Since it's a love story in the context of witches, there might be a group of witches who are friends or rivals of the main witch character. For example, a group of popular witches in the coven who either support or oppose the main character's relationship. And of course, there has to be the love interest, who could be from a different magical background or even a human, which would add a lot of drama to the story.
I'm not entirely sure as I haven't fully explored this 'Every Witch Way Love Story'. But generally, in stories related to witches, there's often a magical world involved. Maybe it's about a witch finding love in a world full of magic, spells and potions.
If it was a crossover with 'The Vampire Diaries', Bonnie Bennett would be an interesting character to include. As a powerful witch in her own right, she could collaborate with the witches from 'Every Witch Way' to fight against any supernatural threats that emerge. Also, Damon Salvatore could add some drama and conflict, especially if he has an interest in one of the 'Every Witch Way' witches.
The main characters could be the witch herself and a human. The human might be a curious adventurer who stumbles upon the witch's lair and they start to fall in love.
Often, there are two main characters. One could be a male character who is perhaps a bit jaded from past love experiences. And the other a female character who has her own insecurities but is also longing for a real connection. They are the central figures through which the story of finding love again unfolds.
One possible fanfiction could be about Maddie and Diego going on a magical adventure outside of their school. They could discover a hidden realm full of unique spells and creatures. Maybe they have to work together to solve a mystery that threatens both the human and witch worlds.
One possible fanfiction could be about Emma and Daniel's first date. They might go to a magical place hidden in the forest near their school. It could be a place filled with glowing plants and friendly magical creatures. They would hold hands and talk about their dreams and fears, all while the magic of the place surrounds them.
The main characters in the 'love the way you lie story' are two lovers. They are constantly in a cycle of fighting and making up. We don't really know their names, but we can see their relationship dynamic which is full of passion and conflict. They seem to be unable to escape from this cycle they are in.
The main character is of course the friendly witch herself. There might also be some villagers, like the village elder who might interact with the witch, and perhaps some children who are curious about the witch and her magic.
The main character is of course the old witch herself. And often there's a young person, like a child or a young adult, who gets involved with the witch, either by accident or on purpose.
In the 'the christmas witch story', the main character is the witch. She could be friends with a young boy or girl who discovers her in the woods. And of course, there may be the traditional Christmas characters in the background, such as Santa Claus. Santa might be a bit wary of the witch at first but then come to realize that she has good intentions. There could also be some mischievous imps that the witch has to deal with as she tries to spread Christmas cheer.