discipline spanking from mom stories

One story I heard was that a boy kept lying about doing his homework. His mom warned him several times but he didn't listen. Finally, she gave him a spanking. After that, he realized his mistake and started to be honest about his schoolwork.

In the stories, one effect is that it makes the child immediately aware of their wrong behavior. For example, like the boy who lied about homework, the spanking was a shock that made him see he couldn't keep getting away with it.

No. Spanking can cause physical and emotional harm to children. There are better ways to teach discipline, like positive reinforcement. When children are rewarded for good behavior, they are more likely to repeat it. Also, talking and explaining why certain actions are wrong is more effective in the long run than spanking.

No. Physical punishment like spanking is not a good approach. A child's academic performance can be influenced by many factors. Instead of punishing, mom could work with the child to figure out the difficulties in study, like if there are problems in understanding certain subjects. Maybe get a tutor or create a better study environment at home.

One alternative is positive reinforcement. For example, when the son does something good, like cleaning his room without being asked, the mom can give him a small reward like an extra half - hour of playtime. This encourages the child to repeat the good behavior.

Yes. In a positive story, spanking can be a form of discipline when it's done in a very mild and controlled way. For example, if a daughter does something really dangerous like running into the street without looking, a light spank can immediately get her attention and make her realize the seriousness of her actions. But it should always be followed by explanation and love.

I don't think spanking from a teacher is appropriate. Teachers should be role models of positive behavior and non - violent communication. Instead of spanking, they can use methods like creating a behavior contract with the student. This way, the student is involved in the process of improving their behavior and learns self - discipline in a more positive environment. Also, spanking can lead to resentment and a damaged relationship between the teacher and the student.

One story could be that a boy was caught stealing cookies from the cookie jar. His mom, in an old - fashioned way, gave him a spanking. She then sat him down and explained why stealing was wrong, not just because it was against the rules but also because it was unethical. After that, the boy learned his lesson and never stole again.

Yes, they are relatively common in some cultures or families. In the past, spanking was more accepted as a form of discipline. Moms might spank their children when they misbehaved, like when they lied or were disrespectful. However, nowadays, many people are against this form of punishment as it can have negative impacts on a child's mental health.

In my opinion, spanking discipline stories are not effective. Children are more likely to respond positively to positive reinforcement, like praise and rewards. When they hear spanking discipline stories, they may just feel scared rather than truly understanding the right and wrong. It doesn't help in building their internal moral compass in a healthy way.