In a Creepy Catalog story, a woman bought an antique mirror. Every time she looked into it, she saw a different face than her own for a split second. At first, she thought it was her imagination. But as time passed, the faces became more vivid and menacing. She later discovered that the mirror was from a place where a serial killer used to keep his victims and their spirits were trapped in the mirror.
It depends on your tolerance for the creepy. If you're easily spooked by things like ghosts or unexplained events, then you'll probably find many of the stories in Creepy Catalog True Stories really scary. For instance, the stories about haunted asylums with the sounds of patients still screaming can be quite disturbing.
One really creepy story is about a haunted house. A family moved into an old, dilapidated mansion. At night, they would hear strange scratching noises on the walls. The children's toys would move on their own. One day, they found a hidden basement with strange symbols on the floor. It turned out the house was built on an ancient burial ground, and the spirits were not happy with the new occupants.
One creepy catalog ghost story could be about an old, dusty catalog that mysteriously appears in an attic. When opened, it has pictures that seem to move on their own. The products in the catalog start to show up in the house at night, but they are all in a spooky, decrepit state.
One story could be about a haunted house. People who moved in there often heard strange noises at night, like someone walking up and down the stairs. But when they checked, there was no one there. It was later discovered that a tragic accident had happened in the house many years ago and the spirits might be the victims of that accident.
One creepy story is about the old abandoned house at the end of the street. People say that at midnight, you can see a figure in the window. It's a girl who died there long ago. Legend has it that she was murdered and her spirit still lingers, waiting for someone to solve her mystery.
One scary story is about a haunted house. There was an old, dilapidated mansion on the outskirts of town. People who passed by at night often heard strange wailing sounds coming from inside. A group of teenagers once decided to explore it. As they entered, the doors slammed shut behind them. They saw shadowy figures moving in the hallways. One of the teens was dragged into a dark room and the others fled in terror, never to return.
One of the scariest stories could be about a haunted house. In it, people hear strange noises at night, like footsteps and whispers. When they try to leave, the doors slam shut on their own.
One really creepy story is about the haunted house. There was this old, dilapidated mansion on the outskirts of town. People who entered at night would hear strange whispers and see shadowy figures. It was said that a family was brutally murdered there long ago, and their spirits still roam the halls.
One story is about an old, abandoned house. People say that at midnight, you can see a figure in the window that looks like a woman in a white dress. She just stands there, staring out. No one knows who she was or why she's there, but it gives off a really creepy vibe.
One creepy real story is about the Bell Witch in Tennessee. A family was haunted by an entity known as the Bell Witch. It would torment the family, make strange noises, and even physically harm some members. It was said to be able to move objects and speak in a terrifying voice. People in the area were so scared that they avoided the Bell family's property.