Which was better, the old version of Romance of the Three Kingdoms or the new version?

2024-09-18 07:11

1 answer

2024-09-18 08:55

As a fan of online literature, I can't make a subjective evaluation of literary works because every work has its own unique value and characteristics, depending on the reader's personal taste and cultural background. However, I can tell you some information about Romance of the Three Kingdoms and the new version of the Three Kingdoms. The Romance of the Three Kingdoms was one of the classic Chinese literary works. It told the historical story of the Three Kingdoms period. It was first published in 1934, and over 70 years, it was published in hundreds of volumes. It was one of the most influential novels in China after Dream of the Red Chamber and an important part of Chinese culture. The new version of " Three Kingdoms " was a TV series that was released in the mainland of China in 2019. It was directed by the famous director Guo Fan, who played Cao Cao, and Liu Bei, who played Zhuge Liang, and Ma Dehua. The TV series rearranged and adapted Romance of the Three Kingdoms, adding some new elements to present the society, politics, and culture of the Three Kingdoms period from a modern perspective. Both Romance of the Three Kingdoms and the new edition of the Three Kingdoms are classics of Chinese literature and culture. They each have their own characteristics, depending on the reader's preferences and cultural background.

Is the Romance of the Three Kingdoms better in the old version or the new version?

1 answer

2024-09-14 02:33

The old and new versions of Romance of the Three Kingdoms both had their own unique strengths and weaknesses, and it was difficult to simply compare them. The old Romance of the Three Kingdoms was a classic novel written by the Ming Dynasty novelist Luo Guanzhong. After hundreds of years of development and evolution, it had become a classic in the history of Chinese literature. The new version of Romance of the Three Kingdoms was a TV series shot by the mainland of China. Although it was also a classic, compared to the old version of Romance of the Three Kingdoms, it lacked literary and artistic performance. When watching the new version of Romance of the Three Kingdoms, the audience may feel more visual stimulation because it is more gorgeous and shocking in visual effects. However, when watching the old version of Romance of the Three Kingdoms, the audience may be more influenced by the plot and character creation of the novel because it is more literary and profound. Therefore, it depended on which version was more suitable for him. He had to decide according to his own preferences and needs. Both the old and new versions were classics worth watching.

Which is better, the old version of Romance of the Three Kingdoms or the new version of the Three Kingdoms (TV series)?

1 answer

2024-09-22 09:28

As a fan of online literature, I can't comment on TV dramas. However, according to my knowledge of online literature, the old version of Romance of the Three Kingdoms and the new version of the Three Kingdoms (TV series) can be seen as an adaptation and interpretation of the original. When reading Romance of the Three Kingdoms, readers could feel the depth and complexity of the historical background, characters, plot settings, and so on. On the other hand, TV series presented the plot and characters in the novel through visual language, which might simplify and weaken the details and complexity of the novel to a certain extent. Therefore, whether it was the old version of Romance of the Three Kingdoms or the new version of Romance of the Three Kingdoms (TV series), they could attract different types of audiences because they all presented Romance of the Three Kingdoms in their own ways. The readers and audiences could choose to read or watch according to their interests and preferences.

Is the new version of the Three Kingdoms better or the old one?

1 answer

2024-09-14 02:33

The new version of the Three Kingdoms and the old version of the Three Kingdoms had their own advantages, depending on personal preferences. The new version of the Three Kingdoms was based on a well-known online novel with a more vivid and interesting storyline and more rich and three-dimensional characters. The old version of the Three Kingdoms was adapted from the classic literary work, Romance of the Three Kingdoms. It used the historical background as a blueprint to show the images and stories of the historical figures during the Three Kingdoms period in the form of a novel. If you like a more lively and interesting storyline, then the new version of the Three Kingdoms might be more suitable. If you like works that are more loyal to history, then the old version of the Three Kingdoms might be more suitable for your taste. However, both the new and old versions of the Three Kingdoms should respect historical facts and avoid distorting or misleading history.

Which version of Romance of the Three Kingdoms is better?

1 answer

2024-09-18 07:29

There were many versions of Romance of the Three Kingdoms, each with its own unique characteristics and style. The following are some common versions of Romance of the Three Kingdoms: 1 Romance of the Three Kingdoms: This is one of the most popular versions of Romance of the Three Kingdoms in the mainland of China. It uses modern narrative techniques and dubbing to portray the characters 'images and personalities. Romance of the Three Kingdoms (Taiwan version): The Taiwan version of Romance of the Three Kingdoms is different from the CCTV version in terms of dubbing and picture style. It focuses more on the historical background and character of the Three Kingdoms period. 3 Romance of the Three Kingdoms (Hong Kong version): The Hong Kong version of Romance of the Three Kingdoms is more traditional in the narrative method, and the image and personality of the characters are more deeply rooted in the hearts of the people. 4 Romance of the Three Kingdoms (Japan Version): The Japanese version of Romance of the Three Kingdoms is similar to the the mainland of China and the Taiwan version in terms of dubbing and picture style, but it focuses more on the cultural and historical background of the Three Kingdoms period. Each version has its advantages and disadvantages. The readers can choose the version that suits them according to their own preferences and needs.

Which is better, the new version or the old version?

1 answer

2024-09-25 21:19

Which is better, the new version or the old version? I can't make a specific recommendation because tastes and preferences vary from person to person. However, you can refer to the following information about these two novels to make your own judgment: - " What Can I Use to Save You and My Lover " was a famous love story between the protagonist and his lover. The plot of the novel was full of ups and downs, the characters were full of emotions, and they were deeply loved by readers. - The old version of " How to Save You and My Lover " was published by China Daily in 2005 by Liang Heng. The book tells the love story between the protagonist and his lover, which has a high literary value. Both novels are very popular, but different readers may have different opinions. It is recommended to read the original work or refer to the feedback of other readers to make your own judgment.

The old version of Romance of the Three Kingdoms?

1 answer

2024-09-12 10:26

The old version of Romance of the Three Kingdoms was a classic TV drama about the war and political struggle between Shu Han and Dongwu during the Three Kingdoms period. The following are the details of each episode: Chapter 1: Liu Bei Arrives in Sichuan This episode tells the story of how Liu Bei and the others successfully entered Sichuan through the alliance against Cao Cao. On the journey, Liu Bei met Guan Yu, Zhang Fei, Zhuge Liang and the others to discuss how to deal with Cao Wei's attack. In the end, they successfully established the Shu Han regime and began to compete with Cao Wei. Chapter 2: Guan Yu Loses Jingzhou This episode tells the story of Guan Yu's defeat in the Battle of Maicheng and his siege by Sun Quan. In this episode, Liu Bei and the others had no choice but to join forces with Wu to take back Jingzhou to avenge Guan Yu. The Northern Expedition of Marquis Wu This episode tells the story of Marquis Wu's Northern Expedition. In this episode, Marquis Wu led the Shu Han army through many attacks and defenses, and finally succeeded in conquering Luoyang, the capital of Cao Wei, and established the hegemony of Hanzhong. However, Marquis Wu also realized that there were divisions and contradictions within Cao Wei, so he began to think about the next development strategy. The fourth episode: Dongwu groom search This episode tells the story of the Eastern Wu Princess's marriage. In this episode, there was a conflict between Liu Bei and Sun Quan because they both wanted their daughters to be their wives. In this episode, Zhuge Liang played an important role. He successfully resolved the conflict between Liu Bei and Sun Quan through diplomatic means. The Battle of Red Cliff This episode tells the story of the Battle of Red Cliff. In this episode, the Shu Han army led by Liu Bei, Guan Yu, Zhang Fei, and the Dongwu army led by Sun Quan, Zhou Yu, and the others met at Red Cliff and engaged in a fierce battle. In the end, Liu Bei and the others won and broke Cao Wei's hegemony. Chapter 6: Ma Chao's Return This episode tells the story of Ma Chao's surrender. In this episode, Ma Chao led his family to revolt in an attempt to overthrow the Cao Wei regime. In this episode, Zhuge Liang played an important role. He successfully quelled Ma Chao's uprising through diplomatic means and maintained the national security of Shu Han.

Who is closer to history, the new version of the Three Kingdoms or the old version of the Three Kingdoms?

1 answer

2024-09-18 06:50

Both the new and old versions of the Three Kingdoms had their own unique historical backgrounds and characters, but from a historical point of view, they were closer to the real history. The old version of the Three Kingdoms was a TV series produced by CCTV. Its historical background and character creation were more faithful to history, especially considering the historical background and character relationships during the Three Kingdoms period. In the old version of the Three Kingdoms, the actors 'performances and the director's exquisite skills were fully reflected. In contrast, the new version of the Three Kingdoms was adapted from an online novel. Its historical background and character creation were more free and could be influenced by the imagination and interpretation of the author and readers. Although the new version of the Three Kingdoms also had good works, its historical background and character creation were more fictional and diverse than the old version of the Three Kingdoms. To sum up, although the new version of the Three Kingdoms and the old version of the Three Kingdoms have different characters and plot settings, they both try to present the history and culture of the Three Kingdoms period in different ways. From a historical point of view, they are closer to the real history.

Which was better, the new Romance of the Three Kingdoms or the old Romance of the Three Kingdoms?

1 answer

2024-09-14 02:54

The new Three Kingdoms and the old Romance of the Three Kingdoms were both Chinese web novels with their own unique styles and characteristics. The New Three Kingdoms was based on the Romance of the Three Kingdoms and had some adaptation and creativity, adding some sci-fi elements and modern war plots to suit the taste of modern people; while the Old Romance of the Three Kingdoms paid more attention to historical authenticity and character portrayals to evoke people's memories and resonance with the classic historical stories. Both works had their own unique charms. The readers could choose to read them according to their own preferences and preferences. If you like modern novels, then the New Three Kingdoms might be more suitable; if you prefer classic historical stories, then the Romance of the Three Kingdoms might be more worth reading.

Which was better, the new Romance of the Three Kingdoms or the old Romance of the Three Kingdoms?

1 answer

2024-09-14 02:38

As a fan of online literature, I can't judge whether a work is good or not. However, I can tell you some information about these two works to help you make your own decision. New Three Kingdoms was an epic war film directed by Guo Fan from the mainland of China. It was released in 2013. The movie told the story of the Three Kingdoms period at the end of the Eastern Han Dynasty, including famous historical events such as the Battle of Red Cliff. New Three Kingdoms received widespread praise for its modern expression and visual effects. Romance of the Old Three Kingdoms was a novel by Somerset Maugham, published in 1886. The novel used the Three Kingdoms period as the background to describe the images and plots of major historical figures such as Cao Cao, Liu Bei, and Sun Quan. Romance of the Old Three Kingdoms was regarded as one of Maugham's representative works, and its literary value and influence were still recognized today. If you like historical works, then Romance of the Old Three Kingdoms might be more suitable. If you prefer a modern narrative and visual effects, then New Three Kingdoms might be more suitable. No matter which work he chose, it should be decided according to his own preferences and interests.

Is the anime version of the romance of the three kingdoms closer to the original or the old version of the romance of the three kingdoms

1 answer

2024-09-18 06:45

The anime version of Romance of the Three Kingdoms and the old version of Romance of the Three Kingdoms were different in terms of storyline and character creation, but they were both adapted from the classical Chinese novel Romance of the Three Kingdoms. The anime version of Romance of the Three Kingdoms was more compact and vivid in terms of the story. It retained the main plot and character settings of the original work, but also added more original elements. In terms of character creation, the animation version of Romance of the Three Kingdoms was more three-dimensional and full of characters, and the characters were more vivid and closer to the image description in the original work. The old version of Romance of the Three Kingdoms paid more attention to the authenticity and objectiveness of history. The character creation and plot setting were different from the anime version. The old version of Romance of the Three Kingdoms faithfully restored the historical background and characters in the original book, but the plot may not be as compact and vivid as the anime version. The anime version of Romance of the Three Kingdoms and the old version of Romance of the Three Kingdoms each had their own characteristics and advantages. It was impossible to directly compare which was closer to the original.