How was 'American Dirt' received in Oprah's Book Club as a novel?
The reception of 'American Dirt' in Oprah's Book Club was complex. On one hand, it had a large audience due to Oprah's influence. People were initially interested in the story it promised about the migrant journey. But as more people read it, criticism grew. There were issues with how the Mexican - American culture was depicted. Some felt it was more of a white - washed version. Also, the writing was seen by some as not up to the mark for such a serious and complex topic. So, overall, it got a lot of both praise and criticism.
When 'American Dirt' entered Oprah's Book Club as a novel, it was met with a storm of reactions. At first, there was excitement as Oprah's picks often draw attention. But soon, the flaws started to surface. Critics pointed out that the novel seemed to rely on stereotypes at times. The story, while aiming to be poignant about the migrant experience, came across as inauthentic to some. However, there were also those who defended it, saying that it at least started a conversation about an important issue. So, it was a very polarizing reception.
It was received with mixed reactions. Some readers really liked it as it told a story that they hadn't really been exposed to much before, about the hardships of migrants. But others were critical. They thought it didn't do justice to the real experiences of migrants and was a bit too simplistic in its approach.