The main problem would be the clash of genres. Harry Potter is a family - friendly fantasy, while Annabelle is horror. This would make it difficult to target a specific audience. Also, the two have different mythologies. Harry Potter has its own set of rules about magic, while Annabelle has the idea of a haunted doll. Mixing them would create a confusing and inconsistent story.
There would be numerous issues. The fanfiction would likely alienate fans of both original works. Harry Potter fans expect a certain kind of magical adventure, and Annabelle fans are looking for horror thrills. Combining them would not only violate the integrity of each original work but also create a Frankenstein - like story that fails to satisfy either group. The world - building of Harry Potter is complex and detailed, and that of Annabelle is simple yet distinctively horror - based. Merging these two worlds would require a great deal of contortion that would probably not result in a coherent or enjoyable story.
It would distort the original image of the Harry Potter universe. The series is about magic, not polygamous relationships.
A 'harry potter is hannibal lecter fanfiction' would be a radical departure from the original series. Picture Harry Potter in the role of a predator, using his knowledge of the wizarding world in ways similar to how Hannibal Lecter uses his knowledge of the human psyche. The Forbidden Forest could become a hunting ground, and the houses at Hogwarts could be divided not by values but by a hierarchy of power and manipulation. The story would be filled with moral ambiguity, as Harry's actions would be far from the heroic deeds in the original. It would be a complex and disturbing re - imagining that would shock and perhaps disgust many fans of the original Harry Potter series.
Imagine a fanfiction where the Annabelle doll has been brought into the wizarding world. It could be smuggled into Hogwarts by a Death Eater - like figure who wants to use it to undermine Dumbledore's authority. The doll starts causing strange happenings around the school, like objects moving on their own in a more sinister way than normal magic. Harry, Hermione, and Ron then set out to investigate. They find that the doll has a connection to an ancient and dark magic that they've never encountered before. They have to use their knowledge of magic, along with some new spells they discover, to deal with the threat of the Annabelle doll.
It might exist because the author was writing more for themselves than for an audience. Some people write fanfiction just to explore their own ideas and don't really focus on making it appealing to others.
It also violates the general respect for the source material. 'Harry Potter' is about magic, friendship, and heroism, and introducing such non - canon and inappropriate concepts distorts the essence of the story. Additionally, it may not be acceptable on most fanfiction platforms which have certain ethical and content guidelines.
One major problem is that it goes against the positive and moral themes of the original Harry Potter series. The series is about friendship, love, and fighting against evil, while NTR often involves non - consensual or unethical relationship situations. It can also be very off - putting for fans who love the original characters and their relationships as they were intended.
Well, one possible plot could be that Xehanort's essence or some form of his power gets transferred into the Harry Potter world. This power could start to corrupt some of the wizarding community, and Harry, with his strong sense of right and wrong, has to trace the source of this new evil. Along the way, he discovers more about Xehanort's past and motives, and has to use his knowledge of both the wizarding world and Xehanort's methods to defeat this new threat. It would be a complex plot that would require a lot of world - building to combine the two very different fictional settings.
Some fans might be very open - minded and supportive. They could see it as an interesting new take on the characters' relationship, adding a new dimension to the beloved story. After all, modern interpretations and diverse storylines are often welcomed in fan communities.
One possible implication is that it would completely change the perception of Harry's character. He would no longer be seen as the innocent hero but rather a character with a potentially dark and dangerous side. Another implication could be on the relationships in the story. His friends might view him differently and there could be a lot of mistrust. Also, the moral landscape of the story would be altered. Instead of a clear battle between good and evil with Harry on the side of good, it would become more muddled.
No. 'Harry Potter' and 'Annabelle' are from two completely different fictional universes with distinct storylines, themes, and tones. 'Harry Potter' is a story about a wizarding world, magic schools, and battles against the dark side, while 'Annabelle' is more related to horror themes around a possessed doll. So it's not a legitimate fanfiction concept.