Is it better for a fifth-grader to read the original or the juvenile version of the four famous Chinese novels?

Answer 1

For children in the fifth grade of primary school, whether they read the original works of the Four Great Chinese Classics or the juvenile version might vary from person to person, mainly depending on the child's interest and reading ability.

The original works are the general name of the four famous novels in China. They are one of the representative works of novels in the Ming and Qing Dynasties. They are famous for their rich characters, profound thoughts and extensive cultural content. Reading the original novel can help children better understand the plot, characters, and theme of the novel and cultivate their interest and ability to read. However, because these novels have hundreds of years of history and language, it is difficult to read them. Therefore, parents or teachers need to evaluate their children's reading ability to ensure that they can understand and enjoy the reading process.

In contrast, the youth edition was a rewrite or adaptation of China's Four Great Masterpieces. It was usually aimed at children. The language was simple and easy to understand, and the content was also in line with children's cognition and interest. The youth edition can help children better understand China's history, culture, and people, and improve their reading interest and ability. However, it should be noted that the content of the youth version may not be as profound as the original, or may not be as rich in historical and cultural background as the original. Therefore, parents and children need to judge and evaluate it themselves.

Parents and children should choose books that suit them according to their reading ability and interests. At the same time, parents and children should also guide and encourage their children to read independently to cultivate their interest and ability in reading.