The Volturi members, like Aro, could be very interesting. They are always interested in powerful supernatural beings, and Bella as a siren would surely catch their attention. Their reactions, whether it's to recruit her, control her, or eliminate her, could drive a lot of the plot in the fanfiction. And the interactions between Bella and the Volturi would be full of tension and power plays.
Edward can be really interesting. His relationship with Bella takes on a new dimension when she's a siren. He has to grapple with his love for her while also being cautious of her new powers. Another character could be Jacob. His loyalty to Bella might be tested as she becomes something different, and he might have his own mixed feelings about her siren side.
Well, obviously Bella Swan is one of the main characters. Her sister, who is a siren, is also a main character. Then there would likely be characters from the Twilight series like Edward Cullen, Jacob Black, etc. as they interact with Bella and her sister.
Alice Cullen can be a very popular character. Since she can see the future, in a 'reborn as bella swan' scenario, her interactions with Bella could be really different. Maybe she tries to guide Bella in a new way based on her visions. Also, Carlisle Cullen is popular. His father - figure role towards Bella might be explored further in these fanfictions.
One interesting plotline could be the sister having special powers that she has to hide from the Cullens. Maybe she can communicate with sea creatures and this causes some confusion and mystery in the story.
Edward is still very popular. Since he and Bella are now both vampires, their relationship takes on new aspects that fans like to explore. Another popular character is Alice. Her ability to see the future could be really interesting in a story where Bella is a vampire. She could foresee events that involve Bella and help her avoid danger or make important decisions.
A common theme might be the reaction of the other Twilight characters to Bella as a siren. Edward, for instance, could be both fascinated and worried about this new side of her. Also, the Volturi might see her as a threat due to her siren abilities. This could lead to conflicts and power struggles within the Twilight universe.
Edward Cullen is often a popular character in these fanfictions. Since he has a close relationship with Bella in the original story, his role can be further explored in relation to Rosalie and Bella's relationship. Another one could be Alice Cullen. Her ability to see the future can add an interesting dynamic, especially when it comes to predicting things that might affect Rosalie and Bella's friendship or any adventures they might go on.
Edward Cullen would likely be a main character. His reaction to Bella's situation, whether it's concern for her well - being or struggle with his vampiric instincts around her period blood, could be a major part of the story.
In these crossovers, Bella Swan herself is often very popular. Her relationship with Edward in the Twilight series makes her an interesting character to transplant into the Vampire Diaries universe. Also, Damon Salvatore from Vampire Diaries is popular. His bad - boy charm and complex personality add a lot of drama to any fanfiction story.
One great alternative theme could be 'Bella Swan and the Mysterious Newcomer'. This can create a story full of mystery and intrigue as Bella interacts with a new character in her town. It gives room for character development, relationship building, and a plot that can be both exciting and positive, far from the negative connotations of the original title.
Edward would definitely interact differently. If Bella goes back in time and changes her initial approach, Edward might be more or less intrigued by her. For example, if she's more confident, he might be even more drawn to her than in the original story.