Denying Erza (R-18)

{A/N: This is a pretty long chapter, my longest ever. So, I put the R-18 warning before the NSFW stuff starts. It goes to the end of the chapter}

Earth land, Ishgar, Kingdom of Fiore, Magnolia.

April 7, x782.

A little more than a month has passed since Mirajane's punishment was decided. In that time, She, Elfman, and Lisanna spent most of their time working in the guild hall as a waiter and waitresses. On top of that, Mirajane came up with a point system for the Fairy Tail wizards to exchange for Alfonzo's cooking.

Each quest rank would be given a point value. D-Class quests would earn each wizard two points. C-Class quests would offer five points. B-Class quests would give twenty points. A-Class quests would give fifty points. And S-Class quests would earn wizards a total of one hundred points.

10-Years and 100-Years quests would not be factored into the point calculations, however. Considering that they are simply S-Class quests that have gone uncompleted for at least a decade, Mirajane determined that it was not necessary.

About a week ago, however, Elfman and Lisanna's quest suspension came to its end. So, Mirajane was left to work alone in the guild hall. Though she was recently approached by a representative for Sorcerer Weekly to become a model in their magazine, an offered she accepted to bring some color to her life.

But today, April 7, was a day of celebration. It was Erza's seventeenth birthday. And like they had done for all the others in most years, Alfonzo and Elicia threw a party for their friend at their mansion.

The party went like all the others in the past. Alfonzo' cooked a dinner for everyone. Then, they all went down to the game room and had fun. Some of the boys even went out to the backyard and played basketball for a while, too. However, the party, like all parties do, eventually came to an end.

"Come on, Erza." Elicia said, nudging Erza toward Alfonzo who had just seen the last guest out.

On a side note, Sun had decided to spend the night at her parent's house tonight. Somehow, she had been getting through to her father about his overprotective/psychotic behavior when it came to her. So, she decided to strike the iron while it was not.

Meaning, only Alfonzo, Elicia, Cana, and Erza were currently in the house.

"Seriously, just get on with it." Cana said, also pushing Erza toward Alfonzo. "We all know you want it. You've been hinting to us to leave the silencing sigils deactivated whenever Sun isn't here."

"But… I'm not sure if I'm ready." Erza said nervously.

"Oh please." Elicia replied. "At this rate, you'll never be 'ready'."

At that moment, Alfonzo turned around. Although he could hear the girls whispering to each other, and he had a good guess about what they were talking about, he didn't bring it up. Instead, he just walked toward them with a smile.

"Erza, I hope you enjoyed your birthday party." Alfonzo said.

"Yes, it was wonderful." Erza replied with a smile and a blush on her face. "And it gets even more wonderful every year."

"That's good." Alfonzo replied with his smile widening even further.

With that, Alfonzo and Erza maintained eye contact, staring into each other's eyes.

Seeing the way the two looked at each other, Cana rolled her eyes. Then, she pushed Erza strongly from behind, causing her to stumble into Alfonzo.

Quickly wrapping his arms around Erza, who was now 5'9" (1.75 m) tall, Alfonzo supported her against his chest.

"Stop staring into each other's eyes like a couple of love-struck kids." Cana said impatiently. "She's been dancing around this for over a year now. Just take her into the bedroom and fuck her brains out. Then, she can go back to being normal about this… Well, as normal as someone from Fairy Tail can be, anyway."

"Cana!" Erza shrieked in embarrassment while burying her face in Alfonzo's chest.

"Seriously, Cana." Elicia said whith a wry smile on her face. "You could have been a little more tactful when you said that."

"Oh, whatever." Cana replied, rolling her eyes once again. "You're just as tired of seeing her act like this as I am, right?"

"Even if that's true, I would have said it differently." Elicia replied. "You could have said make love to her; you know."

"Elicia!" Erza shrieked again. Though, this time it was muffled as she had not raised her head from Alfonzo's chest.

Alfonzo, Elicia, and Cana could not help but laugh at Erza's insanely cute response. A moment later, however, Alfonzo stopped laughing. Then, he held her by the chin and gently raised her head until their eyes met again.

"If you want to do this, I don't mind. In fact, I'd be happy to do it." Alfonzo said in a soothing tone. "But if you're not ready, you don't have to force yourself just because of those two."

Hearing Alfonzo's gentle tone, Erza found herself getting lost in Alfonzo's grey eyes. Then, she subconsciously nodded her head.

In fact, it was not the case that Erza was not ready for a sexual relationship with Alfonzo. Quite the opposite, in fact. Instead, it was because she had a denial fetish. The fact that Elicia and Cana were getting it regularly while she wasn't, turned her on more than anyone could have imagined.

But after staring into Alfonzo's eyes, she finally decided, today would be the day that she lifted the lid on her desires.

"Yes, please make me yours, Alfonzo." Erza said with a smile.

Without another word, Alfonzo swept Erza off her feet in a princess carry. Then, he started taking large steps toward the master bedroom.

"Wait!" Erza said hurriedly. "I have a request."

"What's up?" Alfonzo asked, stopping his footsteps before reaching the door to Elicia's workstation.

On another note, The workshop Alfonzo and Elicia had forgotten when they designed the mansion, was recently completed as well. It was built in the backyard as its own building.

"I would like Elicia and Cana to show me how it is done before I join in." Erza said in a serious tone with a serious expression on her face that was ruined by the deep blush on her cheeks.

"Hey, Lici." Cana whispered. "Do you think she has the same kind of fetish as you do?"

"Who knows." Elicia replied with a shrug. "But I'm not gonna turn down the chance to get some Fonzie inside of me."

"*Sigh* You're like a totally different person when sex is involved." Cana said while shaking her head.

"And you and Fonzie love it." Elicia said, wrapping her arm around Cana's waist and pulling her toward Alfonzo and Erza.

"I never said I didn't." Cana replied with a smile.

Meanwhile, Alfonzo could only smile wryly.

"If that's what you want." Alfonzo said. "It's your birthday, after all."

"Thank you." Erza replied, the blush still present on her face. "[Requip: Seduction Armor]."

In the next instant, while still being held in Alfonzo's arms, Erza was covered in the light of her magic. When the light dimmed, her outfit had changed.

Now, instead of her usual outfit consisting of a white blouse and blue skirt combo, Erza was wearing a long, white apron with ties around her neck and back, and h nothing else covering her chest, revealing a large portion of her E-cup side boobs. On her arms were a pair of armored gauntlets that reached the middle of her biceps with pink, heart-shaped elbow guards and pink ribbons at the opening of each gauntlet.

On her lower body, Erza wore a pink thong, black stockings with pink lace, and no shoes. Rounding out the armor set, she held a sword with a golden blade, a dark yellow hand guard, a black and purple hilt, and a studded pommel. On the flat of the blade, the words, "Come on Boy." She also wore a frilly maid head dress on top of her head for good measure.

Seeing Erza's new outfit, Elicia smiled brightly.

"I get the feeling you were the one who created that armor, weren't you, Lici." Cana asked as she and Elicia followed behind Alfonzo.

"Yup!" Elicia replied energetically. "And Erza loved it from the moment she saw it."

"*Sigh* You two are perverts." Cana said with a smile.

Meanwhile, Alfonzo had restarted his steps after seeing Erza's new outfit. In fact, he even sped up. Using his [Metal Magic] he made the doors separating him from his current position and the bed open on their own. Then, when he arrived at the bed, he threw Erza on top of it, the whole while, he looked at her as if she were prey.

===R-18 Start===

"Wait!" Erza said as she noticed that Alfonzo was starting to undress. "I wanted Elicia and Cana to show me how it was done, remember?"

"Oh, I remember." Alfonzo said as he threw his shirt to the side. "But you'll be watching the show from right there."

At that moment, Elicia and Cana walked through the door. Then, after seeing the situation, they exchanged glances, nodded, and each took a place on one of Alfonzo's sides.

Alfonzo, on the other hand, had already lowered his pants to his ankles. Then, just as he stepped out of them, both Elicia and Cana grabbed his boxers and pulled them down swiftly. Naturally, this caused Alfonzo's already erect dick to pop up, pointing right toward Erza.

*Gulp!*

The sound of Erza swallowing her saliva could be heard by everyone in the room. However, they mostly ignored it. Instead, Elicia knelt down, Alfonzo turned toward her, letting Erza get a good look at just how long Alfonzo's dick was, and Cana moved between them, looking in Erza's direction.

Cana then grabbed Alfonzo's dick and started stroking it gently. At the same time, Elicia licked her lips. Then, she opened her mouth and engulf the head of Alfonzo's dick.

With an amazing amount of coordination, Elicia sucked Alfonzo's dick with loud slurping sounds. Meanwhile, Cana stroked everything that Elicia had not taken into her mouth.

Alfonzo did not remain idle, however. Instead, he reached to his side and removed Cana's bikini top. Then, he began rubbing, squeezing, and kneading Cana's large breasts. A moment later, he bent down a bit and took one of her nipples into his mouth.

"Mm~!" Cana moaned softly as she raised her free hand and grasped Alfonzo's dreads.

While all this was going on, Erza sat there, transfixed. Many times, she had heard the sounds and moans of pleasure that echoed through the mansion whenever Sun was not home. And she had imagined the sight in front of her many times as well. She had even substituted herself in Elicia and Cana's roles in her imagination. But this… was better than she had ever imagined.

Eventually, Alfonzo let go of Cana's breasts, after thoroughly showing both of them some love. Then, he reached down and pulled Elicia off his dick. A moment later, he had lifted her off the floor. Instinctively, Elicia wrapped her arms and legs around Alfonzo like a koala. Then, they started to kiss passionately.

As soon as Elicia's feet were no longer on the floor, Cana knelt down and lunged, mouth first, at Alfonzo's dick. Then, she started bobbing her head and sucking, perhaps even louder than Elicia. At the same time, she used her right hand to stroke Alfonzo's dick while fondling his balls with her left.

By now, Erza, for some reason, was seated in the seiza position with her hands resting on her thighs. And she could feel the wet patch on her underwear being transferred to her stocking clad feet and ankles that were under her butt.

Elicia, after kissing Alfonzo for around a minute, began climbing even higher on Alfonzo's body. First, using her arms, she raised herself so that Alfonzo's face waa right in front of her breasts. And without hesitation, Alfonzo sucked on them while his hands gripped and squeezed her ass.

Meanwhile, Cana was taking Alfonzo's dick deeper and deeper into her throat every time she bobbed her head.

Then, once Elicia felt that both of her breasts and nipples had been showered with enough love, she unwrapped her legs from around Alfonzo's torso. She then performed a handstand on his shoulders. A moment later, she spread her legs, causing her skirt to bunch up at her hips, as she lowered herself so that she was sitting on his shoulders with her pussy right in his face.

In response, Alfonzo once again gripped Elicia's ass, holding her steady. Then, using his teeth, he moved Elicia's panties to the side before he extended his tongue and licked from the bottom to the top of her slit, stimulating her clit at the end.

"Ahn~~~!" Elicia moaned as she grabbed two handfuls of Alfonzo's hair. "Just like that, eat me up, Daddy."

On top of that, by now Cana no longer had her hands on Alfonzo's dick or balls. Instead, her hands were holding onto his ass as she used them to brace herself every time she bobbed up and down on his dick. Now, whenever she pulled back, only the head would be left in her mouth. And every time she pushed forward, her nose would touch his pelvic bone.

Thanks to Cana's fantastic deepthroat blowjob, on top of licking and sucking Elicia's pussy, Alfonzo also grunted and moaned into it repeatedly, causing the extra stimulation to cause Elicia to reach her first climax relatively quickly.

"Ahh~~~~~!" Elicia screamed with her legs tightening around Alfonzo's head as her back arched with her orgasm.

Then, while she was still riding the high of her orgasm, Alfonzo unwrapped Elicia's legs from around his head before throwing her on the bed, right next to Erza.

Once his hands were no longer occupied with holding Elicia steady, he reached down and grabbed Cana's head. This naturally caused Cana to look up at him. Then, after seeing an approving glint in Cana's eyes, Alfonzo face fucked her, causing Cana to gag repeatedly while her eyes rolled back in her head.

Eventually, Alfonzo reached his limit. However, before he could push his dick deep into Cana's throat and release his seed, Cana stopped him. Then, she pulled back until just the tip of his dick was in her mouth and started stroking him once again.

"Hmph!" Alfonzo grunted as he filled Cana's mouth with his cum.

Amazingly, Cana did not spill even a drop. Then, as soon as Alfonzo was done, Cana stood up with her mouth full, turned toward the bed, and crawled up next to Elicia. Then, after glancing at Erza, she leaned down and started kissing Elicia, swapping Alfonzo's cum between them in the process.

Meanwhile, Alfonzo had approached Cana from behind. Then, without taking them off completely, Alfonzo lowered Cana's pants and thong. He then activated the anti-accident sigil before slamming balls deep into Cana's pussy.

"Oh~~~! Fuck~~~!" Cana groaned as she broke the kiss with Elicia.

Pulling his hips back, Alfonzo slammed into Cana once again after only the tip of his dick was inside of her. And he repeated the process, raising his pace with each thrust. And with each thrust, Cana's moans grew in volume, as well.

Meanwhile, Elicia had started quickly taking off her clothes. Then, once she was completely naked, she turned toward Erza.

"The show's much better up close, isn't it?" Elicia said playfully as she saw the lust and desire in Erza's eyes. "If you want, you can take my turn next."

"No." Alfonzo said while still pounding into Cana.

Alfonzo's immediate denial caused Erza to shiver. At the same time, her blush somehow intensified even further. She also felt the wet patch on her underwear and feet get even worse.

"She said she wanted both of you to show her how it's done." Alfonzo continued. "And that's what she's gonna get."

Alfonzo's denial was actually a test. He had a feeling that Erza was a masochist, at least a little. So, he tried denying her. And when he saw the way she shivered, he knew that his guess was right. If she had shown even an ounce of disappointment, he would have back tracked on his words immediately, though.

Like that, Alfonzo continued to pound into Cana for the next fifteen minutes. And at some point, Elicia had taken a spot in front of Cana and forced Cana's face into her breasts. Naturally, Cana reciprocated by licking and sucking the nipples Elicia force fed her.

During those fifteen minutes, sweat covered Cana's body. And as her breasts swayed, the sweat that dripped down to her nipples was flung all over. And when Alfonzo eventually filled her with his cum, she arched her back and froze in that position.

"Ahn~~~~~~~~~! I'm cumming again!" Cana screamed as she came for the fourth time.

Then, without a word, Alfonzo pulled his dick, still covered in his cum and Cana's juices, out of Cana. H then he laid on his back with his head pointing at Erza.

Meanwhile, Elicia laid Cana down to the side. Then, she crawled over to Alfonzo. A moment later, she took Alfonzo's whole dick into her mouth, cleaning off all the fluids that clung to it.

*Pop!*

Once she felt that she had gotten everything, leaving only her saliva on Alfonzo's dick, she released it with a pop. Then she climbed on top of Alfonzo, smiled at him seductively, lined up her pussy to accept his dick, and slammed her hips down, taking the whole thing inside of her.

"Mmm~~~~!" Elicia moaned in pleasure.

Before Elicia could raise herself and start bouncing up and down, Alfonzo grabbed her waist. Elicia then looked at Alfonzo with confusion. Smiling back in response, Alfonzo planted his feet squarely on the bed. Then, he looked back, straight into Erza's eyes.

Maintaining eye contact with Erza, Alfonzo started drilling up into Elicia with everything he had.

"Oh~~~! Yes!" Elicia screamed as Alfonzo started pounding her. "Fuck me! Harder! Fuck me harder!"

Elicia's pleasure filled screams echoed through the mansion. This time, however, there was no one to listen in another room since everyone in the house was currently in the same bed.

About a minute later, Cana finally came down from her last orgasm. Then, with shaky limbs, she pulled her thong and pants off, threw them to the floor, and crawled over to Alfonzo and Elicia. Positioning herself between Alfonzo's legs, she reached around Elicia and began fondling her breasts and giving her nipples the occasional pinch.

"Ahn~~~~!" Elicia moaned even louder thanks to the extra stimulation.

"You're next." Cana said to Erza from over Elicia's shoulder.

By this time, Erza's juices had completely soaked not only her panties and her feet, but they had even created a wet patch on the sheets underneath her. However, although she heard what Cana had to say, she was unable to break eye contact with Alfonzo, once again being drawn into his grey eyes.

Twenty minutes later, Elicia was still being bounced up and down by Alfonzo's powerful thrusts. And by now, she was incapable of putting together a coherent thought. Her eyes had rolled back, her tongue was hanging out of her mouth, and her body was dripping sweat. At the same time, Cana had continued her assault on her breasts and nipples. She had even lost track of how many times she had cum after the fifth time.

Eventually, Alfonzo grunted as he reached his limit. However, Elicia was so exhausted that she could not even scream. Instead, once she was filled up, she just flopped to the side and shuddered violently.

As soon as Elicia went down, Cana laid her to the side, just as Elicia had done for her earlier. Then, also like Elicia, she crawled over to Alfonzo and cleaned him up. But unlike Elicia, she did not climb on top of him. Instead, she stared at Erza.

"Now, Erza, it's your turn." Cana said, crawling over to Erza.

As soon as Cana arrived in front of Erza, she pushed her backward, causing her to lay on her back on the bed.

"Oh, would you look at this." Cana said in a playful tone. "Someone is really excited, isn't she?"

Cana was referring to the wet patch on the bedding where Erza had just been sitting. Naturally, this caused Erza to blush just as red as her hair.

At the same time, Alfonzo had climbed up to his knees and approached Erza, spreading her legs as he drew near. Then, he too noticed the wet patch.

"Hmm… Looks like you enjoyed the show." Alfonzo said, making eye contact with Erza once again. "Maybe I should have another round with Lici and Cana before I get to you."

That statement caused Erza to shiver once again. Although the thought excited her, she felt that she had reached her limit. Her pussy was craving fulfillment like no other time in her life. And she did not think she would be able to stop herself from touching herself for much longer.

"No, please…" Erza said in a begging tone. "I need it right now."

Alfonzo only smiled in response. Internally, however, he was fist pumping happily. The fact that he made a girl, who clearly enjoyed pleasure denial, beg him to fuck her was a serious confidence boost.

"Well, if you insist." Alfonzo said, reaching down and gripping the sides of Erza's thong. "You are the birthday girl, after all."

Then, as Alfonzo pulled Erza's thong down her legs, she instinctively raised her legs to make it easier for him. However, once Alfonzo pulled the thong off her feet, Cana grabbed her ankles just before they could fall to the bed.

"Cana, what are you doing?" Erza asked in a confused tone.

Instead of responding immediately, Cana pressed Erza's feet together. Then, she held them with one hand. After that, she positioned herself at Erza's head. Then, using her free hand, she raised Erza's head and placed it on her thighs before grabbing her ankles with both hands and pulling her legs back as far as she could.

"Helping you have the experience of a lifetime." Cana replied. "now, make her a woman, Fonzie. There's no need for foreplay."

Instead of responding with words, Alfonzo simply lined himself up to enter Erza. The, he slowly pushed his dick inside her.

"Mmm~~~~!" Erza stifled a groan of pain and pleasure as she was penetrated for the first time, ever.

In fact, Erza had never even masturbated, a feat that was getting harder and harder as she overheard Alfonzo, Elicia, and Cana's sessions of love making on a regular basis. But now, all that patience was finally paying off. She could; feel her first ever orgasm coming from Alfonzo's slow penetration.

Alfonzo could feel that Erza was about to cum as well. So, he stopped moving completely, causing Erza to look up at him with confusion. However, instead of looking at Erza, he leaned forward and kissed Cana, who was holding Erza's feet next to her head.

From there, a slow game of cat and mouse started. With Erza getting to the verge of climax and Alfonzo stopping all movement when he felt her vaginal walls contracting around his dick too much.

Eventually, after about five minutes, Alfonzo had pushed inside of Erza as far as he could. Then, he broke the kiss with Cana and looked down at Erza. By now, she was panting like a dog in heat and her skin was shining with a sheen of sweat.

"Are you ready, Erza?" Alfonzo asked in a teasing tone.

"Mmm~~~~!" A moan sounded from the side before Erza could respond.

Looking in the direction the moan came from, Alfonzo, Cana, and Erza saw Elicia with her legs spread wide open, her left hand massaging her right breast, and her right hand's middle and ring finger plunging in and out of her pussy at high speed.

Feeling the gazes on her, Elicia looked at their sources and shrugged her shoulders without slowing down her hand movements.

"What?" Elicia asked in an excited tone. "This is so~~~ hot. I couldn't help myself."

At the same time, while Erza was distracted Alfonzo had slowly pulled his dick out until just the head was still inside of her. Then, as soon as her attention was back on him, Alfonzo slammed his dick back in.

"Ahh~~~~~~~~~~!" Erza screamed, reaching an orgasm immediately.

Though Erza's eyes rolled back and she started shivering, Alfonzo did not give her time to recover. Instead, he started pounding her relentlessly, doing his best to extend the time of her orgasm. And as time went by, Erza's apron bunched together in the valley between her breasts. Plus, the sight of Erza's breasts shaking violently, sprinkling sweat with every thrust, kept him going as well.

Pounding Erza with such a high intensity on her first time undoubtedly caused her some pain. However, going by her facial expression, she welcomed it.

Another side effect of going at it with such force was Alfonzo reached his limit much faster than his rounds with Cana and Elicia. So, in only ten minutes, Alfonzo emptied his load inside of Erza, who passed out immediately from the over stimulation.

"I think I over did it." Alfonzo muttered as he pulled out of the unconscious Erza.

Leaning forward, Cana cleaned up Alfonzo once again. Then, when she was done, she straightened her back again and smiled at him seductively.

"She'll wake up before too long." Cana said after licking her lips.

"Yeah, let's just keep going until she wakes up." Elicia said, crawling over to the rest of the group. "then, we'll rinse and repeat."

In the end, all four of them were to tired to attend the morning training the next day.