There are several elements that make Harry Potter seem like Sherlock Holmes fanfiction. Firstly, the idea of a hero on a journey to uncover the truth. Harry's journey to defeat Voldemort involves unravelling many mysteries. Secondly, the use of clues and evidence. In Harry Potter, there are often small details that Harry and his friends pick up on to progress in their mission, similar to how Holmes uses clues to solve cases. And finally, the sense of a larger world with many hidden aspects waiting to be discovered, whether it's the wizarding world or the seedy underbelly of London in Sherlock Holmes stories.
Another factor is the writing style. A good fanfiction uses vivid language to describe the magical elements and the detective work. It should also have a good flow, so that the reader can easily follow the story. The author might also add some unique twists, like how the two universes interact in unexpected ways. For instance, how Sherlock's rational thinking clashes or combines with the magic of the wizarding world.
Harry Potter can be considered like Sherlock Holmes fanfiction in terms of the element of mystery and the central characters' abilities to analyze situations. Harry has to analyze the actions and motives of his enemies, just like Holmes does with criminals. The Hogwarts houses can also be seen as different 'types' of characters, similar to how Holmes encounters various types of people in his investigations. And the overarching story arcs in Harry Potter, filled with secrets and revelations, mirror the mystery - solving nature of Sherlock Holmes tales.
Well, if Harry Potter reads Sherlock Holmes fanfiction, he'd probably be amazed at how Sherlock solves cases without magic. It might make him realize that Muggles have their own ways of being clever. He could start using some of Sherlock's methods, like observing details more closely, in his battles against the Dark Arts. And he might even share some of these stories with his friends at Hogwarts, like Hermione, who would surely be interested in analyzing the plots and characters.
It would be really interesting. Harry might grow up with Sherlock's deductive skills. He could analyze the magic world in a more logical way. For example, when dealing with the mystery of the Chamber of Secrets, instead of just relying on the usual magic means, he might use Sherlock - style reasoning to find out who the heir of Slytherin is.
Yes. In some ways, we can see elements that might suggest a connection. For example, both series are set in a world full of mystery. Harry Potter has the mystery of the wizarding world, the secrets of Hogwarts, and the enigma of Voldemort. Similarly, Sherlock Holmes is all about solving mysteries in the Muggle world. However, they are two very distinct universes with their own unique rules and characters, but the love for mystery might be a common thread that could make one think of Harry Potter as somewhat of a Sherlock Holmes - inspired fanfiction on a very loose level.
Well, in Harry Potter fanfiction, business can take many forms. There could be stories about the trade of magical artifacts on the black market. As for Sherlock Holmes fanfiction, he often deals with cases that may have a financial aspect to them, like fraud in a business deal. When it comes to combining the two in fanfiction, perhaps Sherlock could be called upon to solve a mystery in the wizarding business world, say a series of disappearances among the goblin bankers who handle the wizarding currency.
The backstories. The Marauders' backstories are so rich and intertwined with Harry's world. For example, Remus Lupin being a werewolf and his relationship with the other Marauders. Also, the fact that Harry inherits the Marauders' Map. All these things create a connection that gives it a fanfiction - like feel.
The setting. Hogwarts is a school for wizards, which is similar to the types of institutions often found in mage fanfiction. It's a place where young magic - users learn and develop their skills. Also, the existence of a hidden magical world parallel to the Muggle world is a common trope in mage - related fictional works.
One common theme is mystery - solving. Just like in the original Sherlock Holmes stories, the fanfictions often have him using his deductive reasoning to solve magical mysteries in the Harry Potter world.
A fanfiction with this premise would be a blend of two very different worlds. Harry would have the best of both worlds - the magic of the wizarding world and the detective skills of Sherlock Holmes. He could use apparition to quickly get to crime scenes in London and then use his deductive abilities to figure out what happened. His friends at Hogwarts might be a bit confused by his new skills, but they would also be in awe. And there could be a whole new set of villains, perhaps ones that combine the dark magic of the wizarding world with the criminal minds from Sherlock's era. Harry would have to use his combined skills to stop them, making for a very action - packed and interesting story.