For detective fiction to be great, it needs a plot that's full of twists and turns. The characters should be well-rounded and have depth. Also, the writing style should be captivating and draw the reader in. A sense of tension and suspense throughout is crucial.
Great detective fiction often combines a cleverly crafted crime, a detective with unique problem-solving skills, and a backdrop that adds to the intrigue. It should have clues that are hidden but not impossible to discover. The pace should be just right, not too slow or too fast.
One of the things that makes it great is the atmosphere. The moors are described in such a way that it feels both desolate and full of secrets. And then there's the mystery of the hound which is both a physical threat and a symbol of the Baskerville curse. The characters are also well - developed. Holmes is his usual brilliant self, and the other characters have their own motives and secrets which all add to the complexity of the mystery.
Another important aspect is the ability to think outside the box. In detective fiction, the obvious solution is often not the correct one. So a great 'Nate' would need to consider all possibilities, even the most far - fetched ones. They might need to look at the case from different perspectives, such as the motives of different characters, their backgrounds, and any hidden relationships. This kind of complex thinking makes the character stand out and the story more engaging.
One factor is their intelligence. A great detective like Sherlock Holmes can quickly analyze evidence and draw accurate conclusions. For example, he can tell a person's occupation just from the calluses on their hands. Another is their unique personality. Hercule Poirot's fastidiousness and his pride in his 'little grey cells' add to his charm as a detective.
One characteristic is a complex mystery. There must be a puzzling crime or situation that keeps the readers guessing. For example, in Sherlock Holmes stories, the mysteries are often very intricate, involving strange clues and unexpected twists. Another feature is a brilliant detective. The detective should be highly intelligent and observant, like Hercule Poirot. He can notice small details that others miss. Also, great detective fiction often has a well - crafted plot structure, with a build - up of suspense leading to a satisfying conclusion.
Well, in 'The Silent Patient', one of the things that makes it a top - notch detective novel is the complex characters. The silent patient herself is a mystery within a mystery. The detective's struggle to understand her motives and past adds depth to the story. Also, the unexpected twists and turns in the plot keep the readers guessing until the very end.
Barcelona's architecture. The Gothic Quarter, for example, with its maze - like alleys and old buildings, provides a perfect backdrop for mystery. A detective can easily disappear into the shadows or find a hidden clue in one of the many nooks and crannies.
Intelligence is key. A detective like Hercule Poirot uses his high - level intellect to analyze the evidence and motives. He can think several steps ahead, which is crucial for solving complex cases. Also, a memorable personality helps. Poirot's fastidiousness and unique mannerisms make him stand out.
One thing that makes detective fiction unique is the element of mystery and the thrill of solving a complex puzzle. It keeps readers engaged and on the edge of their seats.
A great fiction often has an engaging plot. It should have a beginning that grabs the reader's attention, a middle filled with twists and turns, and an end that satisfies or at least makes the reader think. Take 'The Lord of the Rings' for instance. The epic journey and the numerous challenges the characters face keep readers hooked.
For me, a great fiction has compelling characters that you can relate to or root for. Also, a unique and engaging plot that keeps you hooked from start to finish.