In the books, Petunia is rather cold towards Harry from the start. But in the fanfic, the scene of her holding infant Harry might show a more nuanced side. Maybe she shows a moment of hesitation or an unexpected softness that isn't in the books.
The canon description doesn't really focus on Petunia holding Harry in a tender way. In a fanfic, this scene could be elaborated on. For example, in the fanfic, Petunia might hold Harry closer than she would in the books, perhaps with a look of reluctant acceptance on her face, while in the books she just seems to tolerate his presence in a very detached way.
In the books, Petunia's relationship with Harry is mainly defined by her resentment towards the wizarding world and her sister. However, in the fanfic where she holds infant Harry, there could be a different dynamic. The fanfic might explore a deeper emotional connection that was only hinted at in the books. It could show Petunia struggling with her feelings, torn between her dislike for magic and the fact that Harry is her nephew. This could be a chance for the fanfic to deviate from the rather cold and distant relationship depicted in the original books.
One possible fanfic could be 'Petunia's Hidden Affection'. In this fic, Petunia's holding of infant Harry might be a turning point where she starts to feel a strange sense of protectiveness towards him. It could explore her internal struggle between her dislike for magic and her new - found connection to this magical infant.
She might be feeling a sense of envy. Petunia has always been jealous of Lily's magical abilities, and now seeing Harry, who is also a wizard, could stir up those feelings. She may also feel a bit of fear, not knowing exactly what to do with a magical infant.
One idea for a fanfic could be that when Petunia holds infant Harry, she has a premonition of the great things he will do in the wizarding world. This scares her at first, but then she starts to think about how she can be a part of his life in a positive way. It could be a story of redemption for Petunia and a new start for Harry within the Dursley family.
The Magicians by Grossman and the Harry Potter books have some similarities and differences. The Harry Potter series is set in a very detailed and magical world with a lot of wonder. In contrast, The Magicians has a more cynical view of magic. For example, in Harry Potter, learning magic at Hogwarts is exciting and positive. But in The Magicians, the characters at Brakebills often find magic to be more of a burden or something that doesn't always bring them happiness. However, both deal with the idea of a hidden magical world.
It's a mixed bag. Some parts are very similar, but there are also quite a few differences and omissions.
By focusing on their shared past traumas. For example, both have had experiences related to Lily's death in different ways. Harry lost his mother, and Petunia lost her sister. They could start to bond over this common pain and gradually move towards a more positive relationship.
I don't think it's a very common type. Most 'Harry Potter' fanfics tend to focus on the magical adventures, the relationships between the main characters like Harry, Ron and Hermione, or exploring different magical elements in the wizarding world. While there are some that might delve into darker themes, the idea of Petunia abusing Harry isn't as mainstream as other topics in the fanfic community.
It changes the canon by introducing a new form of interaction between Voldemort and Harry. Instead of just the typical battles and mind - reading attempts we see in the original books, the 'plugging' concept adds a more invasive and direct connection. For example, Voldemort could directly influence Harry's thoughts and actions in ways that were not possible in the canon.
The magic in Harry Potter is mainly channeled through wands and potions, and it has a certain structure within the wizarding world. However, in Aladdin, the magic is more fantastical and free - flowing. In fanfiction, when combined, it can create some really interesting scenarios. For instance, a wizard might try to understand the genie's magic and find that it defies all the rules they know. Or the genie might be amazed at the complexity of wizarding spells.
Definitely. Fanfic writers often explore Petunia's role in Harry's life in a more positive light. Maybe she had some internal struggles about taking Harry in, not just out of spite but also out of fear of the wizarding world. Such fanfics can offer new insights into the 'Harry Potter' universe and its characters.