There are several factors. First, the fact that it's a normal - looking hotel room but filled with such abnormal and malevolent happenings. Second, the psychological torture the main character endures as his rational mind tries to make sense of the impossible events. And finally, the feeling of being trapped in that one small space while all these horrors unfold around you.
The sense of isolation. When a character in a real scary story is alone in a spooky place, like an old mansion or a dark forest, it makes the situation scarier. There's no one to turn to for help. Also, the atmosphere plays a big role. Dim lighting, strange sounds, and a cold breeze all add to the feeling of dread. For instance, in a story where a person is in a haunted house and the lights keep flickering while there are creaking noises everywhere, it gives the reader a sense of impending doom.
The Annabelle real story is scary because it taps into our fear of the unknown. We don't really understand what was causing the doll to act up. Was it really a spirit? And the idea that something so innocent - looking like a doll could be a source of evil is truly terrifying. Also, the reports of people getting scratched and the general sense of unease around the doll contribute to the scariness.
The fact that they are real. Knowing that these events actually happened to someone makes it scarier than fictional horror. For example, if you hear about a real - life haunted house where people have experienced unexplainable things, it sends a chill down your spine because it could potentially happen to you too.
Another aspect that makes real frightening stories scary is the way they can seem so real. Sometimes, these stories are based on real - life experiences or events that people claim to have happened. When we hear about a place that has a reputation for being haunted, and then we hear a detailed story about someone's encounter there, it makes it more believable. This believability makes the fear more palpable, like the story of an old cemetery where people have reported seeing apparitions. It makes us wonder if we were to visit that place, would we also have a similar encounter?
The unknown. In real scary stories, often there are elements that we can't explain. Like a strange noise in an empty house. We don't know what's causing it, and that scares us.
The mystery around it. We don't really know who Bloody Mary is supposed to be exactly. It could be anyone from a wronged woman to a witch. And the idea that just by saying her name in a specific place (the bathroom) and in the dark, something terrifying might happen.
The things that make 'harold the scary story' scary could be multiple. If Harold is a menacing character, his actions like stalking or making strange noises in the dark would be scary. Also, the setting of the story might be spooky, like an old abandoned place. And the unknown elements about Harold, such as his motives or where he came from, can add to the scariness.
The unknown element makes it scary. We don't really know what the pumpkin is capable of in the story. Is it a haunted object? Is it possessed? All these unanswered questions create fear.
The mystery surrounding the wanderer is what makes it so scary. We don't know where it comes from, what it wants, or why it's wandering. This lack of knowledge creates fear in our minds. Also, it might be associated with death or bad omens. For instance, whenever it shows up, strange things start to happen like animals acting strangely or the weather suddenly changing for the worse. It gives the impression that it has some sort of power over the natural world, and that power is not friendly to humans.
The unknown elements make a scary story terrifying. When there are things that the characters and the readers don't understand, like a strange noise in the dark or a figure that appears and disappears without explanation, it creates fear. For example, in a haunted house story, if there are unexplained cold spots or voices, it gives a sense of unease.