimacy...

Before long, Starfall, the muscular and powerful Stallion, who currently sported both an impressive and sharp horn as well as a pair of strong albeit actually fake wings, towered above the meek, small and "bloodied murderer" Pinkameena, Her legs opened wide to allow entrance for the ginourmus schlong that was about to rupture her insides.

Starfall looked at her questioningly, asking whether she was sure about it, but the mare showed him a rare smile and nodded.

"Please Mr... Ravage this little whorse..." She whispered with a glint in her eye as Starfall looked at her in disapproval. it wasn't time for their little byplay, even if he enjoyed it...

She rolled her eyes and smiled.

"Please... Starfall....I want it...Don't hesitate..." She said pleadingly, giving him a green light to move forward as her hind-legs wrapped around his back pushing him harder into her vagina.

She screamed in pleasure as the massive member destroyed her hymen, and moaned even harder as soon as the powerful schlong impacted her womb.

Slowly but surely, Starall began to move, rhythmically pushing in and out of the mare as she screamed into the ceiling out of pleasure, Pinkie Pie still unresponsive only a bit to the side on the other side of the bed.

They didn't knew how long they have been making love, but they swapped between multiple positions and did a lot of roleplaying, the most common being a Prince punishing a crazy outlaw, Pinkameena going along with everything and adding a lot of her own twists to the mix.

She clearly enjoyed it all just as much as Starfall did, and when they finally had enough of roleplay, their quirky session smoothly transferred into the regular sensual lovemaking where they showed all the true and proper emotions they felt to eachother and wanted to convey.

A funny thought went through his mind during the experience. If that's what sex felt when doing it with a mare who's talent was partially sharing happiness and love, How would it be if the Mare's talent was literally spreading love... Damn Shining Armour was a lucky brother-in-law...

That Night, Starall and Meena didn't fall asleep...With Pinkie Pie slowly regaining her bearings and with her finall realization that her sister got her Cutie Mark, a congratulatory lovemaking threesome had been in order... followed by another party to properly celebrate the occasion the next day, again followed with another threesome the following night...

Yes...That really was a life that Starfall could enjoy forever...