There could be a fanfiction where Puck discovers Shelby's past and tries to help her overcome some old traumas. This would involve a lot of emotional conversations and character development for both of them.
A fun fanfiction might be set at a school event where Puck and Shelby are forced to work together to solve a problem, like a missing piece of equipment for the performance. They end up bonding over their shared love for music and their determination to make the event a success.
Family is also a theme sometimes. Since Glee often touches on family issues, in fanfiction, Shelby and Puck might form a sort of surrogate family for each other. For example, Puck might find the motherly figure he lacked in Shelby, and Shelby might see Puck as a son - like figure she can nurture and help along the way.
One great Glee Shelby and Puck fanfiction is 'Shelby's Influence on Puck'. It shows how Shelby's presence in Puck's life helps him grow as a person and as a singer. It has some really heartwarming scenes where they bond over their shared love for music.
A great fanfiction could involve Kurt and Puck being cast in a school musical together. Puck is used to being the tough guy, but through Kurt's guidance in the musical realm, he starts to soften and they create a memorable on - stage duo, while also developing a strong off - stage bond.
One interesting Glee puck and Quinn fanfiction could be about them getting back together after a long time apart. In this story, they might meet at a high school reunion and realize their feelings for each other never really went away.
Another option is Tumblr. There are often posts about Glee fanfiction, and some users might recommend or even post their own Puck and Shelby fanfictions. You can follow relevant Glee tags or search specifically for what you want.
One great 'Puck and Rachel' 'Glee' fanfiction is 'Unlikely Duet'. It beautifully explores their relationship as they work on a duet together in a different setting than the show. They start to understand each other on a deeper level.
There's also 'Puck and Rachel: A New Duet'. This fanfic focuses on how they might support each other in their post - Glee club careers. It shows Puck being surprisingly protective of Rachel as she tries to make it on Broadway, adding a new dimension to their relationship.
One possible storyline could be about how Quinn and Puck deal with the reactions of their friends and family. For example, Quinn might be worried about her parents' response, while Puck could be concerned about how his bad - boy image will be affected. Another could be their struggle to balance school, their social lives, and impending parenthood. They might have to make sacrifices like giving up some of their extracurricular activities in Glee club to focus on preparing for the baby.
There's a fanfiction where Puck has to protect Rachel from some bullies at a music event. This fic explores their relationship in a more protective way. Puck uses his tough - guy image to keep Rachel safe, and in the process, they start to see each other in a different light. Their shared love for music becomes the bond that deepens their connection.
Will Shelby could be a source of inspiration in Glee fanfiction. His passion for music and teaching can be a driving force for other characters to pursue their dreams.