[This will be in 3rd Pov. It's my first try so it might not be good, so if you would just please try bearing it for a couple of chapters.]
{Present Time}
"Why did you stop?" I asked him.
"... Allen I don't think I can do it…" Peter seemed disputed about something.
"Is it something related to the decision you made at that time…?" I asked him.
"...?!" he shivered but soon regained his composure.
"Tell me what happened next," I said.
"I-I can't…" he covered his face but that isn't going to stop me.
"Peter, you have to say it." I said, "That's your redemption. Don't you also want to get redemption? Don't you want to free yourself from this… suffering that has been eating you from inside?"
"..."
"I know you have been holding it inside for far too long," I said, "It's time to let it go."
"..." his silence didn't mean anything to me. I just want this to end quickly.