The complex characters. In detective novels, there are often well - developed characters, both the detectives and the suspects. Those who enjoy this genre might be attracted to these complex portrayals.
The sense of justice. Detective novels usually end with the truth being revealed and justice being served. This can be very satisfying for readers who reportedly enjoy detective novels as it gives a feeling of order being restored in a chaotic world.
There could be many people. For example, Arthur Conan Doyle, who created Sherlock Holmes, must have had an affinity for detective novels as he wrote such great ones. He might be among those who reportedly enjoyed this genre.
Maybe they had a bad experience related to the ideas in romance novels, like a broken heart and they associate the genre with false hopes.
Perhaps some people with very conservative views might consider reading novels a waste of time and thus label it as 'guilty'. They might believe that one should focus only on more 'productive' or 'practical' activities. But this view is quite narrow - minded.
One reason could be to protect a family member's reputation. For example, if a family member made a mistake at work and it could lead to public shame, another might take the blame to shield them from that. Another reason is to maintain family harmony. If a younger family member is at fault and taking the blame from the parents would prevent a big argument or family rift, an older one might do it.
One possible reason could be as a form of punishment. For example, if a character has been misbehaving in a way that is considered inappropriate for their gender, magic might transform them to teach them a lesson. Another reason could be an accident. Maybe a young wizard was practicing a spell and it went wrong, resulting in the transformation. Or it could be a magical curse placed on someone because of a feud between families or kingdoms.
Maybe she falls in love with someone who truly understands her on a deeper level than her previous relationships. This person might be more attuned to her dreams and fears, and she decides to marry them for that deep emotional connection.
In some stories, it could be due to a magic spell. Just like in fairy tales, a wicked witch or an inexperienced wizard might accidentally cast a spell that changes a person's gender. Another reason could be a scientific experiment. Scientists might be trying to do something revolutionary like gender transformation through some new technology, but things go wrong and a male turns into a girl.
One reason could be to gain sympathy. Some people might feel that by sharing a sad story, others will be more lenient towards them or give them special treatment. Another reason could be to avoid criticism. If they hide behind a sad story, it's harder for others to point out their flaws or mistakes.
One possible reason could be for personal glory. They might want to seem like a hero or have an exciting adventure to share when in reality they didn't experience it. Another reason could be to gain sympathy or attention. Maybe they feel overlooked in their normal life and think a fabricated war story will make people focus on them.
One reason could be to gain sympathy. People might think that by sharing a sad story, others will be more likely to pity them and give them special treatment. For example, in a work situation, an employee might hide behind a sad story to get an extension on a project deadline without facing any consequences.