Mystery itself could be a theme. The very idea of a 'shady plot' implies that there are things not immediately known or understood. There may also be a theme of discovery as the characters try to uncover what's really going on. Additionally, there might be a theme of trust, as the characters have to decide who to trust in the midst of all the mystery and deception.
A reader loved by a yandere Elsie fanfic is likely to be very empathetic. They can put themselves in the shoes of the characters in the story, especially those involved with the yandere Elsie. This reader would also be interested in exploring the psychological aspects of the yandere character. They don't shy away from the twisted love and the potential danger that comes with it, instead, they are intrigued by how the story unfolds around such a character. They might also be fans of stories with high - intensity drama and strong emotions.
I haven't actually read this specific 'A Shady Plot by Elsie Brown'. But if it's like many stories with a'shady' plot, it might start with an ordinary situation that soon takes on a strange or unsettling quality. There could be secrets hidden within the story's world, whether it's secrets about a person, a place, or an event. As the story progresses, the protagonist might be drawn deeper into this web of mystery, facing challenges and revelations along the way.
To be loved in the context of a yandere Elsie fanfic, a reader should first show respect for the character of Elsie. Understand her yandere nature and don't simply dismiss it as 'crazy'.
Perhaps the story is about the daily life in Varrock. She could talk about the merchants in the market, the different kinds of goods they sell, and how they interact with the customers. It might also be about the local guilds, like the smithing guild, and the skills people learn there.