There might be a new character introduced in the fanfiction who is using the appearance of the Grim Reaper to cause chaos. This character could be a dark wizard who has found a way to mimic the Grim Reaper's powers and uses it to spread fear among the wizarding community. Harry would then have to figure out who this impostor is and stop their evil deeds.
In this fanfiction, it's possible that the Grim Reaper appears to Harry at a crucial moment, like when he's about to make a big decision. The Grim Reaper could show him different possible futures depending on his choices, much like a guide through the complex web of time and consequences. It could also be that the Grim Reaper has a connection to Voldemort, and Harry has to deal with this new and unexpected alliance or conflict.
Salem would be a great main antagonist in this type of fanfiction. Since she already has a connection to the Grimm, she could use Grim Reaper - like Grimm to further her goals. Maybe she creates a super - powerful Grim Reaper Grimm that can not only kill Huntsmen but also corrupt their souls, making them turn against their own comrades.
It could still be Voldemort. Even though the focus is on Harry and Nagini, Voldemort is Nagini's master and the main source of evil in the Harry Potter world. He would likely try to stop Harry from getting too close to Nagini or from finding out any secrets Nagini might hold.
It could be a dark wizard who is jealous of the bond between Harry and Lily. This wizard might try to break their connection and use Lily's power for his own evil purposes. Maybe he wants to control Lily's magic, which is known to be strong, to achieve domination over the wizarding world.
It could be Voldemort who somehow follows Harry into the realm of the Morrigan. His dark magic could disrupt the balance there and make him a common enemy for both Harry and the Morrigan.
There could be a group of anti - magic fanatics in the fanfiction. They see Byako as an abomination because of his strange powers that don't conform to the normal rules of wizarding magic. They also view the Hogwarts students' acceptance of Byako as a sign of the corruption of magic. So they set out to eliminate Byako and anyone who stands in their way.
It could be the person who sent the venomous snake after Harry Potter. Maybe a dark wizard who wants to harm Harry.
Maybe it's a group of dark wizards who believe in a more extreme form of pure - blood ideology. They see Arcturus Black as a traitor for teaming up with Harry Potter, who is a half - blood. They plot to take over the wizarding world and eliminate anyone who doesn't fit their idea of a pure - blood wizard.
The main antagonist could be an old, corrupt house - elf. This house - elf was mistreated in the past at Hogwarts and has now turned to the dark side. It wants to bring chaos to Hogwarts and sees Lady Hogwarts as the key. It uses its knowledge of the school's hidden passages and secrets to plot against her. Harry Potter, being the defender of the underdog, tries to reason with the house - elf at first but when that fails, he has to use magic to stop it from harming Lady Hogwarts.
It could be Bellatrix Lestrange. Since she is a Death Eater and has a personal vendetta against Sirius, she would be a great antagonist. She might try to kill Sirius again and also target Harry to please Voldemort.