'Hemlock Grove' is a good one. It has a lot of dark and disturbing content, similar to 'American Horror Story'. It deals with werewolves, witches, and other supernatural beings. The show has a very moody and atmospheric setting which is great for horror fans.
The 'Scream' TV series. It has the horror and mystery elements like 'American Horror Story'. It's based around a series of murders in a town, and there are many twists and turns in the plot. There are also some really creepy characters that add to the horror factor.
The 'Haunting of Hill House' is another great option. It focuses on a family haunted by their past experiences in a haunted house. It has jump scares, psychological horror, and a complex family drama aspect that is somewhat similar to American Horror Story.
There are several shows. 'Carnival Row' has a dark and fantastical world filled with mythical creatures and political intrigue that gives off a similar sense of unease as American Horror Story. 'Channel Zero' is a horror anthology series, just like American Horror Story. Each season has a different spooky story to tell, often based on internet horror stories. And 'The Order' combines elements of the supernatural, a college setting, and mystery, which are also common in American Horror Story.
One show similar to American Horror Story is 'Penny Dreadful'. It also features elements of horror, supernatural creatures, and a dark, gothic atmosphere. Another is 'The Haunting of Hill House'. It has a spooky, psychological horror feel, with a focus on family secrets and a haunted house. And 'Stranger Things' can also be considered in a way. It has some horror elements combined with a sense of mystery and a unique 80s setting.
Another is 'The Haunting of Hill House'. It shares the horror genre with 'American Horror Story'. It focuses on a family haunted by a haunted house. The show is really good at creating a spooky and tense atmosphere, and it also delves deep into the psychological traumas of the characters.
Pepper appears in 'American Horror Story: Asylum'.
'American Crime Story' is related in a sense. While not strictly a horror show, it is from the same creators as American Horror Story. It focuses on real - life crime stories, but it has that same level of drama and intensity. It presents a different kind of 'horror' in the form of the true - crime events it portrays, and the way it unfolds the stories with a focus on character development and narrative twists.
Try 'The Walking Dead'. It offers a post-apocalyptic world filled with zombies and human drama, similar to the intensity of American Horror Story.
There's 'Bates Motel'. It's a prequel to 'Psycho' and has a lot of psychological horror elements. It focuses on the relationship between Norman Bates and his mother, and the motel has an eerie feel to it, much like the settings in American Horror Story.
One show similar to American Horror Story is 'Penny Dreadful'. It has a dark and gothic atmosphere, filled with supernatural elements like vampires, werewolves, and witches. Another one is 'The Haunting of Hill House'. It focuses on a haunted house and the psychological effects on the characters. Also, 'American Gothic' has elements of mystery and horror set in a small town with a dark secret.
Most horror - themed shows focus on different aspects compared to 'American Horror Story'. 'American Horror Story' is quite unique in its character creations like Pepper. But shows like 'The Haunting of Hill House' do have some characters with deep and dark backstories, though not as similar to Pepper as one might hope. They are more about family - related horror rather than the asylum - type horror with a character like Pepper.