The plot could also revolve around a misunderstanding at first. Human Toothless might be seen as a threat by the female Hiccup. But as time passes, she realizes he has a good heart. They could then team up to protect their village from an impending threat, like a group of raiders. Along the way, they develop feelings for each other and have to navigate those new emotions while still focusing on the safety of their people.
Another idea is that they both have a shared dream of creating a more inclusive world between humans and dragons. They meet while trying to convince the more stubborn members of their community about this vision. They go on a journey to find proof that humans and dragons can co - exist peacefully. During this journey, they encounter different cultures of both humans and dragons, and through their experiences, their relationship deepens into a strong friendship or even more.
Well, one possible plot could be that Toothless, in his human form, meets Hiccup's female counterpart. They might start off as strangers but then bond over their love for adventure. Maybe they discover a new, uncharted island together filled with strange and wonderful creatures. Their relationship could grow as they face various challenges on this island, like dealing with a territorial dragon or finding a way to cross a dangerous terrain.
Another idea could be that a new and unknown force in their land has the ability to make the impossible happen, like male pregnancy. Hiccup becomes a target for this force for some reason, and Toothless has to protect him not only from the physical threats but also from the social stigma that might come with such an unusual situation. As they face these challenges, their bond deepens and they discover new aspects of their love for each other.
One possible plot could be that Toothless is under some sort of spell or mind control. Maybe a new villain in the How to Train Your Dragon universe has the power to manipulate dragons. Toothless, being a powerful Night Fury, is forced to kidnap Hiccup. Hiccup, of course, tries to figure out why Toothless is acting this way and how to break the spell.
I'm not really into this specific concept, but in general, fanfiction often explores unique relationships. In this case, it might involve a very different take on the characters' bond, perhaps with Toothless in a more human - like form. However, it's a very niche and often not a canon - compliant idea.
Well, perhaps in this fanfiction, there's a new kind of magic discovered in their world. This magic messes with the natural order and causes Toothless to be able to impregnate female Hiccup. But then, they would have to face a lot of challenges. The village might not accept this strange occurrence, and they would have to figure out how to deal with the upcoming birth and the new life that is about to enter their world.
Well, it might be about their first encounter. Maybe Hiccup is out exploring and stumbles upon Toothless in a hidden cove. He's initially scared but then realizes Toothless is different from the other dragons he's heard about.
In the 'Toothless Eats Hiccup Fanfiction', it might be that there is an alternate universe where the relationship between Toothless and Hiccup is completely different. Maybe in this universe, dragons are more savage and Toothless hasn't formed the deep bond with Hiccup like in the original story. So, he sees Hiccup as just another source of food. This could explore how their relationship might have been if things had been different in this strange fan - created world.
The plot could involve young Hiccup's first encounter with Toothless. Maybe he stumbles upon Toothless in a hidden cove while exploring. Hiccup, being the curious and kind - hearted boy he is, tries to approach Toothless despite his initial fear. They gradually build a connection through shared moments like Hiccup offering food to Toothless.
Well, it's really hard to imagine, but perhaps it could be about a strange magical world where a human - like Toothless has some sort of encounter with Hiccup that results in an unexpected pregnancy in a very unconventional way. Maybe there are some strange potions or curses involved.
One great story could be about Hiccup and Toothless exploring a new, uncharted land together. In this fanfiction, they might encounter strange new dragons and have to use their unique bond to overcome challenges. Hiccup's intelligence combined with Toothless' strength would make for an exciting adventure.
Another plot idea is that a strange illness starts affecting the dragons in Berk. Toothless is one of the first to show symptoms. Hiccup, being the dragon expert, sets out to find a cure. He and Toothless travel far and wide, facing many challenges along the way. They meet other dragon riders from different lands who may or may not be helpful in their quest for the cure. This journey tests their bond and shows how much they rely on each other.