Maybe they're just not into the whole magic and wizardry thing. Some people prefer more realistic stories.
Perhaps they don't fully understand the depth of the world - building. They might see all the magic and think it's just some random, crazy ideas thrown together like in a not - so - well - thought - out fanfic.
Perhaps they haven't fully understood the series. Some people might just skim through the books or movies and miss out on the depth. They could be focusing on just the surface elements like the magic spells and not realizing the complex relationships and themes beneath.
Perhaps they've come across some really strange fan - created stories. Some fanfictions can be very out there with their interpretations of the wizarding world.
The 'Harry Potter' series is much more than what the wrong statement implies. It has a complex family tree of characters, a detailed history of the wizarding world, and a well - developed magic system. There are also important social and political aspects within the story, like the relationship between wizards and muggles. All these aspects show that it is a sophisticated work of fiction, not a toy fanfiction at all.
The idea that 'harry potter is silly fanfiction' is completely wrong. J.K. Rowling created a whole new universe with its own rules, cultures, and histories. The characters are multi - dimensional, evolving throughout the series. Harry's journey from an orphan boy to a hero is full of growth and self - discovery. The magic in the books is not just for show; it serves as a metaphor for power and its proper use. And the story has inspired generations of readers and even led to a whole new wave of interest in fantasy literature. It's a masterpiece, not 'silly fanfiction'.
Great writing skills, for starters. If someone can write in a way that feels like it could be part of the original Harry Potter series, that's a big plus. Also, being able to create new and exciting storylines that don't feel out of place in the wizarding world.
Maybe they want to emphasize the purity of the original 'Harry Potter' story. They don't want it to be confused with the many fan - made stories out there.
One reason could be that they feel the official Harry Potter story has a defined end, and the fighting in fanfiction is just over - done. They want to focus on the original tale's conclusion.
Maybe they just want to be controversial. Some people like to make extreme and untrue statements to get attention.
Well, a true magic fan in Harry Potter fanfiction would really understand the magical elements deeply. They'd know all about the spells, like how Wingardium Leviosa works, not just on a surface level. They'd also be into the different magical creatures, from the cute Nifflers to the majestic Hippogriffs. And they'd understand the significance of magic in the wizarding world's society, like how magic is used in education at Hogwarts.