A common plot is that the reader is a loner or an outcast, just like Jeff in a way. Jeff becomes intrigued by the reader and starts to follow them. The story then unfolds as the reader discovers Jeff's presence and tries to either befriend him (which is a very dangerous idea) or get away from him. There could also be a plot where the reader has some kind of special ability or knowledge that Jeff wants, so he tries to get it from them. This often leads to a cat - and - mouse type of situation.
One interesting plot could be the reader moving into a new neighborhood where Jeff the Killer is rumored to lurk. The reader starts experiencing strange things like seeing a pale face in the window at night. Another plot might involve the reader being kidnapped by Jeff and having to find a way to escape while also trying to understand his motives. There could also be a plot where the reader is a detective trying to solve the mystery of Jeff the Killer and ends up getting too close to him.
Well, sometimes the plot is about the reader having a pre - existing connection to Jeff the Killer without knowing it. For example, they might have met him when they were younger and something happened that made him turn into what he is now. Or, the story could be about the reader being in a situation where they have to face their own fears and Jeff represents that ultimate fear. They have to outwit him to survive. It could also be a story where the reader is part of a group that is being hunted by Jeff and they all have to work together to fend him off.
The relationship can be portrayed as a terrifying one. Jeff could be seen as a predator and the reader as his prey. He might stalk the reader, leaving little signs of his presence to scare them. For example, he could leave a bloody knife on their doorstep.
One interesting plot could be Jeff and Ben teaming up to face a common enemy in the Creepypasta world. Maybe a new, more powerful and menacing entity emerges that threatens their 'territory' or way of existence, and they have to put aside their differences to fight it.
In some fanfictions, there might be a plot where Ben has to save Jeff from a dangerous situation. For example, Jeff gets trapped in a haunted place and Ben, with his unique abilities, comes to his rescue. It could involve a lot of spooky encounters and tense moments as Ben tries to find and free Jeff.
Another plot might involve a love - hate relationship. Pinkamena and Jeff the Killer could start off hating each other due to their different natures. But as the story progresses, they gradually find some common ground and start to have some strange feelings towards each other. This kind of complex relationship can add a lot of drama to the fanfiction.
One interesting plot could be them teaming up against a common enemy in the creepy world they inhabit. Maybe a new and more menacing slasher figure shows up, and they have to put aside their differences to fight it.
One interesting plot could be their unexpected alliance. Maybe they are forced to team up against a greater evil in the fanfic. This would create a lot of tension as they have their own issues with each other but have to put them aside for the common good.
Well, themes like fear and survival are really common. The reader is usually in a fight - or - flight situation when dealing with Jeff. Also, there can be themes of mystery, as the reader tries to understand Jeff's motives and what makes him tick. Sometimes, there are also themes of forbidden love, in a very twisted way, as the reader might develop an unexpected connection with the killer.
One common theme is fear. Since Jeff the killer is a horror character, the fanfictions often play on the reader's fear of him. Another theme is the idea of an unlikely connection. For example, the reader might be drawn to Jeff's dark side in some way.
A different plotline could be set in an alternate universe where Jeff and Nina are not killers. They meet in a more normal setting, like a school or a small town. However, their dark pasts or tendencies start to surface, and they have to deal with how this affects their new - found relationship, all while trying to keep their true selves hidden from the people around them.
Another theme is an unexpected connection or relationship development. Despite Jeff's murderous nature, some fanfictions explore how he and the male reader might form a bond. This could be due to the male reader seeing a different side of Jeff that no one else has, leading to a complex and often angsty relationship.