Aarvi is the key

At the police station,

Father Fisher did his everything but found no way to bring Naomi out. He had plans to talk out with the Brown family and settle things outside but the Rivas family, he had no power against them.

Having no choice, he called his father to request him to speak to Jordan and the Rivas family to convince Aarvi and Aaron to take the case back.

After relaying all the information, he requested his father, "Dad, I know what she did was wrong but we should give her a chance to redeem. Dad we can't let our family reputation ruin if this leaks out. Please do something, please ask Elder Rivas to talk to Aaron. If you talk to him, Aaron will definitely listen to you. Dad…"