In the context of fanfiction, it's a complex matter. While it goes against the established relationships in the original 'Harry Potter' story, fanfiction often explores 'what if' scenarios. However, from an ethical standpoint within the lore, it can be seen as disrespectful to the characters' original personalities and relationships.
Considering the original 'Harry Potter' story, Hermione having an affair in fanfiction is not ethical. The story has built a world with certain values and relationships. Hermione is in a relationship with Ron, and changing that in a way that involves an affair goes against the spirit of the story. Fanfiction should, to some extent, respect the essence of the original, and this kind of scenario doesn't seem to do that.
The ethics of affair fanfiction are a bit of a gray area. On one hand, it's just a form of creative expression by fans. They're not actually causing any real - life harm by writing fictional stories about affairs. But on the other hand, it can be seen as disrespectful to the original creators' intentions, especially if the original work promotes certain values like fidelity. However, as long as it's clearly labeled as fanfiction and not being passed off as the official continuation of the story, it can be considered a valid form of creativity.
There could be a situation in fanfiction where Dumbledore wrongly accuses Hermione of something and punishes her by making her stand in front of the whole school as a form of public shaming. But this goes against what we expect from Dumbledore. He is a mentor figure, and Hermione is a smart and dedicated student. This type of rough punishment would create a lot of tension in the fanfiction and might be a sign of the author taking creative liberties to explore darker themes that don't really align with the overall positive tone of the original Harry Potter world.
In the wizarding world, age - gap relationships can be a bit of a grey area. On one hand, magic often blurs the lines of normal human concepts. However, from a more traditional view, it might seem unethical. Hermione is a young and impressionable witch, and an older man might have a certain power over her. But if the relationship is based on true mutual respect and love, it could be seen as acceptable. It really depends on how the fanfiction portrays the relationship and the characters' intentions.
It completely changes her character. Hermione is typically seen as a smart, loyal friend. An affair in fanfiction makes her seem unfaithful and morally loose, which is the opposite of how she's portrayed in the original books.
It's not ethical. Hermione is a character who has been through a lot in the original story, and creating or reading fanfiction about her being tortured is a form of glorifying harm. It goes against the spirit of the original work which is about friendship, growth, and facing challenges in a more positive way.
Yes, it is quite popular. Some fans are drawn to the idea of Draco and Hermione getting involved in an affair because it represents a 'forbidden' or 'unexpected' relationship. It goes against the typical Gryffindor - Slytherin rivalry shown in the original 'Harry Potter' series, and that contrast creates an interesting dynamic for fanfiction writers to explore.
Well, it depends on your taste. There are fanfictions that delve into the Hermione - Lucius affair concept. However, not all of them are of high quality. You might need to read through several to find one that really grabs you. For example, some might focus more on the power dynamics between them, while others could be more about a secret relationship.
There are indeed. Fanfiction allows for a lot of creative reinterpretations. But it's important to note that this particular concept is quite a departure from the canon. It might be interesting for those who enjoy exploring alternative storylines, but it can also be off - putting to fans who prefer to stick closer to the original relationships.
The fanfiction could introduce a new character, perhaps a wise old wizard or witch, who has experience with mental health issues. This character could guide Hermione through her dark thoughts. They could teach her coping mechanisms, like meditation or positive self - talk. For instance, they could tell her 'When those negative thoughts come, replace them with something positive about yourself.' This new perspective could be a turning point for Hermione in the fanfiction.
These fanfics change the dynamic by making Harry and Hermione the central romantic couple instead of Hermione and Ron. This alteration has a domino effect on other relationships in the story. The trio's unity, which was based on friendship in the original, might be affected as Ron could be left out or have a different role, like a jealous ex - friend perhaps. Also, the way the story progresses in terms of the overall plot against Voldemort could be different as the focus shifts to their new relationship.