One reason is the tension and conflict that arise from the mismatch. It creates suspense as readers wonder how the situation will be resolved. Also, the character development and growth throughout the story are quite captivating.
To write an 'enigmatic return novel', you need to build suspense throughout the story. For example, when the character returns, don't reveal all their motives at once. Let the readers wonder why they are really back. Also, introduce some enigmatic side characters who seem to know more than they let on. They can drop hints and add to the overall mystery of the return.
Suppose the crossword clue in the 'Enigmatic Puzzle' story is 'A building where people pray'. There are many possible answers such as 'church', 'mosque' or 'temple'. It depends on the context of the crossword. If it's a crossword with a more Western - centric theme, 'church' might be more likely. If it's more general or global, all three could be valid answers. You need to look at other intersecting words in the crossword to be more certain.
A woman in a story can be enigmatic if she has a mysterious past. For example, if no one knows where she grew up or who her family is. It could also be her actions. If she does things that are unexpected or hard to understand, like leaving town suddenly without explanation. Another factor could be her appearance. If she dresses in a unique or strange way that gives off an air of mystery.
One example could be 'The Return of the Native' by Thomas Hardy. It has an enigmatic quality as the characters' fates seem to be guided by both their own choices and some mysterious forces of nature and society.
I'm not sure as the name doesn't give much away about the characters. It could be a character who has been away for a long time and is now coming back, like a prodigal son or daughter.
I'm not sure specifically as I haven't read it. It could be about a mysterious return of a character or an event. Maybe it involves a character coming back to a place or a situation in an unexpected and puzzling way.