I think it depends on how it's done. If it's written in a way that is more about exploring the psychological impact and the resilience of the character, and not just for shock value, it could be considered a valid form of fan - created content. But if it's gratuitous torture with no real purpose other than to be cruel, then it's not ethical. We should respect the integrity of the character and the feelings of the fans who care about her.
Hermione's resilience can also be shown by her not breaking down easily. She might endure the pain and still taunt Bellatrix, showing that she is not afraid. This could be portrayed by her making sarcastic remarks despite the torture. Another way is that after the torture, she quickly recovers and is more determined than ever to fight back.
Hermione might resist by trying to escape. She could look for weaknesses in the place where she is being tortured. If there are any magical objects or elements around, she might try to use them to her advantage. Also, she could try to form an emotional bond with Bellatrix in a strange way. By appealing to Bellatrix's possible humanity or some shared experience within the wizarding world, she hopes to make Bellatrix stop the torture. However, this is a very risky move as Bellatrix is known for her cruelty.
It makes the story's tone much darker. Hermione being tortured is a very cruel and disturbing event. It can heighten the sense of danger in the plot. For example, it might make Harry and Ron more determined to fight against the Death Eaters. It also shows the brutality of the villains like Bellatrix.
Well, it can have a huge impact. It often adds a great deal of darkness and tension. It might change the way other characters view the situation in the story. For example, it could make Harry and Ron more determined to fight against the Death Eaters. It also shows the brutality of the bad guys, in this case Bellatrix, and makes the readers feel more sympathy for Hermione. This event can be a turning point in the fic, leading to different character developments and plot twists.
One alternative could be exploring her dealing with difficult moral dilemmas. For example, she might have to make a choice between saving a friend or following a strict rule. This would add depth to her character without involving torture. Another option is to have her face her fears in a more psychological way, like dealing with the fear of failure or not being good enough. It can create tension and a darker mood without being overly cruel.
There's also 'Shadows of Pain'. Here, Draco is tortured as a form of punishment for not following Voldemort's orders strictly. The story focuses on how he endures the pain and how his relationship with Hermione starts to develop in the midst of this chaos. It's a dark and somewhat gritty take on the Dramione pairing with a lot of emotional turmoil.
Living with Bellatrix would be a terrifying experience for Hermione. However, she would rely on her wits. She would probably keep her Gryffindor courage in check and act more like a Slytherin, being cunning and sly. She might start to understand Bellatrix's insecurities and use them to her benefit. For instance, if Bellatrix is insecure about her standing among the Death Eaters, Hermione could offer advice that seems helpful but actually undermines Bellatrix's loyalty to Voldemort. And she would constantly be on the lookout for any signs of kindness or humanity in Bellatrix, hoping to use it as a way to change the situation.
One popular fanfiction that might include such a scene could be 'The Darkest of Bonds'. In this fic, their interactions are complex and full of tension. However, it's important to note that fanfictions vary greatly in quality and content.
Yes, it is a somewhat popular trope. Some fans are intrigued by the idea of pairing such contrasting characters. Bellatrix is a dark and complex Death Eater, while Hermione is a brilliant and moral Gryffindor. The marriage concept often involves exploring how their different backgrounds and personalities could interact, with some fanfictions delving into a redemption arc for Bellatrix through her relationship with Hermione.