A rare book was stolen from a locked study. The only people in the house at the time were the homeowner, his secretary, and a delivery man who had just dropped off a package. The homeowner was in his bedroom. The secretary said she was typing up some documents in the adjacent office. The delivery man left immediately after delivering the package. The secretary stole the book. She had made a copy of the study key long ago and had planned to sell the book for a large sum of money.
Here's another. A famous painting was slashed in an art gallery. The security cameras showed no one entering or leaving the room where the painting was. There were two guards on duty. Guard A said he was at his post all night and saw nothing unusual. Guard B said he had briefly left to check on a noise in another part of the gallery. The truth was Guard A did it. He had been bribed by a rival artist and had disabled the cameras for a short time while he slashed the painting.
Sure. One short whodunit story could be: In a small, locked room, a valuable diamond has disappeared. There were only three people who had access to the room - the butler, the maid, and the owner's nephew. The butler said he was polishing silverware in the kitchen. The maid claimed she was changing the bedsheets. The nephew said he was reading in the library. But there were strange fingerprints on the safe where the diamond was kept. It turned out to be the nephew. He had made up the alibi of reading and used a fake fingerprint device to mislead the investigation.
One great whodunit short story is 'The Adventure of the Speckled Band' by Arthur Conan Doyle. It's a classic mystery where Sherlock Holmes uses his brilliant deductive skills to solve a strange and seemingly impossible case.
Another good one is 'The Secret in the Garden.' A body is found in a secluded garden. Everyone in the nearby house has a motive, but who did it? The clues are hidden among the flowers and paths.
Agatha Christie's 'The Witness for the Prosecution' is a classic. It keeps you guessing till the end.
They usually have a complex plot with multiple suspects. The ending is often unexpected and full of twists.
They usually have a mystery to solve, with clues hidden throughout. The characters are often diverse and suspicious, and the ending is often a surprise.
I like 'A Study in Scarlet' which can also be regarded as a kind of a whodunit short story. It's the first story to feature Sherlock Holmes. Holmes is able to solve the mystery behind a corpse found in an abandoned house. He notices small details that others overlook, such as the different types of cigar ashes at the crime scene, which eventually lead him to the murderer.
There are many! Like 'The Missing Cookie' where a child's cookie goes missing and they have to figure out who took it. It's simple and fun.
You could start by visiting websites like Goodreads. It has user reviews and recommendations that can lead you to where you can find these stories. Another option is to search on Google Scholar for academic or literary collections of whodunit short stories.
One of the best is 'And Then There Were None' by Agatha Christie. It's set on an isolated island and people start getting killed one by one. The mystery keeps you guessing until the very end. Christie is a master at creating complex characters and a web of suspicion.
The mystery aspect. In short whodunit stories, you have a puzzle to solve. For example, in a story where a necklace is missing from a locked jewelry box. There are suspects, and you want to figure out who did it just like the detective in the story. It's like a mental game.