One of the scariest is 'Jeff the Killer'. The idea of a deranged, pale-faced killer with a permanent smile carved into his face is truly horrifying. He's often depicted stalking his victims in the dead of night.
Another is 'Ben Drowned'. It involves a haunted Majora's Mask cartridge. The story goes that the character Ben, who is a corrupted version of Link, haunts the game. Strange glitches and messages occur when the cartridge is played, and it gives the feeling of being in a real - life horror scenario.
The 'Slenderman' story is also quite disturbing. A tall, faceless figure in a black suit that preys on children and those who wander into the woods. The way it can seemingly appear out of nowhere and its association with missing children cases makes it a very creepy story.
One really terrifying story from 'creepypasta true scary stories' is about the 'Smile Dog'. It's said that once you see the picture of this dog with a really creepy, wide smile, it will haunt you. People who've seen it reported having nightmares and a feeling of being constantly watched.
The Hinterkaifeck murders in Germany are quite terrifying. An entire family was brutally killed on their farm, and there were strange occurrences before the murders, like footprints in the snow leading to an empty barn. No one was ever really convicted of the crime, and the mystery adds to the creepiness.
The 'Slenderman' Creepypasta is also well - known. He is a tall, faceless figure in a suit that preys on children. His appearance in the woods and his ability to teleport make him extremely terrifying. There are many stories about people who encounter him and the horrors that follow.
Well, in '20 most terrifying horror stories', there could be a story of a small town haunted by an ancient evil. The townspeople start experiencing unexplainable phenomena like animals acting strangely and people disappearing. There might also be a horror story about a group of friends who go camping in a forest that has a dark history. They encounter something that hunts them down one by one. Additionally, a story about a possessed doll that seems to have a life of its own and causes chaos in a family's home is also a possibility.
The unknown. In creepypasta, a lot of the entities are not fully explained. For example, Slenderman. His faceless nature and his ability to just appear and disappear make him very scary. We don't know his motives fully.
One of the scariest is probably the story of 'Jeff the Killer'. His pale face, cut - in smile, and the whole idea of him stalking people at night is truly horrifying.
The story of the Donner Party is also extremely terrifying. A group of settlers got stranded in the mountains during winter. Due to lack of food, they resorted to cannibalism to survive. It shows the extreme desperation and horror that humans can face in dire situations.
The back story of Eyeless Jack is really terrifying. He was once a normal medical student. However, he got involved in some sort of cult sacrifice and had his eyes removed. Now he has empty sockets and a craving for human organs, especially kidneys. He stalks his victims at night, using his enhanced senses to hunt them down.
A very terrifying creepypasta name is 'The Rake'. The Rake is a human - like creature with pale skin and large black eyes. It is often described as being very fast and agile. Its story tells of it attacking people at night, usually while they are sleeping. It will scratch at doors and windows before breaking in and harming its victims. People who have 'encountered' it in these stories often wake up to find it hovering over them, and they are powerless to stop it.
There's a story where a girl keeps seeing a figure in her peripheral vision. Every time she tries to look directly at it, it disappears. As the story progresses, the figure gets closer and closer until she's in real danger. It's the kind of story that makes you check over your shoulder.