Tickle Me Elmo is a beloved childhood toy for many. So when it's the center of a scary story, it plays on our memories and emotions. The contrast between the happy memories associated with the toy and the new, scary elements introduced in the story is what makes it so creepy. Also, the physical features of the doll, like its big eyes and plush body, can be made to look quite menacing when described in a spooky context.
One scary 'Tickle Me Elmo' story could be that at night, a little girl heard strange giggles coming from her Tickle Me Elmo doll. When she went to check, the doll's eyes were glowing red. She tried to turn it off but it just kept giggling louder and louder until she ran out of the room in fear.
The contrast. We are used to seeing Elmo as a friendly and cute character from Sesame Street. When we put him in a scary situation, like a haunted place or being chased by an unknown entity, it creates a sense of unease because it goes against our normal perception of him.
Atmosphere is key. If a story is set in a dark, isolated place like a cemetery at midnight or an abandoned castle, it immediately sets a creepy mood. The description of the setting, like the cold wind blowing through the broken windows of the castle and the howling of wolves in the distance, adds to the scariness.
The unknown. In a creepy man story, often we don't know his motives. For example, if a man is just lurking in the shadows, we don't know if he's going to harm someone or not. It creates a sense of unease.
Well, first of all, its appearance is quite scary. If it has long, spindly fingers or slimy tentacles like in the stories, that's not a pleasant sight. Also, it often attacks unexpectedly. Just like when Tom entered the abandoned house, he had no idea the tickle monster was there waiting for him. And it doesn't seem to have any mercy. It keeps on tickling its victims until they are completely terrified or pass out, like what happened to Jack when he was in the forest.
The sense of powerlessness. In a tickle monster horror story, the victims often can't escape or fight back. The tickle monster has an upper hand. For example, if it tickles you until you can't breathe or until you pass out, there's nothing you can do. It's like being at the mercy of a cruel force that you can't control, and that makes it really frightening.
The Bunnyman Bridge story is so creepy because it combines the ordinary with the abnormal. A bridge is a common place, but when you add a man in a bunny suit who might be a deranged escaped patient, it becomes something very frightening. The idea that this could be a real - life situation, that someone might be out there in that bunny suit, waiting, is what makes it so scary. Also, the fact that it's often associated with the night, when our fears are amplified, adds to the overall creepiness.
Some say that there was a 'Tickle Me Elmo' that seemed to move on its own when no one was looking. A family had the doll in their living room. One day, they came home to find the doll in a different position, and when it was tickled, it let out a scream instead of a laugh. This made the family very scared and they got rid of the doll immediately.
The unknown nature of it. We don't really understand how reincarnation could work, if it does at all. So when someone claims to remember a past life with such vivid details, it's unnerving. For example, a child remembering a life as an adult in a different era is just so strange.
The element of the unknown. In these stories, there are often things that can't be easily explained. For example, strange noises or apparitions that defy logic.